Oxford University students’ ‘freshers fit list’ investigated
Summary of story from the Daily Mail, December 8, 2011
Oxford University is investigating after male students drew up a ‘fit list’ of female freshers and joked about luring them to a party ‘with no witnesses’.
The emails were sent between members of the notorious ‘Honey Badgers’ drinking club at Lady Margaret Hall.
Students are accused of drawing up a ‘fit list’ of female undergraduates to target for sex at the next ‘crew date’ party at the college.
Jesus College Oxford President and head of the drinking club George Barnes emailed members asking for a list of girls to invite.
In the email he suggested members ‘get to know the Freshers [girls] a little better in the coming week or so’.
The emails, which were leaked to student paper Cherwell and photocopied throughout the university, are being investigated by the Dean of Lady Margaret Hall.
Barnes defended his comments, telling the paper: ‘What happened is that at the start of this year, our drinking society thought it might be good fun to crew date some of the freshers, especially as this seems to be a common thing throughout Oxford.’
Oxford University Dean Dr Michael Monoyios said he was ‘investigating the matter thoroughly and fairly.’
















Hmmm, us girls were just as bad when I was a student. There was a tick/asterisk chart, in lieu of the metaphorical bed notches, pinned up in one of the rooms in my hall, which we gleefully filled out and kept our score.
Barnes is at LMH, not at Jesus, as Mail states
Were you just as bad though C’era una volta? Did you make jokes about luring boys to a place with no witnesses so that you could sexually assault them?
I don’t really understand why anyone should be surprised by this tbh. If you have a culture which encourages young men to see women as sex-toys, then the attitude of seeing women as sex toys, is bound to rub off on even very privileged young men with a higher level of education than the average.
please read my post, it clearly was a dry-humoured joke, taken out of context. This guy in question has a very longterm girlfriend, despite that shes not even in Oxford he’s totally dedicated. Don’t judge these students, please just read my post. x
Oh yes of course, a dry-humoured joke about rape. Because rape’s hilarious and so uncommon, isn’t it, that scenario, of younger less experienced girl being lured to place where she can be raped or assaulted without witnesses and then not bother to report it because no-one would believe her.
Thing is, 1 in 4 women are raped or sexually assaulted in their lives, and most of these assaults are by people who know them – so this sort of rape is very common, rapists get away with it because between 60% and 90% of rapes aren’t reported and of those that are, only 6% end in a guilty conviction because the rape myth says that rapists are monsters in dark alleys, not blokes who have a bit of a drink with someone and then take her somewhere with no witnesses…
This has made me so angry, im a friend of someone at this college (president of LMH btw, NOT jesus, maybe get your facts right before you post the general nonsense that everywhere is publishing about this), i’ve also met a majority of these guys in question.
Ive seen the email, which im pretty sure you haven’t, nor has any of the press who’ve bothered to cover this story.
If you note, the comments that are quoted don’t seem to be anything about how ‘fit’ the girls are, simply their personality.
The comment about taking the girl out- CLEARLY A JOKE?! Its people just trying to think the worst of someone else who are makeing this comment more far-fetched than it is.
Haven’t we all made comments about the fitness of guys before anyhow? Our views simply aren’t hacked, which is what happened, by someone that hated Barnes, printed hundreds of copies, and placed them in every single pigeonhole of the colleges members, then sent it off to a very untrustworthy paper.
This whole fuss is a personal vendetta gone too far, and potentially ruins these students careers. These guys are in NO way sexist, they are decent, typical sarcastic, dry-humoured, banterous men, who really are the victims of illegal hacking in to private messages and distributing information that was in no way theirs to share.
Im sickened by the behaviour of the culprets, i fully support Georege Barnes and the rest of the group, i hope after this more factualand contextual account of what has happened, unveils the reality of what has happened. I only hope that these lovely people will not be affected in the long-term, as already great stress has been thrust upon them.
Now, how about we worry about real problems in this world, not oxbridge bashing.
I think it was the ‘party with no witnesses’ that has got people up in arms. Is that bit made up by the Mail then?
its one of those comments taken out of context, as papers normally do, it’s a typical lad kinda joke, this guy has a serious, longterm girlfriend. I don’t think he would be that much of an idiot to practically suggest raping a girl on an email of several people.
Surely everyones said things they later regret, as comments get overheard/passed along and totally misunderstood, so eventually someone claims you said something, when actually you meant nothing like what they assume you to have said?
Like i said, people have got to learn to develop a decent contextulised basis before having the audacity to make judgements.
Thankyou for taking the time to read my comment Vicki, whatever the resultant judgment it leaves you with!
What I was asking L is is the party without witnesses bit made up or is it fact, whatever the context. Currently we are facing an epidemic of rape and sexual assault by men on women and girls with 1 in 3 girls the victim of sexist violence in a relationship. This is as a result of a generation of boys that have grown up with rape is a joking matter or entertainment on porn sites. The fact that you describe his comment as a typical lad kinda joke shows just how far young men have drifted from what would be regarded as decent human regard for other members of the human race. Young men dress up in Nazi uniforms at parties like Prince Harry, as if 6 million Jews didn’t die in the Holocaust, young men make racist jokes as if racial discrimination doesn’t exist, and make sexist jokes as if 100 women a year aren’t killed by sexist partners plus a whole lot more by strangers. Laddism allows men to behave as if they have the right to scorn another’s discrimination from their position of priveledge without consequence. I can’t do much about their attitude apart from from point out the humanitarian flaws in it, but don’t expect anyone who’s been raped or sexually assaulted to treat your friend as if he’s a likeable rogue – he’s not. He’s a nasty individual making out that rape is a bit of a wheeze – try telling that to the parents of the numerous rape victims who commit suicide after an attack.
ok; lets go and ruin the lives of every single guy that has made a rape based joke, im sorry but it’s ridiculous to get so hyped up on one person, it’s the whole country that makes these jokes and a very minute percentage have ever done something abusive.
