Tory woman rants about ‘extreme feminist’ agenda
Comment on and summary of story from Yahoo News Oct 11, 2011
Charlotte Vere, the founder of something called “Women On”, and a failed Conservative party candidate at the last UK general election, takes a swipe at deputy leader of the Labour party, Harriet Harman, in this news blog.
She accuses Harman of parading “around Labour party conference dressed in the Empress’ new clothes of righteous and radical feminism and continued to push the message that the coalition government is anti-women”.
In a passage that smacks of paranoia, she asks why Harman and her “sister-in-crime” Yvette Cooper (shadow home secretary and minister for women) “feel emboldened enough to push their pro-women, anti-men agenda with so little opposition?”
She then goes off on a rant about a “women-only” meeting at Labour party conference which included the leader of the party, Ed Miliband.
Apparently, this has “very serious undertones” because it was a meeting where the “attendees are decided by gender”.
Worse still, the event discussed the idea that either the leader or deputy leader of the party should always be a woman. That seemed to push her over the edge into another rant about democracy and quotas.
I just can’t help wondering why she cares so much about what happens at Labour party conference.
Or is it just that it’s much more interesting than what happens at Tory party conference. Just a thought.
















And your rebuttal is … or have you just proved my point?
There is no “extreme feminism” anywhere in British politics. I should know; I’ve been looking for it everywhere.
“A meeting where policy is purportedly set by just one gender? Is that democratic?”
No indeed, Charlotte, but I think you may be missing the wood for the trees. Have a look at the cabinet.
Do women necessarily act in the interests of other women? Are you saying that men can’t act in the best interests of women? And vice versa?
There is only way to appoint people to the cabinet, based on skills and experience. We need to build a critical mass of women with skills and experience but that is a more complex undertaking than imposing arbitrary and unhelpful quotas. The debate has been simplified in extremis and now lacks support from the very women it purports to represent.
How can you expect a prime minister and deputy to appoint on merit or to train up and give experience to a group of people he quite clearly regards with total condescension. His ‘calm down dear’ comment, followed by ribald laughter round the House was the equivalent of him putting on a fake comic Indian voice to put down an Indian or Muslim MP. He can make all the apologies he wants, but we still saw a glimpse of what is behind his public mask. I think Ed Miliband at least understands the dynamics of discrimination and he certainly has a better grasp, in my opinion, than the playground bullies that are currently ruining our economony, democracy and media, of how to put right some of the ethical issues that is ruining this country for the majority that live in it.
So, if you want to conflate under representation of women and muslims, let’s go with that…how many muslim MPs should we have? – shall we have an arbitrary quota? can I convert to Islam in order to get a better chance? or would I not be muslim enough to represent the community? would I fairly represent all muslims anyway? Would anyone? Quotas and positive discrimination are wrong for muslims and wrong for women.
The fact is putting women on a pedestal and assuming that we would do better is idealistic and misguided. We need to remove the barriers to women succeeding rather than, as you have just done, blame everything that is wrong in our country on men! It is not helpful and will serve to increase the divide between men and women and alienate the politically-moderate who don’t see things in such black and white terms.
I didn’t conflate under representation of women and muslims, I was making a point about DC’s mocking of women. The fact that he discriminates against women is the most serious barrier to women succeeding since he sets the culture of those he leads, so I guess I would suggest we get rid of Dave Cameron. I am not blaming everything in the country on men but on chauvinism which stops people selecting from a true meritocracy and uses socially balanced values rather than predominantly male ones of risk and aggression. If you don’t understand what I’m talking about may I suggest reading Masters of Nothing by fellow Conservative MPs Nadhim Zahawi and Matthew Hancock who have amply illustrated why male only economic structures lead to economic disaster such as we are living through now.
“Do women necessarily act in the interests of other women?”
Once again Charlotte, I agree and disagree with you at the same time. You are evidence of the truth of your statement. No, they do not, necessarily.
Theresa May denying that legislation is required to address the nearly 50% of FTSE 250 companies that have no women at all on their boards, that have never had a woman on their boards, is another fine example.
The government is not acting in the interests of women. The government is placing the financial cost of the economic crisis disproportionately on women. You may not have been in meetings where tough decisions are taken, but I have and the people who lose out are the ones who are not in the room. Women are not in the cabinet room.
But you are not worried about women being excluded from government or business or every other avenue of public life. You are worried about women meeting ‘alone’ with the (male) leader of the opposition party. How are these women setting policy exactly? It is depressing that I have to argue how little power women exercise in the Labour Party as if that was a good thing. And there are better uses for the public voice you have been given.
Harriet Harman and Yvette Cooper prove it is not a requirement for success that women ignore the obstacles that block other women, obstacles that they have been talented, determined and, above all, lucky enough to avoid. It wins you friends if you do ignore them though, doesn’t it Charlotte,particularly in the Conservative Party. Are you sure they are laughing with you?
Women like Theresa May and Charlotte Vere provide the same function as Lord Hawhaw did in the war – they are put into place by the predominant power to undermine their own kind and be an easily maleable smokescreen behind which their men can hide.
Oh come on Vicki, what a very odd thing to say. ‘Put into place’? What about the women ‘put into place’ to fill quotas on boards?!
Just a nonsense argument. I sense you feel you are losing.
Yes, Vicki.
See Liz Jones today in the Daily Mail – ‘Why are women so vile to each other?’
Theresa May, you and I all share the same goal – we want women to fulfil their full potential economically, socially, culturally and politically. Theresa May and I go on to agree that mandatory quotas send the wrong message to young women and young men and it should be possible for a natural equilibrium to be achieved by working with men and women rather than pitting one against each other. The latter cannot result in a sustainable solution.
So claiming that I am not worried about the ‘exclusion’ of women is a nonsense. Of course I am worried about it – it is quite ridiculous – but I don’t agree that mandatory quotas are the way forward.
And do I sense just a little condescension at the end of your article? Seems like I have indeed struck a nerve.
“it should be possible for a natural equilibrium to be achieved by working with men and women”
Why should it? It hasn’t yet in human existence. How much longer are you going to advocate doing nothing about this problem you are so worried about?
Men have an overwhelming advantage. They are the incumbents, they have a strangehold on executive positions, boards do what has been done before. They do not change voluntarily. Have you not noticed? Have you not noticed how the business world penalises mothers? And you say equilibrium ‘should’ be possible. I don’t think you believe that. Anyway, it is wrong.
I may be doing you a disservice, Charlotte, I realise I have no idea what you mean by achieving ‘equilibrium’. Did you deliberately choose that word over ‘equality’? I am trying to understand if we do share the same goals.
Charlotte, thanks for checking in with us, but I hardly know where to start to unravel your tangled thoughts. In your first comment, you pose this little teaser – “.. and your rebuttal is ….?” as though you had put forward a philosophical or political point in your original blog post that either could be or was worth rebutting. You had done neither, in my view.
You then ask whether women always act in the best interests of women (that point has already been well answered by Jane Da Vall) and whether men cannot act in the interests of women?
I assume this is in reference to the issue of the dire lack of women in positions of power in this country (and elsewhere in the world) and the struggle by feminists and others (both women and men) to do something about it.
I think you have missed the entire point. The point is not whether men or women can represent each other’s interests (to my mind our political cabal is only interested in representing the interests of the rich and powerful, irrespective of their gender) but it is about whether we live in a democracy that is built on a meritocracy.
To my mind, the answer is clear. To argue otherwise, given the current poor representation of women at the top table, would mean we (and that includes you and I) must be inherently less able than men.
Nor do we need to build “a critical mass of women with skills and experience” because we already exist. There is endless research to show that the problem is not on the supply side, but on the demand side.
Take the example of Norway which introduced a quota system for women on boards a couple of years ago. Up until that point, Norwegian businessmen (and I use that term deliberately) whined that they would appoint women to the board of their company if only they could find some to appoint. Then, miraculously in comes the quota system (introduced by a male Conservative government minister) and what do we find – yes, there were women a-plenty out there. Some have since tried to argue that the women appointed are somehow less able or are token women, but there is absolutely no evidence to that effect.
Given the current talent “slate” on the boards of some of our banks and the decisions taken by many of them in the lead up to the 2008 crash, I hardly think they are in a position to argue that their boards were crammed full of talented people all making sensible decisions in the long-term interests of that corporation.
Quite the contrary.
All the evidence directs us to ask this very serious question – if there are lots of talented women out there, many of them willing and able to get to the top, why are we still so poorly represented in positions of power?
Boards cannot find appropriately qualified female candidates because one of the qualifications they require is that candidates be male.
Not expressly, of course, that would be illegal, by which I mean they would get caught. No, a FTSE 250 board requires that its non-exec directors have CEO or CFO on their CV. There are 4 female CEOs in the FTSE100 and 10 in FTSE 250 companies. There are fewer CFOs. That is the problem and neither the government nor the companies are doing a thing about it.
They will continue to do nothing until Brussels forces their hand, and then there will be wailing from government and the media the like of which we have not seen. So, bring it on.
Charlotte there is nothing odd about saying someone that is appointed to a position by another more senior is put into place. Please stop with the Dave Cameron ‘if I look down my nose and sneer, that will derail your argument’ tactics. There are no quotas in place at the moment and the current situation has not resolved itself in 40 years of so called legal equality. I am using facts here, you are the one that is smokescreening and patronising – stick to facts and it is you that is losing your argument as your position is simply not borne out by reality.