Herman Cain’s Planned Parenthood ‘genocide’ remark inaccurate
Summary of story from The Guardian, November 4, 2011
American Republican presidential hopeful Herman Cain issued a blistering, and factually incorrect, attack on Planned Parenthood on CBS News’s Face the Nation recently, according to, among others, Alexander Sanger.
During that interview, Cain confirmed remarks he made earlier when he said:
“When Margaret Sanger – check my history – started Planned Parenthood, the objective was to put these centers in primarily black communities so they could help kill black babies before they came into the world. It’s not Planned Parenthood, it’s planned genocide.”
Cain’s accusation is not only dangerous, says her grandson Alexander Sanger, it’s inaccurate.
African American leaders, Sanger says, welcomed the women’s health services his grandmother started, as did Republicans.
According to the Guttmacher Institute, he continues, white women account for 36 per cent of abortions compared to 30 per cent of black women and 25 per cent of Latinas.
And sixty-three per cent of abortion clinics are in neighborhoods where more than half the residents are white.
Beyond that, he adds, Planned Parenthoods do much more than provide safe abortion services: they offer contraception, prenatal care, HIV testing and breast and cervical cancer screenings, for a start.
And while it took 30 more years for America to catch up with his grandmother, the goal of securing reproductive healthcare for all was less controversial than it is today, he says.
Back then, Republicans supported voluntary family planning programs as much as Democrats did. Back then, sound public health policies trumped politics when it came to women’s health.
Today, the debate has shifted, and militant conservatives are waging a war on women in an effort to advance politically.
Cain and the other Republican presidential hopefuls now support eliminating federal funding for Planned Parenthood, which provides millions with vital health services, including contraceptives, each year, Sanger points out.
But it doesn’t stop there: House Republicans are attempting to abolish funding for family planning programs throughout the world.
And if Cain’s experience as a businessman has taught him anything, he’d recognise that it’s a simple matter of supply and demand: more than 200 million women around the world want access to family planning, but lack these basic services.
















This is such a baseless article. Regardless of the percentage of white women that get abortions TODAY, or that it was supported by both political parties, googling “origins of planned parenthood” brings up http://www.blackgenocide.org/sanger.html, which quotes Sanger and Co. about the need for way to rein in the minority populations to keep crime rates from climbing.
Cain may not have been wrong, but he was abusing facts to fit his ideology.
Lots of well-respected organisations had dodgy politics to start with and it doesn’t have any bearing on what the organisation does today beyond providing a curious historical footnote.
For instance, SOAS was founded as a training college for colonial administrators, but people don’t raise its history as a reason to disregard the arguments of SOAS academics as ‘secretly imperialist’ now that it’s one of the most radical institutions in the UK.