It’s every man for himself when the ship sinks
It seems that it is every man for himself when it comes to escaping a sinking ship, with women having less chance of survival than men.
The ‘women and children first’ rule is a myth according to research, released to coincide with the centenary of the Titanic sinking.
In fact on the few occasions when the myth became reality, it was more often ‘ladies first’ with the lower class women left to fend for themselves in the hull of a stricken vessel.
Swedish researchers Mikeal Elinder and Oscar Erixon, authors of “Every man for himself — Gender, Norms and Survival in Maritime Disasters”, told AFP news that out of 15,141 people who were on board 18 ships they studied, twice as many men survived as women – 17.8 per cent compared to 34.5 per cent of men.
The Titanic and the wrecking of the British ship Birkenhead off the coast of Cape Town in 1852 are the exceptions when women and children went first, but this was down to the captains who banned the men from jumping in to the lifeboats.
Nearly 1,500 passengers were killed when the Titanic sank but just 26.7 per cent of the women on board perished and 50 per cent of children, while about 80 per cent of the men died.
The researchers wrote: “His [the captain’s] policy, rather than the moral sentiments of men, determines if women are given preferential treatment in shipwrecks. This suggests an important role for leaders in disasters.”
It was one which the captain of the Costa Concordia which went down in January this year off the coast of Italian island of Giglio seems not to have adopted.
Francesco Schettino is currently being investigated for manslaughter and accused of abandoning ship before everyone on board could be evacuated. Of the 33 dead or missing just under half were women, and most were passengers rather than crew.
Erixon and Elinder said they were shocked when they studied the Estonia passenger ferry disaster which sank in the Baltic Sea in 1994. A total of 852 of the 989 people onboard perished, with only 5.4 percent of women surviving, compared to 22 percent for men.
Overall the academics found women fared worse on ships sailing under British flags than other nationalities.
Erixon said: “That fact sort of busts the myth about the British gentleman.”
Lucy Delap, fellow and director of studies in history at the University of Cambridge, told Discovery News: “Women and children first was a very patchy, uneven goal in 19th and 20th century shipwrecks. It had strong class, nationality and ethnicity elements, which meant that ‘ladies first’ was more often practised,” she said.
Delap, who was not involved in the Swedish research, said that people of low economic class weren’t divided into men and women, and were generally regarded as “the mob” at the bottom of the ship.
Captain Christer Lindvall, president of the International Federation of Shipmasters’ Associations, told CBC News that the fact that men more often survive is down to training and experience and not because they abandoned passengers. He added that there is no rule to say that women and children should go first.
The research has re-ignited the debate in the media about whether it is right that women and children should have preferential treatment. When the Titanic went down suffragettes made the point that the rule made women out as vulnerable with no self-determination reports The National Post.
Peter Glick, a professor of psychology at Lawrence University in Wisconsin has researched ‘benevolent sexism’ and says there is still a belief that men should be the heroes.
He is quoted by the National Post saying: “During the time of the Titanic, there probably was a lot more pressure on men to say ‘Well, of course not, you have to defer to the women and children being saved first otherwise you’re a coward,’ whereas today we have a lot more questions like ‘If women are men’s equals, what does that mean? Should they still be the protected sex?’
“I think we’re uncomfortable, at some level, with completely giving that up.”

















Having equal rights doesn’t make women and children equal in strength to men. Aid agencies in Darfur have had to instigate a ticketing system where women and children are given tickets to get food rations otherwise men just push to the front of the queue. Taken to its ultimate conclusion, only men would survive in the ultimate disaster. Think an orderly queue in a crisis is a bit much to ask, but some type of social mechanism such as women and children first at least gives the physically weakest a fighting chance of surviving disasters.