subscribe: Posts | Comments

Catholic institutions sue Obama administration over contraception mandate

0 comments

Polly Trenow
WVoN co-editor 

Last week, a dozen Catholic institutions filed a federal lawsuit against the Obama administration.

The plaintiffs, including The Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Washington and The Catholic University of America, are fighting a mandate that would require them to cover contraception in their employee health insurance.

Although other religious groups filed lawsuits earlier in the year, last Monday’s action was only by Catholic groups and included Washington’s own Bishop.

Forty-two separate Catholic institutions, including the University of Notre Dame and 13 dioceses, filed 12 separate lawsuits.

The institutions accuse the US Department of Health and Human Services of violating the First Amendment, which protects freedom of religion.

In a statement made by the Archdiocese of Washington, Cardinal Donald Wuerl said the mandate required Catholic institutions to pay for medicines and procedures that “violate their religious beliefs.”

Last August, as part of Obama’s ‘Affordable Care Act,’ all health insurance was required to include birth control for women.

After an outcry from religious groups, the mandate was amended to allow religious organisations to apply for an exemption if their purpose is to spread religious belief, and if they primarily employ people of the same faith.

Another amendment ensures religious organisations would not have to pay anything towards contraception as these costs would be covered by the insurers.

But many institutions such as the University of Notre Dame may not receive such an exemption.

Father Jenkins of the University said:

“A narrow exemption was given to religious institutions that serve and employ primarily members of their own faith, but, departing from a long tradition in federal law, organizations like Notre Dame—schools, universities, hospitals and charitable organizations that serve and employ people of all faiths and none—were granted no exemption, but instead were made subject to the law to the same extent as any secular organization.”

He also stated that the lawsuit was “not about preventing women from having access to contraception, nor even about preventing the Government from providing such services.”

Experts have claimed there is nothing unconstitutional about the law which requires Catholic employers to adhere to the same laws as all other employers.

Similar lawsuits have already been rejected in New York and California.

The New York Court of Appeals ruled that “[t]he employment relationship is a frequent subject of legislation, and when a religious organization chooses to hire nonbelievers it must, at least to some degree, be prepared to accept neutral regulations imposed to protect those employees’ legitimate interests in doing what their own beliefs permit.”

The California court ruled years ago that any exemption for religious groups “sacrifices the affected women’s interest in receiving equitable treatment with respect to health benefits.”

The Obama administration is reported to have asked the lawsuits to be dismissed. They claim that given the mandate will not come into effect until August the lawsuits are premature.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *