US Catholic leadership out of step with public on birth control
Summary of story from The Atlantic, December 9, 2011
While the Vatican has spoken out about the morality of the vastly unequal global financial system, the US Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) seems to be focusing on the issue of birth control.
The Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace called last month for international standards and safeguards to prevent worsening inequalities in the world’s concentration of wealth.
However, despite the fact that millions of Americans are struggling to stay afloat in the current financial crisis, the bishops have not joined the Vatican in their concerns.
Instead, the USCCB is consumed by the issue of birth control.
The bishops’ leadership is unhappy with a new national policy which categorises contraception as preventative health care, requiring health insurance plans to cover it in full. The policy, to be implemented next August, would widen women’s access to birth control.
However, despite the fact that 98 per cent of sexually active Catholic women use birth control, the USCCB is working with Republicans in Congress to undermine the new policy.
In the US, employers are required to provide health insurance plans for their employees. When the new policy was adopted, an exception was made for religious employers, exempting them from the requirement to include birth control in the health insurance provided for their employees, on the basis of religious freedom.
The USCCB wants this exemption expanded to cover not only religious employers, but any employers affiliated with religious organisations.
Such an expansion would do nothing to better ensure religious freedom, but would deny a benefit to thousands of workers, both Catholic and non-religious, who are entitled to it.
The new policy would dramatically expand access to birth control, but would not require anyone to use it: the one per cent of American women who never use contraception would be free to continue avoiding it. However, an expansion of the current exemption would deprive many of access to a vital health care service.
The USCCB’s campaign is an indication of how out of step the bishops are with ordinary Catholics. The Catholic church, which does not sanction contraception, refuses to bend on the issue because senior clerics feel such a change would undermine the Church’s authority.
However, the fact that the USCCB needs to lobby Congress to influence Catholics’ behaviour is itself a statement of how much the Church’s authority has declined.
This decline can be attributed to the Church’s disdainful treatment of its faithful, and particularly of women, in denying them the freedom of conscience to make their own decision on the personal issue of birth control.











