Tackling young women in gangs and serious youth violence
Harri Sutherland-Kay
WVoN co-editor
Earlier this month, UK Home Secretary Theresa May announced a new strategy on tackling gang and youth violence.
The report, which May states is the first truly cross-governmental approach to tackling gang and youth related violence, was written as part of the government’s response to the UK riots in August.
The recommendations, which run up until April 2014, include establishing an Ending Gang and Youth Violence Team, distributing £10 million worth of funds to areas severely affected by gang and serious youth violence, plans for effective data sharing, new offending behaviour programmes and making more advice available to parents.
But what does it say about gender?
Very little is the answer. There are no more than a few paragraphs on the gendered impact of gangs.
The report does state that:
“In focussing on the male perceptions and male victims of gang violence it can be easy to lose sight of the role that young women and girls may have in gang related activity… [This] shows the often hidden impact of serious youth violence on them.”
Carlene Firmin was a lead researcher of a report on the impact of serious youth and gang violence on women and girls by Race on the Agenda (Rota) published in 2010 (see WVoN story).
Firmin wrote an article for The Guardian soon after May’s report was released, saying:
“With girls seen as a prop rather than as integral to the causes and consequences of youth violence, some professionals and decision makers have focussed activity on males who are perceived as ‘central’ to all solutions…But following […] Theresa May’s strategy […] it is evident that the tide could be changing.”
I have to admit that despite the accumulation of good and important work on girls’ involvement in gangs, I was sceptical when I read May’s report.
This is partly down to the lack of space given to gender, very typical of the vast majority of government proposals.
But it is mainly due to being unable to see how these proposals will be implemented effectively in a time of financial crisis when budgets will be dramatically reduced for the foreseeable future.
Lee Sprake, a youth worker based in Portsmouth, told me that cuts in youth services since the 1980s, police targeting of young people for anti-social behaviour and the criminalisation of youth (of which the London riots – the harbinger of the report – are an excellent example), the rise in youth unemployment, low rates of pay and the growth of insecure part time work have all led to an increase of anger in young people, especially in a time of mass inequality and gross commodification.
Catch 22, a charity that works with young people in 150 towns and cities across the UK, has been involved in various projects about gangs and serious youth violence.
It is also involved in promoting campaigns throughout Europe on the importance of healthy relationships between young people. The aim is to reduce girls’ involvement in gangs.
In a series of recommendations put together in 2009, Catch 22 made the case for gender-specific programmes that would enable services to adapt in order to meet the needs of young women. Part of this should be an emphasis on building relationships rather than establishing rules.
It highlighted the importance of taking family and peer groups into account when looking at young women’s offending behaviour, as well as the benefits of approaches that maximise young people’s self-esteem and sense of worth.
Rosie Chadwick, director of public affairs, policy and innovation at Catch 22, feels that these are incredibly important to consider.
The combination of factors that surround girls in gangs is hugely complex, often including destructive interpersonal relationships in which violence is normalised, poverty and a lack of interest in school.
There is still a lot more work that needs to be done on methods of intervention and pathways out of violence and, as Catch 22’s work states, it is critical that these methods respond to the young women’s personal experiences.
Chadwick notes that while there have been pockets of work done on girls’ involvement in gangs and serious youth violence, May’s proposals have finally brought the subject into the spotlight.
And although there is still a lot more to be done, she says, May’s document is “a small but important step in the right direction”.
As much as May’s report does take some of Rota’s work into account and has, hopefully, begun the move towards gender-specific services for young people in gangs, I remain very critical.
This stems from my own sense of terror at a great many of the policies of the coalition government, the increasing criminalisation of young people and the horrific treatment of young people on political demonstrations and during the riots.
This doesn’t even touch on my concerns about the move to “payment by results” services by the Ministry of Justice, which is reducing the funding and therefore the capacity for women’s organisations that, through their knowledge and expertise, are in a position to develop specialist services for young women.
May’s report, though recommending that specialist services need to be put in place “for girls and young women suffering gang-related sexual exploitation and abuse”, still doesn’t address the intricacies of working with young people in gangs, with gender being more of an added consideration than anything else.
Despite the lack of mainstream media coverage, the involvement of girls and young women in gangs and serious youth violence seems to be a hot topic at the moment.
The Greater London Authority has just commissioned an in-depth research project, which is being undertaken by the research arm of the Women’s Resource Centre.
Before the Rota study there had been almost no gender and class analysis within reports on gang and serious youth violence.
This new project will use this analysis and build on Rota’s work to develop a strategic framework to enable a more coordinated and consistent response to girls involved in gangs.
The only way we’re going to develop effective strategies of working with young women involved in serious youth violence is through research and funding projects that are able to holistically address their needs.
With the current economic priorities being to cut back on the public sector, the voluntary sector and on education, with their criminal justice priorities, especially after the August riots, being to lock people up, I’m not particularly optimistic.
There is a lot more to be done, but I do hope that this new interest in the topic and investment in research means that the tide really could be turning on how we work with young people and gang violence.











