Underage models spark debate
Rachel Ogbu
WVoN co-editor
Designer Marc Jacobs has sparked an ethical debate after allegedly using two models aged 14 in his autumn/winter 2012 catwalk show.
The move goes against health guidelines by the Council of Fashion Designers of America (CFDA) which say girls under 16 should not be used for runway shows.
The guidelines also include recommendations to supply healthy food backstage and educate the industry about the early signs of eating disorder.
Jacobs’ action immediately sparked outrage from fashion stakeholders who condemned the famous designer over the issue.
As Felicity Hannah said on Yahoo Lifestyle: “for every child you see on the catwalk, there are thousands battling feelings of failure and rejection. That’s why I’d like to see them banned from runway shows.”
Underage models are banned from catwalks at the UK’s London Fashion Week.
The British Fashion Council makes designers sign a contract that prohibits them from using models under 16, due to concerns that young teens were more at risk of developing eating disorders.
However, other fashion hubs have been less willing to restrict their designers in this way, so young teenage girls continue to strut down catwalks, pouting provocatively for the cameras.
Marc Jacobs hired the two models, Thairine Garcia and Ondria Hardin, from the Ford Models Agency.
The agency said that while they agree with much of the CFDA health initiative, the company had not actually signed up to the specific proposal restricting the age of models in runway shows.
However Ford was one of around a dozen agencies listed in an earlier press release from the CFDA as having “pledged that they will not send out models under the age of 16 for shows.”
Marc Jacobs defended his use of the models, telling Vogue:
“I do the show the way I think it should be and not the way somebody tells me it should be. If their parents are willing to let them do a show, I don’t see any reason that it should be me who tells them that they can’t.
“There are children actors and children models for catalogues and stuff, so I guess if a parent thinks it’s ok and a kid wants to do it, it’s fine,” he told the New York Times.
Also lending her voice to the debate is young model, Coco Rocha. Of her own experience in the industry, which she talked about with Anderson Cooper recently, she said:
“I was scouted at 14 and I started at 15, and I know for a fact that I wish I was a little older, wiser. And who’s to say that 16 is wiser? But it’s sure better than 14.”
Speaking to fashionista, Rocha says a lot of girls are told to lie about their age: “It’s sad, because why must you? If you were under the age of 16, why not just grow into being a model? You don’t have to do it.
“The CFDA isn’t hurting or hindering the idea of models, they’re just trying to improve models and give them a little more confidence, to be a little more savvy in this industry.”
The CFDA initiative is only guidelines, and not in any way mandatory – although a good number of fashion stakeholders hope designers will follow them.

















As always there are a lot of different angles to this. First of all, parents. How can a responsible parent allow his/her daughter to participate in this industry. Then, the fashion designer. Honestly? This calls for a boycott, if Mr. Jacobs can’t flog his stuff, he will be gone pretty quickly. So ladies, next time you feel compelled to by fashion, remember that the, mostly male, designers convey a female body image that is way beyond reality and buying their stuff makes you part of story. Lastly, body image. How can a 14 year old model grown-up fashion, she has neither the body nor the mind of a grown woman. What does this tell us about the role models those misogynous peddlers are trying to sell us?