Do the pension reforms penalise women?
Labour insists that many women will be worse off after this government’s pension reforms.
In press releases which were recently issued and published online, various Labour MPs have reiterated claims made in January by Shadow Pensions Minister Gregg McClymont.
After the pension reforms were announced on 14 January, McClymont said: “This government’s pension changes have hit hard-working women time and again and these reforms are no different.
“Almost half a million women will be nearly £2000 worse off compared to men, but instead of being honest with the women who will lose out this government tried to bury the truth.”
The coalition government is planning to introduce a flat-rate state pension from April 2017 onwards.
Instead of a basic pension of £107.45 per week, pensioners would receive £144 in today’s money.
The three million people due to retire before April 2017 will stay on the current system, meaning that they could be worse off by £36.55 per week or £1900.60 over the course of one year.
Around 430,000 women born between 6 April 1952 and 6 July 1953 will not qualify for the new pension.
Yet men born during the same period will be eligible, as men currently retire later than women.
When McClymont brought up this discrepancy on 14 January in the House of Commons, Pensions Minister Steve Webb responded: “The changes are based on state pension age, and as he knows, that is different for men and women so the implications are also different.”
In another debate on 28 January, Webb further explained that the changes cannot be implemented earlier because it will be 2018 by the time women retire at age 65, the same age as men.
“The only way we could treat men and women identically would be to delay until 2019, but if we did that many more women would be excluded,” he said.
The reforms will come as a further blow for women who have been affected by the government’s aim to increase the retirement age for women from 60 to 65 by 2018.
Many women have had to wait longer for their pension but will retire before the changes are made.
Women who retire after April 2017 may also be negatively impacted by the new system.
In order to receive the £144-a-week pension in full, recipients must have 35 years of National Insurance contributions. This is five more than currently needed to receive the full state pension.
Additional years can be gained by making voluntary contributions, but women may find this difficult to afford as they tend to earn less than men and work less so that they can look after their children.
The government claims that mothers who have stayed at home will benefit from the revised system.
“This reform is good news for women who for too long have been effectively punished by the current system,” said Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith.
“The single tier will mean that more women can get a full state pension in their own right, and stop this shameful situation where they are let down by the system when it comes to retirement because they have taken time out to care for their family.”
The Institute for Fiscal Studies has found that these women will actually only benefit in the short run.
Initially, mothers will have a higher pension, as the state pension amount will increase and the number of years spent raising children will count towards National Insurance contributions.
However, mothers will end up worse off in the long run as the government intends to decrease the amount of extra pension income that is currently allocated to certain groups of people.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies concluded: ‘In the long run, the reform will not increase pension accrual for part time workers and women who take time out to care for children.
‘In fact, in common with almost everyone else, these groups would end up with a lower pension at the state pension age under the new system than they would do under the current system.’
The Work and Pensions Committee will review the government’s proposals and their implications for women over the next few weeks.











