Why we should care about women bishops
Apart from the fact that women have become a vital asset to the Church of England.
Last week’s vote by the Church of England’s General Synod to continue to outlaw women bishops may not have felt particularly significant to many feminists out there.
Perhaps busier organising Reclaim the Night marches that were going on around the country on Saturday; fighting the sexism on our pavements rather than that emanating from institutions from which we feel dislocated anyway.
It is the Church, after all, that continues to preach Biblical scriptures, the like of which tells us, “Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord.
For the husband is the head of the wife” (Ephesians 5:22-24), and “A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a women to teach or to have authority over a man; she must be silent.” (1 Timothy 2:11-12)
Is it any wonder, then, that many of us are apathetic about whether the women that choose to preach the word of God are excluded from the highest echelons of His ministries?
As some were heralding the result of the vote as a funeral knell for the Church of England, ‘suicidal stupidity‘ from an institution that has been ‘haemorrhaging credibility for years’, did we give a half smile? We shouldn’t have.
As Reverend Biddi Kings wrote for WVoN last week, women have become a vital asset to the Church of England since their ordination as priests was first permitted two decades ago.
With current numbers exceeding those for men in both training and ordination as priests, it is a mark of the institutional misogyny that female clergy remain mostly unpaid and in lower level positions.
Something, then, that we can all agree on, if we leave spiritual beliefs to one side, is that the experience of discrimination within the workplace is entirely unacceptable and illegal thanks to the Equality Act 2010.
It is this legislation, criticised ironically earlier in the year by an all-party committee that accused it of being ‘anti-Christian‘, which exempts all religious institutions from the legislation on employment and equalities.
Some Christians, however, deny that the comparison between the Church and the secular workplace is fair.
‘To be called to be a bishop is not to be called to be a CEO but to be a father in the church family,’ wrote Susan Leafe in justification of her vote against women joining the episcopate.
It is, nonetheless, treated as such in the eyes of the law, and in the wake of the General Synod’s decision, Frank Field a legislator and former member of the General Synod, has tabled a bill to strip the Church of its exemption from equality laws.
“Any organisation that thinks it can turn its back on half of the talent in the country, and thinks it will be taken seriously, needs some sort of serious wake-up call.”
Similarly, senior Liberal Democrats, including the chief whip, Alistair Carmichael, have questioned whether the 26 bishops (Lords Spirituals) that serve in the House of Lords should be allowed to remain there if the situation continues.
They are effectively a government sanctioned ‘male-only club’ which, as Giles Fraser describes, ‘could have been put down to an accident of history [before the vote]. Now it is deliberate.’
Interventions from Parliament, however, seem unlikely after David Cameron made clear at prime minister’s questions that, whilst he is, “a strong supporter of women bishops,” “you do have to respect the individual institutions and the way they work.”
Arguably though, the Church of England itself is a product of government interference.
Parliament appoints its spiritual leader, the archbishop of Canterbury, the Lords Spirituals, and would have had to ratify the legislation on women bishops – had it been approved by the Synod.
Therefore, if Mr Cameron is unwilling to make use of the establishment between Church and State to intervene on this issue, then shouldn’t disestablishment between Church and State be enacted?
After all, isn’t it contradictory for a institution which discriminates against women from entering the episcopate to have a women as the Defender of the Faith?
In a timely coincidence, the first woman bishop was consecrated in Africa a day before the General Synod vote.
Swaziland is a country where nearly 50 per cent of women will have experienced sexual violence before they turn 24, and ruled by polygamous King Mswati III, the last absolutist monarch.
A country neither lauded for its human rights record, nor its gender equality.
Yet, as he officiated at the ceremony for Ellinah Wamukoya, the Very Reverend David Dinkebogile stressed that he was there to consecrate a bishop, “not a black woman, not an African, not a Swazi woman.”
Herein lies a lesson in acceptance for traditionalists.
















Uncomfortable reading, but I agree with all of this. Let us not forget that the titular head of the Established Church of England for the past 60 years has been a woman, our Queen Elizabeth.
Ove the past 20 years supporters of women as bishop in the Church of England turned ourselves inside out trying accommodate, in this change of law, those who cannot accept women’s ministry. We did this to prevent schism and damage to the Chuch we love.
That worked well didn’t it?
Paul does not only command that a believing women should not teach or exercise authority over the believing man, in both Church and believing home… but points us to the Creation Account as to why.
Our order of Creation exposed a weakness that was once exploited by an enemy, which is only remedied by adhering to God’s authoritative order.