Also, again about contextualising, the joke wasn’t in reference to a sexual attack, it was a joke about how a majority of the college were annoyed with her beccause she ruined an event.
I think your friends need to understand that their joke was about a party with no witnesses – a reference to rape. It is not a minute percentage of guys that rape, currently 60% of guys would be happy to conduct themselves in a way that would result in a rape taking place (The Havens survey 2011) and 85% would continue having sex with a girl that was crying and distressed, that is not a minority … and 1 in 3 girls report having been abused by a partner or ex … not a minute percentage either.
L I find it quite sad and disturbing that you seem to think that everyoen in the country makes jokes about rape. Um, IME, decent people DON’T make jokes about rape, misogynists do.
1 in 9 women get raped. Most of them don’t report it because we live in a rape culture which says that rapists are monsters in dark alleys, when in fact, they are ordinary men with an extraordinary sense of entitlement. So their victims know they won’t be believed and indeed they are not, only 6% of reported rapes end in a conviction for the rapist, even though only about 2-4% of rape allegations are false.
The results of rape can be shattering for some victims, leading to trust issues, relationship problems, sexual problems, denial, etc., sometimes for years. To talk about ruining a young man’s life for making a joke about rape, when in fact his life will not be ruined but for thousands of women, their lives actually ARE ruined for a while, by actual rape, is ever so slightly inappropriate. Your friend and his jokes are part of the problem; the minimisation, denial and joking about rape, are part of rape culture. Rape culture is what enables rapists to rape women and get away with it; most rapists are never reported to the police and rape women again and again and of those who are reported, most of them walk free.
My question to you, is this: do you want to help those rapists, or do you want to help their victims? I don’t say this to attack you, I get that you are sticking up for your friend and that is a laudable thing to do; but I do want you to educate yourself about rape so that you can understand why this comment by your friend is so wrong and to decide whether you want to be part of the problem or part of the solution. If you’re going to be part of the problem, then it’s better that you make an informed choice to be so, rather than it just being a default as it is for most people. It is of course your choice and I wish you a Happy New Year whichever way you go.
L: I find your comments quite astonishing given that you have obviously not been raped and therefore are advocating for rape jokes from a position of having absolutely no idea what you are talking about. Search the web for rape survivor stories, read them, and then consider whether a single person who has been raped would find a joke about rape funny. Try and develop some empathy for people who have experiences beyond yours and then – I dunno – consider their feelings?
One further thing to ask L – do you have a name by the way that you are happy to attribute these comments to? Which joke are you now refering to? The people on here and the Mail were shocked at the ‘party without witnesses’ statement, you reply with saying a joke was made about the majority of the college being annoyed with a girl that ruined an event … what event was ruined by this random girl’s behaviour which has not even been mentioned in any reports?! Or is there more behind this story than you are admitting?! Also, speaking as someone who has been raped twice, once by 4 strangers at a party when I was 14 and once by a work colleague when I was 15, I would remind you of an old adage – many a truth said in jest …
Im not being insensitive to people that have been raped? I’m not suggesting they should have to deal with these jokes.
The reason the true context to the joke has not been reported is because it makes a less interesting story, clearly.
This girl was a fresher, she had been incredibley rude toward many members of college. And no, this isn’t me saying that she would deserve to be raped, it is the guy in question implying he wants to tell this girl what everyone thinks of her, yes it’s bitchy and cruel. But NOT a rape statement. And this is in reference to the party with no witness’ statement; This was the basis of the joke, nothing sexually abusive.
I am not going to be forced into giving my name because i promised my own friends i would let this story go, but i can’t face up to the fact that people are being so determined to critiscise someone for one comment. ONE comment. I’ve never in my life heard him say any sexually abusive joke. Ever.
Also, you know nothing about my life. I myself, have been victim to some quite horrible instances that i don’t want to write on the internet. They are not as severe as yours, but they were horrible, and changed my way of thinking greatly.
I agree, you should make an informed choice before you make a decision; i therefore think it is necessary for you all to possibly meet the people behind this story then. Ive met rape victims, i know you seem to think i am a total innocent being in the world, that has no awareness to others pain, but i really do.
I may not be well educated in the facts and figures, and obviously the figures would support your argument more than mine. But i am well educated in the pain of abusive men, okay, so please don’t try to make me feel guilty, or make out that i don’t understand. To an extent i can reason with the anger, but i also have the ability to see the other side, the fact that not every guy is abusive. I’m also lucky in the fact that i know the truth behind these emails. I don’t think anything i say will satisfy you. Just don’t insult me as an immature girl.
L: we are not trying to insult you. We are just trying to get across that the ‘luring them to a party ‘with no witnesses’ statement is a incite to rape and this is simply unacceptable language to use. This language is the result of a wider culture of sexual violence against women all over the world and it needs challenging every time it is used. This doesn’t mean that the guy that made the comment is an abuser – it means that because sexual violence against women is accepted in our society he felt comfortable making this comment. That is our point.