Cameron goes a-wooing to capture female hearts
Summary of story from Total Politics, November 24, 2011
British PM David Cameron thinks his best hope for keeping his own job is through winning the hearts and minds of women.
Between now and the election in Spring 2015, he needs to persuade thousands more females to vote Conservative in order to secure a significant Commons majority. He wants women to view him as a modern compassionate person.
According to his advisor Andrew Cooper, men have accepted the ‘logic’ of brutal spending cuts while women remain fearful about how the squeeze will affect their families.
According to this report, many women are feeling ‘guilty’ that they cannot provide for their families and that political leaders don’t speak the language they understand when discussing the economy. Cameron and Chancellor George Osborne are now changing their language to make it more emotional.
However hardline Tories feel this ‘softly, softly’ approach will harm the economy by preventing more unleashing of capitalism.
WVoN comment: This kind of patronising shows exactly why women aren’t falling for Cameron. Good grief, we feel ‘guilty’ about not providing for our families? No, we feel bloody angry. Angry that we work all hours for lower pay than men, angry that SureStart support is being pulled from under our feet, angry that slashing of benefits hit the poorest, we could go on.
Cameron has already shown with his ‘calm down dear’ language that he is an old Tory in disguise. The last thing we need is him and Osborne coming over all emotional to ‘woo’ us.
We can understand you, Dave and George, we know that given a choice you would prefer to ‘boy’ up to the bankers, rather than man up to the genuine concerns of women on human rights, equality, social and economic justice.
















Why not change the tag line – “women’s news and current affairs service” to “partisan prose and anti-Coalition comment”?
Do you realise that you are ‘reporting’ on the words of someone who works in a lobbying firm, a lobbyist, as if they are fact?
The reality is that polling and focus groups have suggested that *in general* women prefer less aggressive language re changes to budgets. Perhaps not all women, not the shouty radical feminists, but the vast majority of women. There is nothing underhand or inappropriate about recognising that and making sure the language used engages this group.
And finally, SureStart – dear oh dear – there are over 3,500 of them. 6 have been closed by local authorities, 1 has been opened and just over 100 have merged to provide better services. ‘Surestart support pulled from under our feet’? Hardly.
Hi Charlotte, thank you for your comment. I am not quite sure why you feel outraged by what you call “partisan prose”. The first part of the blog is clearly a summary of a story from Total Politics, marked up and linked to the original, as we do with all our summaries. After that we have marked up clearly as “WVoN comment” the view of the co-editor who posted the summary.
I think it’s fair to say that all news outlets have their own bias – the Daily Mail, the Sun, the Mirror, the Guardian, the Times are all seen as either left wing or right wing papers and all have “partisan prose” to go along with them, even when reporting so-called news. News can be “spun” in the same way that “facts” can be used in a feature or opinion piece that tie in with the writer’s own viewpoint. They pick out the facts that back up the point they’re trying to make, for obvious reasons.
There is no such thing as a story that is free from bias, as every story is told from the point of view of the person reporting it, however much they try to be “non-partisan”, Nothing wrong with that, of course. We live in a democracy with a free press. At least WVoN makes it clear what is our comment and what is not, unlike much of the reporting (whether in print or online) that we read day in, day out. Even your own website, Charlotte, is not free from bias.
However, we welcome your comments because we enjoy debate and are always pleased when you visit.
My website is not supposed to be free from bias! It doesn’t claim to be ‘news’.
it does say ‘views’ on news, Charlotte. Plus as Alison pointed out, these comments are clearly labelled and distinct from the stories.
And as I tried to explain in my comment, Charlotte, there is no such thing as unbiased news no matter what anyone tries to tell you. News is told through the lens of the person telling the story as a result of which you will always have different takes on the same event. Just consider different reports from different communities in, say, Northern Ireland, Palestine, Iraq etc. Each one tells the story from their own viewpoint. It doesn’t make anyone right or wrong, but we all need to understand that when reading or watching news reports.
I still think it is funny that you are reporting as ‘news’ the opinions of a lobbyist!
And yes, you sound very defensive.
PS: will anyone respond on the SureStart nonsense in the comment?
Hi Charlotte,
We report a wide range of stories relating to women, from straight news reports to comments and opinion pieces. In this case we summarised a story as published in a political magazine, and clearly marked it as such.
As for Sure Start, 124 have closed since the coalition took power, according to this article dated Nov 11th: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2011/nov/14/sure-start-centre-closures-coalition?newsfeed=true
Thanks again for your comments
Quick message for Una – a quote from the piece –
“Of the reduction of 124 children’s centres, six are outright closures; the remainder are accounted for by local re-organisations such as the merger of two or more centres”
A reduction of just over 3% and no evidence of a reduction in services – not exactly “support being pulled from under our feet”. Stop the hyperbole!
There are a lot of women badly affected by these ‘mergers’ Charlotte. We’re happy to provide them with a voice. But debate is welcome, so thanks!
Really? How so? I think it is the anti-cuts folk stirring up a storm where one doesn’t really exist.
Oh, and by the way, children’s centres are for men too – it’s not only about women.
Actually people I’ve spoken to who are affected by the cuts would not consider themselves political, so it’s frustrating when their views are dismissed in this way – it does the coalition no favours. And you’re absolutely right that children’s centres are for dads too, the more the merrier!
Una, we were specifically talking about Sure Start and whether or not there has been a significant change in services provided – I do not believe that there has. The rhetorical has been overwhelming, but the evidence is severely lacking. I am not dismissing anyone’s views, on the cuts or otherwise.
Thank you, Charlotte, for saying what I was too busy seething to say!
If David Cameron really wanted to do something to win back women it would have to include making some real changes to the male culture in this country – block violent internet porn, enforce laws about purchasing trafficked/enslaved women for sex, ensure anti discrimination lawsuits were fairly reported in the press, give fathers equal paternity leave and incentivise them to take it up, ensure the media report rape in a truthful fashion rather than constantly referencing the victim as an ‘alleged’ victim and make sure the courts actually stop treating victims of sexist violence such as rape and DV as the perpetrator of the crime rather than the victim. His ‘calm down dear’ snipe was the equivalent of putting on a pseudo Pakistani voice to address a Muslim MP – it will take alot of concrete contrition on his part through actions rather than words to remove the memory of his smug little smirk to all the other boys in the playground when making that remark alone. It was like a window into his soul – and it wasn’t a pretty sight.