subscribe: Posts | Comments

Supreme Court overturns non-EU young spouses ban

0 comments

Summary of story from BBCNews, October 12, 2011

British judges have ruled that a UK government ban on non-European Union foreign spouses under the age of 21 coming to Britain is unlawful.

The Supreme Court judges said the law interfered with the human rights of couples, including Article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights – the right to private and family life.

The case was brought by two couples, including Briton Amber Aguilar and her husband, Diego, from Chile.

The couple were under 21 when the rule was introduced – and Diego Aguilar was not permitted to stay with his wife in the UK once his student visa had expired.

Mr and Mrs Aguilar moved first to Chile and then to Ireland to be together, resulting in Mrs Aguilar losing her university place.

“I basically felt like I’d been exiled from my country and in forcing him to leave they’d also forced me to leave,” she said.

The Labour government, in power at the time, introduced the ban – preventing a foreign partner from outside the European Union (EU) from joining their partner if they were under 21 years old – in 2008.

In the Supreme Court, Lord Wilson acknowledged that the law was designed to prevent arranged marriages, but said that the intervention it made into family life did not justify the means.

“The number of forced marriages which it deters is highly debatable,” he said.

“What seems clear is that the number of unforced marriages which it obstructs from their intended development for up to three years vastly exceeds the number of forced marriages which it deters.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *