Mirror-fasting: the ugly face of obsession
Women, take down your mirrors! And stop being vain by looking at yourself so much.
You are so self-obsessed that you can’t pass your reflection without, well, reflecting on it. Who do you think you are anyway?
Since the summer news outlets have been trying to convince us there is a growing trend called mirror-fasting. It started in the US, travelled to Britain and this weekend reached Australia or at least it did in the media’s imagination.
Mirror-fasting is when women (not men) take a break from looking in the mirror, in order to rid themselves of their self-obsession, apparently.
This is the more self-conscious cousin of the old game of daring TO GO OUT WITHOUT WEARING MAKE-UP. (see the Mail on a daily basis but here’s one example to be going on with).
Women are now being told that it is good for their self-esteem to cover over mirrors and not look in them for a month – all in order to stop worrying about their looks.
Apparently, nine in ten women over 40 have the condition of mirror-angst reports The Mirror (somewhat ironically) – although my GP friend says she has never heard of it.
So the paper asked writer Sally Windsor “a self-confessed vain mum-of-one” to spend a week avoiding mirrors, windows and her mobile phone.
She claimed that the pressure of living in Crawley, a town near Gatwick airport, which is popular with air hostesses had led her to slap on the fake tan, and Shellac nails, just to keep up with the cabin crew set on their school run.
However, after covering her mirrors with paper and drawing a smiley face on her make-up mirror and ‘only’ wearing mascara and moisturiser, she became liberated.
“The key to feeling good about yourself is to spend less time looking for imperfections. If you can’t look in the mirror and see only good things, then try to look at yourself less,” she reasoned.
This clearly makes as little sense as my reasoning that if I don’t look at my bank statement somehow the truth of my finances won’t be as bad I fear it might be.
This avoidance just results in getting more depressed and paranoid. Something which a psychologist in the Mail (of all places) points out in their mirror-fasting feature.
Dr Phillippa Diedrichs, of the Centre for Appearance Research in Bristol, said ‘mirror-fasting’ was another way of obsessing about appearance. She added: ‘When working with people who have issues around body image we encourage the “mirror exposure technique” – to look in the mirror and take a less critical approach.”
Mirror-fasting all started with New York beauty writer Autumn Whitefield-Madrano, who went a month without mirrors and wrote about it on her blog the beheld. This is a more intelligent, interesting analysis than the watered-down version that the tabloids are pumping out. Whitefield-Madrano argues that surveillance is “an effort to carefully control our ideas about ourselves”.
She said that she was exhausted from appearing to be interested, appearing to be womanly, appearing to be professional, appearing to be pretty.
After a month without mirrors, Whitefield-Madrano concludes, among other things, that she can never become an objective viewer of herself, but can better recognise the differences between herself and her image.
So the media has distorted Madrano’s intentions to highlight once again the obsession of women having to look good (don’t men pose in front of mirrors too, certainly the ones at the gym do. Don’t alpha to zeta males worry about how they look on a night out and practice their outfits, style their hair, and raise their eyebrows to their reflection? Of course they do.)
Jezebel highlighted the panic that mirror-fasting has caused among the American broadcast media, who it reports seem appalled that women could give up mirrors. NBC’s chief medical editor Nancy Snyderman went into panic overdrive saying; “How we present ourselves opens up doors for job interviews and dating.”
Jezebel asks: “Is it that they are in such an image-driven industry that they cannot fathom not caring about your appearance? Or, more cynically, could it be that much of the money that they bring in through advertising is tied up in products meant to keep women concerned with their appearance?”
Mirror-fasting throws up a number of issues, but what is being reported is the superficial and the gloss, and no-one has really attempted to get under the skin of what Whitefield-Madrano was trying to do and whether her conclusions stand up to close scrutiny.
As columnist Mary-ann Seighart said, she would rather deal with the causes of insecurity than “the symptom of looking in the mirror.”











