US academic thinks white men can solve black women’s problems
Summary of story from The Economist, October 15, 2011
Stanford law professor Ralph Richard Banks has found himself on the receiving end of harsh criticism following the publication of research on black women and marriage.
Banks first caused controversy in August after describing his work in an article for the Wall Street Journal (see Jezebel story).
His book, entitled ‘Is Marriage for White People? How the African-American Marriage Decline Affects Everyone’, has now been published.
Noting that black women are the ‘most unmarried’ group in the United States, who intermarry least with other races, Banks suggests that black women should look to other ethnic groups for a husband.
According to Banks, there is a crisis in the black ‘relationship market’ because of a ‘man shortage’.
This is due to a lack of eligible or even available men – black men, as a social group, have fallen behind black women in terms of their education and income, while one in ten black men in their early thirties is in prison.
Many black women, says Banks, respond to this problem by ‘marrying down, but not out’. However, this incompatibility leads to a high chance of a marriage failing.
Black men with better educational achievements and income have more options, leading to a reluctance to settle down with one woman.
Banks proposes a solution: black women should learn from the example of black men, and be more open to marrying outside their race. Currently only one in ten black women intermarries, compared to one in five black men.
WVoN comment: In his apparent rush to place the responsibility for black women’s failure on their own shoulders and make them feel guilty for causing a problem that according to his title ‘Affects Everyone’, Banks fails to acknowledge the cultural and social pressures that may be a bigger influence on black women’s unwillingness to marry outside their race.
He also ignores surveys from dating websites that have shown, for whatever reason, that many men are unwilling to go out with a black woman (Ok Cupid).
Crucially, what ever happened to love in Banks’ research? No-one makes a logical decision about who they fall for and it is unrealistic – not to mention unromantic – to expect black women to be more rational and calculating than the rest of us.
Of course, there is always the radical conclusion that women don’t need to be married to be happy.











