subscribe: Posts | Comments

‘Lads mags’ may legitimise hostile sexism

12 comments

Summary from Middlesex University, December 7, 2011

‘”Soft porn” magazines could be legitimising hostile sexist attitudes, according to new research.

Psychologists from Middlesex University and the University of Surrey found that most of the people they surveyed were not able to tell apart descriptions of women taken from ‘lads’ magazines, and comments about women made by convicted rapists.

The research, due to be published in the British Journal of Psychology, also revealed that most men who took part identified themselves more with the language expressed by the convicted rapists.

Dr Miranda Horvath and Dr Peter Hegarty argue that lads’ magazines could normalise hostile sexism, by making it seem more acceptable when its source is a popular magazine.

Horvath, lead researcher from Middlesex University, said: “….we are concerned that the legitimisation strategies that rapists deploy when they talk about women are more familiar to these young men than we had anticipated.”

Due to  concerns about their content, from February this year many major supermarket chains and petrol stations in the United Kingdom agreed to place lads’ magazines on the top shelf, out of the eye line of children and some have installed modesty boards to hide front cover images.

Yet according to Hovarth: “A lot of debate around the regulation of lads’ mags has been to do with how they affect children but less has been said about the influence they have on their intended audience of young men and the women with whom those men socialise.

“These magazines support the legitimisation of sexist attitudes and behaviours and need to be more responsible about their portrayal of women, both in words and images.

“They give the appearance that sexism is acceptable and normal – when really it should be rejected and challenged. Rapists try to justify their actions, suggesting that women lead men on, or want sex even when they say no.

“There is clearly something wrong when people feel the sort of language used in a lads’ mag could have come from a convicted rapist.”

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I bet this piece of research receives zero coverage in the media.

    • From the article “rank the quotes on how derogatory they were, and to try to identify the source of the quotes” – the work doesn’t seem to actually look at whether people actually agree with these comments but rather takes quotes out of context and asks you to rank them in order of badness. Without seeing the whole paper and their actual methodology this looks like hocum.

      It is easy to find quotes that are easy to misunderstand or attribute out of context. So really, context matters.

      • vicki wharton says:

        I think what the researchers are pointing out is that one of the media’s roles is as an educator (whether they recognise this role or not) and most of the message content/context within lads mags is pretty consistent with a rapists eyeview of the world. She’s gagging for it as she’s had a lot to drink, she’s gagging for it as she’s wearing a short skirt, she’s gagging for it as she’s let me dance with her etc etc etc. In the same way that paedophiles view children’s behaviour through a sexualised lense of their own making, so do rapists. What this research is showing is where that lense is learnt by young men.

        • I understand where you are coming from and where the research is coming from Vicki however the context matters. While the message may be similar the context does make all the difference. Take Call of Duty – without context it suggests killing people, in context it is both a game and the other side is generally trying to kill you as well. Most non-young-children are capable of discerning fiction from reality so context is important to this kind of research.

          • vicki wharton says:

            The context of how lads mags portray women and girls is aggressively sexist, disguised as ‘irony’. Violence towards girls and women is presented as ‘funny’ but if you call these hypocrits out on their bigotry they then go all coy and accuse women of not having a sense of humour. Same with that other popular men’s media pornography. Men make much of the fact that anything done on camera is done with consent – but turn away from the fact that the average age of girls entering pornography, like prostitution is 13, way below the age of consent. Once in the business they are then subjected to violent sexual acts which are not acted, they are done – in real life – and presented as enjoyable for women – being spat on, spunked on, hit and sworn at. The fact that 1 in 3 girls and women are subjected to sexist violence with young girls under 18 the most abused group suggests to me that an awful lot of non young children are not able to differentiate or work out what is abusive behaviour when it is portrayed by the men’s media as irony.

          • Vicki, do you have any sources for mainstream media pornography starring anyone under the age of 18 (in the US or UK, or appropriate age in the country of origin)? Now I will admit to not being well versed in pornography but from what I am aware the content generally has a reference at the start to the records of age and declaration of consent, most of it generally has an interview at the end with the participants as well for harder stuff as well to show that it was roleplay and not reality.

            Some of the things you list can be enjoyable, I’m sure there is a whole BDSM community in arms at the idea that hitting and swearing are categorically not enjoyable. Even spitting and spunking on have people who enjoy them. If it is happening non-consensually, or non-consensually-non-consensually then it is a problem but if it is being done consensually or consensually-non-consensually then we should accept and allow it.

            1 in 3 girls under 18 being subject to sexist violence, I don’t have figures for however given what we class now adays as sexist violence it wouldn’t surprise me. By today’s standards there was a girl at my primary school who sexually assaulted at least 100 boys.

            Why are under 18 year olds having access to pornographic material? If they are and it is causing a problem this suggests two or more independent failures in the media distribution (someone is selling pornographic content to minors), failure in the parents (to discuss the difference between reality and fantasy, to set an example), and likely numerous other failures. While the magazine has some responsibility if it is targeted at 18+ then there is little else they can do if they want to maintain their content.

