Pentagon to allow women on front line
In a groundbreaking announcement last week, the Pentagon confirmed that US Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta will lift the ban on women serving in front line combat roles.
This means that women will now be allowed to join military units which engage in combat at close quarters.
It also opens up positions and career prospects in the armed forces that were previously not available to women.
Congress has been given thirty days to consider the plans and raise any objections.
The military services have been given until 15 May to consider how they will comply with the new regulations by 2016, or to otherwise request exemptions for certain roles where they believe that the presence of women would ‘reduce combat effectiveness’.
However, ‘the onus is going to be on them to justify why a woman can’t serve in a particular role,’ a Pentagon spokesperson said.
While women already make up 14 per cent of American military personnel, if Panetta’s plans go ahead, hundreds of thousands of new positions are expected to become available to women in frontline and elite commando units in army and marine forces.
This expands on the Pentagon’s move almost a year ago which opened around 14,000 combat positions to women, predominantly in the army.
However, women are still excluded from almost 25 per cent of roles in the Army, a figure which is expected to fall significantly when the new proposals are implemented.
Democratic Senator Patty Murray, who is head of the Senate Veterans Affairs Committee, and a member of the defence appropriations subcommittee said: ‘This is an historic step for equality and for recognising the role women have, and will continue to play, in the defence of our nation.
‘From the streets of Iraqi cities to rural villages in Afghanistan, time and again women have proven capable of serving honorably and bravely.
‘In fact, it’s important to remember that in recent wars that lacked any true frontlines, thousands of women already spent their days in combat situations serving side-by-side with their fellow male service members.’
Despite what appears to be general support for the decision, there is, of course, dissent.
Former Navy Seal Dick Couch said: ‘I think it’s a bad idea. Men and women are different.
‘The guys act differently around them.
“This is not to lay blame at women – this is a gender specific indictment, I guess you might say, and I don’t think it will contribute to combat effectiveness.’
He went on to say: ‘It would be a very rare female who has the upper body strength to carry our some of these very arduous training programmes and special missions taskings that we ask some of our special operations troops to do.
‘So I don’t see it really working. It just doesn’t seem like a good idea to me.’
Although these views are disappointingly antediluvian and based on vague notions rather than cold hard facts, they are, unfortunately, not isolated.
Here in the UK, women are also banned from close combat roles.
Women are not officially attached to front line operations, but are allowed to ‘supply’ them – in engineering or medical roles, for instance.
Female military personnel currently make up around nine per cent of the British armed forces, and will be able to serve on submarines as of next year.
But anything close to what has been announced in the US seems a long way off.
Last November a Ministry of Defence spokesperson said there were no plans for a further immediate review.
However, British Brigadier Nicky Moffat, who retired recently, said that judgements around who can and cannot serve should not be made on gender, but on capability.
She said: “It is not just about physical strength. It’s about endurance, it’s about ability to operate within a team, it’s about a range of skills.’
But Major Judith Webb, the first woman to command an all-male field squadron, thinks resources would be wasted trying to train women up to a standard they were unlikely to reach.
‘By opening it up to women, are women shooting themselves in the foot? Because they are not going to meet those standards.’
So, because not every woman would make the grade, all should be excluded? Is that what she’s saying?
The truth is that the new US policy will simply make the practice of women serving in front line combat roles ‘official’, as in reality, it has been happening for years.
Eighty-four American servicewomen have been killed in the last 11 years during combat missions in Iraq and Afghanistan.
British or American, if a women is capable of serving in a military position, whatever that may be, then she should be given an equal chance to do so…. and equal recognition if she is already doing it.
Interestingly, as Cynthia Enloe of Clark University has pointed out in her blog, the news coverage given to Panetta’s announcement is, in fact, misleading.
‘The Defense Secretary and the Joint Chiefs of Staff have not suddenly awoken to the evils of sexism of their own accord. They have been pushed relentlessly.
‘The lifting of the ban is the result of 30 years of women activists’ strategizing and campaigning.’
She writes that activists such as Lory Manning and Carolyn Becraft of the Women’s Research and Education Institute (WREI), and Nancy Duff Campbell and Holly Hemphill of the National Women’s Law Center (NWLC), along with energetic members of the Servicewomen’s Action Network (SWAN) deserve the credit for forcing the Pentagon’s hand.
And, she adds, one should never imagine that any major change in any powerful institution happens without the work of determined, smart, social movement activists.
In this case, that would, I reckon, predominantly be women.












