subscribe: Posts | Comments

Porn and feminism – what’s missing from the debate?

7 comments

Polly Trenow
WVoN co-editor

Journalist Tanya Gold addressed the thorny issue of porn and feminism in Stylist magazine last month, observing that “consensual sex, consensually on camera, for the pleasure of consensual viewers, should be in the same box as all other consensual sex acts”.

In mainstream porn, however, Gold ventures “violent misogyny is everywhere”. Her answer? Feminist porn.

I’ll get back to feminist porn later because what interested me most was not what she wrote as much as the readers’ comments.

Far from the troll-style hate comments you’d expect following an article by a woman (a feminist at that), her respondents identified some of the grey areas in porn that feminist debate may have overlooked.

Take amateur porn, for instance. Damien asked: “Are you completely over-looking that the most popular and fastest-growing style of porn is homemade? It’s two people expressing their own sexual desire however they see fit.”

Damien’s point is a good one – amateur porn is largely absent from discussions about porn and feminism.

This homemade genre appears to offer what mainstream porn lacks: diversity, affection, respect and the odd female orgasm.

Real couples enjoying themselves is a rare thing in mainstream porn but amateur is choc full of it. Equally, though, many of these novice “productions” are inspired by Hollywood and are predominantly from the male point of view.

Whilst female climaxes are more common in amateur footage (and more likely to be real?) there is still an excessive interest in spooge and its place on women’s faces.

Nevertheless it is about time we addressed the potential advantages of amateur porn in these discussions.

Then there’s sado-masochism. Lauren was concerned that Gold’s article suggests that, “women can’t be turned on by sado-masochism” and this seems “pretty anti-feminist, insisting all women want affectionate porn and sex”.

Even if Hollywood style porn is mostly male sexual domination over women, there are plenty of women who find this sexually exciting.

Sex allows us to explore power dynamics that we don’t necessarily want to play out in the rest of our lives. Some men want to be dominated and so do some women, even feminist women. We can’t ignore the fact that what some of us might find ‘degrading’ is a legitimate sexual niche for others.

To tell women they shouldn’t find sexual pleasure in something is pretty anti-feminist. And yet this subject is rarely dealt with by anti-pornography movements.

My own experience and perhaps the experience of other young feminists is eloquently summed up by Responder who posted:

“Until recently I had read more feminist critiques of porn than I had actually seen porn films. When I did, I was pleasantly surprised given that feminism had told me all mainstream porn was violent and disgusting.”

Feminist debate about porn is clearly invaluable and there is no doubt that it is changing our society, often in unpleasant and unsavoury ways.

Does this mean it should be better regulated? Yes, but it doesn’t mean it should be banned.

  1. Some good points Polly; however I find it hard to imagine any kind of porn that is NOT framed by the current male power dynamic. Having said this, if people are truly consenting adults then that is fine.

  2. Thanks for your comments Jane. Do you think any sex exists outside of male power dynamic? If so surely putting it on film doesn’t make it patriarchal?

  3. Hi Polly – I find it hard to believe that any sex (in capitalist societies) exists outside the male power dynamic – how can it when there has never been (film/public) sexual spaces that show females exploring their own sexuality? Even now, the mainstream film industry insists of the ‘woman has orgasm through penile penetration’ trope, which says it all really.

  4. vicki wharton says:

    The male dominant, female submissive dynamic is pushed at girls and boys from 2 years old in Disney and then upwards. Not sure that any of us really know our sexuality since so much of it is a product of our social training. I abhor violent porn and am very worried of the effect on our society that wanking yourself off to violence towards women and children does to the viewer’s psychology … but film of two people making love, or three or whatever I can’t see a problem with – for me it’s the term love that’s most important, rather than making hate, which is what current porn seems to be about.

  5. Thansk for the article, but I don’t believe that feminists who are against the violent porn movement want pronography “banned” as you state in your last sentence. They understand that this is impossible anyway. They just want to see the big players in the porn industry offering up a more wholistic vision of sexuality, and have them more accountable to pornography seeping into popular culture, where it is accessible to young people who are not sexually realised yet…

  6. There is approximately 50 billion tons of literature on the subject of the subject and the presence of a camara and how a mediated media affects our conciusness and blah deh blahs. 50 billion tons of literature written by and for academic types who have the capacity and inclination to engage in intellectual pursuits that are as incomprehensible as they are pointless.

    I only bring this up because, if anyone at any point were to suggest using any of that literature to analyse the impact of “mediating sex”, they would be called a raving lunatic.

    50 billion tons of literature focusing on every aspect of the human life and how the presence of the media and the camara affects us.

    And not a word is ever spoken on how the presence of the media and the camara may affect our sex lives.

    Why on Earth should we accept the presence of a camara while we are having sex? It’s not natural, it’s not even environmentally friendly, and it stinks of “Big Brotherness”.

  7. In regard to the magazine article – Why bother trying to justify consensually produced porn? What is the point? In spending time justifying its place, attention is deflected away from the porn industry – and in time they make use of the rhetoric and apply it to their own marketing. Do we have to focus on difference yet again? It is divisive and works in the favour of big porn business, and does nothing to target nasty, exploitative porn.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *