Increasing the diversity of the judiciary sparks debate
Summary of story from The Guardian, November 3, 2011
Lady Hale and Lady Neuberger gave evidence to the UK Lords constitution committee last Wednesday, arguing the case for increasing the diversity of the judiciary but failing to highlight the universality of the issue.
Hale, the only female justice in the history of the supreme court and the law lords, stated that it was a constitutional issue.
Stressing that: “in disputed points you need a diversity of perspectives and life experiences to get the best possible results”, she believes that increasing diversity could change the results of a range of cases.
Both Hale and Neuberger gave examples where the gender of the justice could make a significant difference to the outcome of case, particularly where women are seeking damages for having an “unwanted” child and cases of rape.
While the committee’s discussions drew on provisions of the Equality Act, it did not examine the key underlying issue of equality in its true sense, exposing misguided views over the importance of increasing diversity.
Lady Neuberger offered concrete suggestions as to how this diversity could be increased, suggesting increased mentoring and appraisals of judges of lower courts.
Lady Hale argued that: “fairness and equality are central values of the law, and the courts should reflect this. Everyone should be able to see the courts as their courts, there for all sections of society and not just for some.”











