War casualty recording proven possible
A new study may help war widows and orphans with closure – and with compensation claims.
The Oxford Research Group (ORG) has recently completed a two-year study into casualty recording practice worldwide.
In what is believed to be the largest ever study of casualty recording practice, the ORG found that violent deaths in conflict can be recorded.
The Geneva Convention of 1949, places on parties in international armed conflict a strict legal obligation to record details of the captured, dead, wounded and missing in conflict.
However, these obligations are only defined comprehensively and in binding fashion for individuals who are members of the official military forces of the parties involved.
Both the US military and the British Foreign Office, it seems, thought counting casualties in the 21st century was not possible.
For example, at a press briefing in Baghdad on 4 August 2003, US military spokesman Colonel Guy Shields said there was “no accurate way” to keep a record of civilian deaths.
And UK Defence Minister Adam Ingram, responding to a letter from then Labour MP Llew Smith, maintained that ‘Whilst the Ministry of Defence has accurate data relating to the number of UK service personnel that have been killed or injured during Operation Telic (the invasion of Iraq), we have no way of establishing with any certainty the number of Iraqi casualties.’
Smith could only really conclude:
“Surely this is both an inhumane and unacceptable position.
“As at least part of our aid to postwar Iraq must be targeted at assistance to families left without breadwinners who have been killed or seriously injured by the invasion, then our planners are going to have to calculate the numbers of families left destitute by their loss.”
The ORG study, however, shows that recording casualties is entirely practicable.
Authored by Elizabeth Minor, Research Officer on the ORG’s Documenting Existing Casualty Recording Practice Worldwide project, the study was publicly launched in Washington, DC, at the United States Institute of Peace (USIP), a co-funder of the project, together with the Federal Department of Foreign Affairs of Switzerland.
It investigates the work of 40 casualty recorder groups and individuals, based in different conflict and post-conflict environments.
The Iraq Body Count, for example, has been compiling the world’s most comprehensive set of casualty figures for deaths in Iraq since the invasion in 2003.
The ORG research has resulted in a policy paper and a collection of practice-focused papers.
One example of such good practice is “A dossier of civilian casualties in Iraq 2003-5” co-published in 2005 by ORG and Iraq Body Count. This was a “proof of concept” for the utility and feasibility of marshalling and disseminating high quality documentary evidence from an ongoing conflict.
ORG has also been undertaking a comprehensive investigation into the law as it applies to all aspects of casualty recording.
The aim was to demonstrate to the satisfaction of key legislative authorities, at state and interstate level, that the recording of casualties was consistent with the range of norms, laws and agreements to which the international community has already subscribed or committed itself.
ORG’s legal consultant, Susan Breau, was interviewed by ABC South Australia last year about the legal team’s finding that an obligation exists in international law to record all the casualties of conflict, civilian and combatant.
The responsibilities include searching for and identifying civilian casualties, and notifying the family, as there is a “right of the family to know the fate of its relative, and that’s an international human right”.
To hear the interview, click here.
And a group of NGOs concerned with states’ ongoing failure to record violent deaths launched A Charter for the Recognition of Every Casualty of Armed Violence at the British Academy on 15 September 2011.
This Charter was founded on the principle that no person should die unrecorded, and its authors and supporters call on states to uphold this principle for the victims of armed violence.











