Home births should be option for low risk pregnancies, report says
Summary of story from The Guardian, November 25, 2011
Women with low-risk pregnancies should have the right to choose where they want to give birth, according to a study of nearly 65,000 births in England.
The research, published in the British Medical Journal, found that, for women who already had a child, giving birth at home or in a midwife-led birth centre was as safe as going into hospital.
However, home births posed a slight risk of extra problems for the babies of first-time mothers.
The study, led by Professor Peter Brocklehurst of the University of Oxford, was set up to answer the fraught question of the relative safety of hospitals, birth centres and the home.
Prof. Brocklehurst and his colleagues in the Birthplace in England Collaborative found that adverse outcomes for the baby – including stillbirth, death soon after birth and oxygen deprivation leading to brain damage – occurred in only 4.3 out of 1000 births, and that there were no significant differences between hospital obstetric units and other settings.
But for babies of first-time mothers born at home, the risk rose to 9.3 per 1000, compared to 5.3 in hospital and 4.5 in a dedicated birth centre.
The reason for the higher risk for at-home first-time mothers is unknown. “We don’t know which aspects of the care or the site contributed to this,” said Brocklehurst.
It could be to do with the sort of women who chose home birth, who tended to be white, slightly older, better educated and live in more affluent areas.
It could also be due to the midwife’s experience, problems in transferring to hospital in an emergency or something else entirely.
More work would be needed to establish what was happening.