          • vicki wharton says:

            Re underage porn stars try Sam Fox in the Sun, Sun wrote to her school to get her parents details in order to write to them to get permission to shoot her naked, another girl I worked with was shot at age 13 for News of the World. For sources if you look at Gail Dines book Pornland there are references in there as to ages of girls first being entered into pornography, as well as stats on sex slavery/trafficking for the sex industry on various UN/WHO and Anti Trafficking Coalition. Women’s Resource Centre references 75% of prostitutes are first entered into the trade under the age of 16. There is no age limit on selling pornography to children in national supermarkets and Zoo and Nuts magazines are aimed at below 18+ as their content and editorial stance clearly illustrate although I am sure they wouldn’t put that on their media pack. Most porn is now accessed through the internet where there is no age limit apart from a self policing notice and the average age of boys first accessing porn is 7 years old. Whilst some people may enjoy being beaten, spanked, spunked on or semi asphixiated, enjoying these practices are normally the result of abuse and grooming in childhood to accept these practices and to promote them on porn websites as mainstream and desirable leads to coercive behaviour on behalf of would be perpetrators to push these boundaries onto their regular partners. If you want sources for this check out mumsnet and netmums domestic violence chat rooms to see evidence of rape, strangulation and anal sex without consent.

          • Is there a reference to the Sam Fox thing? As far as I can see she was topless modelling at 16 which was legal at the time.

            Are these numbers for the UK though? The way you mention them it sounds a lot more like a world wide study than one that links it to the UK which is where the issue with nuts / zoo appears to be. Their official market is 18+, that they are sold to under 18s is a different issue again, that is one to take up with the sellers.

            Internet pornography being accessed by children – why are they having unsupervised access to the Internet if that is an issue? It’s easy enough to set up a walled garden for them if you don’t want them accessing everything. Or perhaps we need to open this up and let people actually see what options there are for their sexuality rather than being heteronormative and kinknegative.

            Evidence that it is abuse? My GF likes both inflicting and receiving most of the things you listed and has not been abused or groomed (and trust me it wasn’t my suggestion). People ‘pushing’ things on their regular partners sounds rather lacking in ominous tone. What is being pushed, if there is consent then we have to treat it as acceptable, if there is acceptance when someone turns down the suggestion then again it has to be acceptable. Just because some people are in something because of abuse or force doesn’t mean that others don’t want to be in that situation voluntarily.

          • Jane Da Vall says:

            Context CAN make all the difference, but why do you assume it must? Usually, the strict meaning of a word or phrase works quite well, or it would not be the strict meaning.

            Context can put a different meaning on words, but you seem to be assuming it always does, and arguing the value of this research without even having read it. Why?

          • I’ve read the quotes they used and got them all right and their methodology seems lacking so I question it. Science says sceptical till evidence says otherwise and they don’t appear to have much evidence.

            As for words I’m sure we can’t just use there strict meanings, I’m sure I can think of words beginning with most letters of the alphabet that feminists would object to me using the dictionary definition of.

          • vicki wharton says:

            I get the feeling that whatever figures I quote you will say they are either outside of the UK and therefore not applicable to the UK, or applicable to the UK and therefore not consistent with a world wide problem. When girls and women in porn are being double penetrated they are not role playing, they ARE actually being double penetrated, the acting part is in the perception of pleasure. Sam Fox writes about The Sun approaching her parents in her memoirs and did her first photo shoot topless aged 14. The business of setting up parental controls is not so easily achieved – I have put on parental controls on my daughter’s part of the computer as she is five, type in sex on Google on her account and the first site that comes up offers anal and rape videos. I would argue that magazines that treat attacking other people sexually as being a joke should be reviewing their content – in whatever context – since sexist violence is something 1 in 3 women in the UK and also world wide contend with on a daily basis, so clearly a great number of men do not understand the difference between fantasy and reality – or maybe it would be truer to say that if you secretly dream of hitting your girlfriend to stop her disagreeing with your wishes and feed these fantasies with a two hour hit of violent internet porn, then sooner or later you tend to be in danger of your dreams becoming yours and her reality. That’s how advertising and the media works. Of course, that’s my opinion, but its also backed up by 25 years in the PR industry using that exact same media to change people’s attitudes on drink driving, safe sex and smoking which I tracked via numerous statistical samples on behalf of clients to test the efficacy of media messages on people’s behaviour.

  2. The campaigners Object and other organisations that lobby for a ban on lad’s mags have long pointed out that these publications provide a conducive context for men’s derogatory and misogynist attitudes and actions towards women and girls.

    As Vicki points out, as a section of the print media, these magazines are unfortunately educative and play a role in shaping young men’s attitudes and behaviour towards women and girls.

    Given that reported levels of sexual violence are increasing, and that many girls report sexual harassment including unwanted touching in schools, the findings of this research should come as no suprise.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *