A Europe free from prostitution
Lobbyists call to criminalise the purchase of sex and free Europe from prostitution.
Mary Honeyball MEP and Labour’s spokesperson in Europe on women and gender equality has declared her backing for the European Women’s Lobby (EWL).
This called on the European Parliament to support a ‘Europe free from prostitution’ at a conference in Brussels recently.
The EWL made six key recommendations to EU Member States, which essentially follow the model adopted in Sweden.
The Swedish model referred to recognises women involved in prostitution as victims of violence and criminalises the purchase of sex and offers methodical exit strategies towards new lives.
Legislation in Sweden makes it illegal to procure sexual services, including promoting or deriving profit from prostitution. In 1999 further legislation prohibited the purchase of sexual services.
In 1996, prior to the prohibition of the purchase of sexual services, 13.6 per cent of Swedish men said they had bought someone for prostitution purposes.
In 2008, the figure had dropped to 7.8 per cent.
By this time, of course, it was illegal to purchase sex.
One wonders how many men questioned at this time therefore answered truthfully and whether indeed this figure could be higher in reality.
Speaking to WVoN recently, Ms Honeyball said that she was in full support of the adoption of such a model.
In a statement, Ms Honeyball said that we must also focus attention on the issue of human trafficking, which helps fuel the demand for prostitution.
“If we are to tackle the problem of prostitution we must also acknowledge and fight equally hard to abolish the very violent crime of human trafficking.
“Statistics show that between 76-79 per cent of reported trafficking in humans is for sexual exploitation.
“This is a worryingly high statistic, and, in reality, is likely to be even higher because not every crime of this nature is reported.
“I therefore support the criminalisation of all forms of procuring, and the creation of effective exit programmes for sex workers, in line with the views of the EWL.”
Ms Honeyball said that statistics from Sweden following the introduction of legislation to criminalise those who pay for prostitutes had shown a significant impact: reducing the number of persons exploited in street prostitution by 50 per cent.
Petra Ostergren, a Swedish debater, writer and social commentator specialising in gender politics, interviewed sex workers affected by the change in laws in Sweden and studies reports which have sought responses direct from sex-workers.
She reported that while Swedish politicians and feminists insist the criminalising of procuring all forms of sex has brought about positive effects, the girls and women involved in prostitution report very differently.
Her work showed that Swedish sex workers feel discriminated against, endangered by laws considered protective by politicians and were under severe emotional stress as a result of these laws.
And while some women have reported a reduction in the number of exploitative pimps seen on the streets of Sweden since the introduction of the legislation, other sex workers criticise the legislation as placing them at risk of violence.
They argue they now have to offer lower prices because there is higher competition from other sex workers on the streets for fewer clients.
Women in need of the money agree to engage in unsafe sex to secure the business and put themselves in situations they previously would not have considered.
Some Swedish men still want to purchase sex despite the legislation making it illegal – what the law does, however, is to make it difficult for sex workers to make a full assessment of the client and the risk they may pose.
As a result of the change in law any negotiating is reported as being a hurried affair placing the sex-worker at greater risk of ending up with a dangerous client.
What is concerning, is that Swedish sex workers report an increase in ‘perverted’ customers – those who demand more violent forms of sex and sexual practices including humiliation and degradation.
The men paying for sex refuse to wear a condom more frequently than before the legislation was introduced and those sex workers who are funding a drug problem find it difficult to refuse these customers.
The girls who remain on the street report a weaker support network resulting in an inability to warn each other of dangerous clients.
They also report the need to live a double life, too afraid to admit they work in prostitution for fear of putting their families at risk.
In Sweden, it is illegal to receive any income from a sex-worker, making it difficult to co-habit with a partner, and prostitutes are not considered fit parents so live with the fear of losing custody of their children, if it emerges they sell sex.
In response to criticism of the Swedish model, Ms Honeyball refers to the findings of Sweden’s Justice Chancellor, Anna Skarhead, who reviewed the impact of the legislation 10 years after its implementation.
“A review of the prohibition of the purchase of sexual services in Sweden found that it had had the intended effect, and moreover, it proved an effective tool in both preventing and combatting prostitution and human trafficking for sexual purposes.”
The report said: ‘There is nothing to indicate that the prevalence of indoor prostitution that is not marketed through advertisements in magazines and on the Internet, e.g. prostitution in massage parlours, sex clubs and hotels, and in restaurant and nightclub settings, has increased in recent years.
‘Nor is there any information that suggests that prostitutes formerly exploited on the streets are now involved in indoor prostitution’.
However, other reports have found criticism of the model.
One year after the law was passed, the National Council for Crime Prevention conducted a survey of the practice of the new law and what problems had been encountered.
The National Board of Health and Welfare, also documented existing knowledge of the spread of prostitution.
The National Police Board published a report evaluating the practice of the law and making suggestions about new methods in police work against prostitution.
All three of these reports find, unsurprisingly, that street prostitution dropped immediately after the introduction of the law.
They also suggest that recruitment was lower, although the National Council for Crime Prevention stated that the exact number of prostitutes in certain areas was hard to estimate because street prostitution had simply moved to other streets in larger areas.
All three reports said there is no evidence that prostitution was lower overall. Instead they say that hidden prostitution had probably increased.
This concurs with the reports from the sex workers interviewed, who said that lying about their lives had become a necessity and that those who paid for sexual services simply denied it.
All three reports also confirmed that those men still purchasing sex were more dangerous, and the women who cannot stop or move their business were dependent on these more dangerous men, since they could no longer afford to turn them down.
The National Police Board also highlighted concerns by the healthcare system regarding the declining health of sex workers and the spreading of sexually transmitted diseases.
In response to this, Ms Honeyball said: that sex workers having adequate access to health check-ups is of paramount importance.
“I appreciate that much of the work is demanding and requires healthcare workers, charities and others to do a lot of outreach work and this can be a challenge in such a closed community.
“However building good relationships based on trust helps, and such agencies are trained and equipped with these skills.”
With all the cuts in public spending, one wonders which organisations would be sufficiently trained with the necessary skills to deal sensitively with these women and have the time and resources to build the level of trust required.
“Of course this relies on the government not cutting essential services provided by these stakeholders and I have campaigned against Boris Johnson and the Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) who planned to cut services to a dedicated MPS human trafficking unit which provided skills and expertise to tackle violent crimes like human trafficking.”
It would be naive to say that sex work is a career choice, but many of these women do depend on sex work to live.
We do of course hope there is a brighter, safer future for the sex workers of Europe – a future which includes them in the decision making process and recognises that removing prostitutes from Europe will be a long struggle.
Let’s hope lawmakers consider and listen to the opinions of those women who are already living with the consequences of the criminalisation of prostitution – and offer them a future with the dedicated, appropriate levels of support they will undeniably need to exit the world of sex work.











