subscribe: Posts | Comments

Iceland considers online porn ban

0 comments

pornbuttonIceland to address effects of violent pornography on women and children.

The Icelandic government has outlined plans to ban internet pornography, a move which could make it the first western democracy to censor the internet.

According to the Telegraph, Icelandic officials are considering internet filters which would stop Icelanders accessing and downloading online porn.

The government could also make it illegal to use Icelandic credit cards to access x-rated content on the internet.

Laws prohibiting the printing and distribution of pornography are already in effect in Iceland, and the country has outlawed strip clubs and introduced prostitution laws which criminalise the customer, rather than the sex worker.

The latest move, announced last week by Iceland’s Interior Minister Ögmundur Jónasson, is designed to protect children from the damaging effects of viewing violent porn online, as well as protect the civil rights of women.

Advisor to the interior minister, Halla Gunnarsdóttir, told the Observer: “We are a progressive, liberal society when it comes to nudity, to sexual relations, so our approach is not anti-sex but anti-violence.

“This is about children and gender equality, not about limiting free speech.

“Research shows that the average age of children who see online porn is 11 in Iceland and we are concerned about that and about the increasingly violent nature of what they are exposed to.

“This is concern coming to us from professionals since mainstream porn has become very brutal.”

The move has been criticised by Icelandic MP Birgitta Jónsdóttir; in an article in the Guardian she called the proposals ‘misguided’ and suggested the bill was already deterring businesses from operating in the country, in fear of full-blown censorship as seen in countries such as China and Saudi Arabia.

“The possibility that this bill will pass through the parliament is near zero,” said Jónsdóttir.

“The parliamentary committee tasked with discussing the censorship proposal, which I am part of, is looking into alternative ways to help parents to protect their children from online porn, mainly through free porn-filter software and educational means.”

“Introducing censorship without compromising freedom of expression and speech is like trying to mix oil and water: it is impossible.”

The logistical problems of blocking online content have also been touted as a barrier to the proposals.

How do you determine which sites are banned, for example, and how will the government stay ahead of an industry which has been quick to adapt to emerging technology?

The proposals do raise concerns over government censorship and freedom of expression, but many countries, including the UK, already have controls in place to limit access to extreme and child pornography.

It seems the next logical step is to take a stance against sexually explicit material which normalises gender-based violence.

In the Observer, Hildur Fjóla Antonsdóttir, gender specialist at Iceland University, said: “This initiative is about narrowing the definition of porn so it does not include all sexually explicit material but rather material that can be described as portraying sexual activity in a violent or hateful way.”

Iceland certainly seems to be doing something right; in 2012 it came top in the Global Gender Gap Index for the fourth year running, while the UK dropped two places – to eighteenth.

Anti-porn campaigner Dr Gail Dines, author of ‘Pornland: How Porn has Hijacked our Sexuality’, claimed Britain would be next in line for a ban on the “increasingly brutal and hardcore imagery which is now the standard”.

“Of course internet porn is damaging,” she said. “We have years of empirical evidence.

“It’s like global warming – you will always find some global warming deniers out there who can quote some little piece of research they have found somewhere, some science junk, but the consensus is there.

“We are not saying you see porn and go out and rape, but we are saying it shifts the way people think about sexual relationships, about intimacy, about women.”

In December, however, plans to automatically block access to pornography sites were rejected by ministers.

The proposed opt-in system would have required internet service providers (ISPs) to block adult content unless it was requested by customers.

Revised proposals will require ISPs to introduce mandatory filters for any new computer in a household where a child is present, so parents can decide how strictly they would like content filtered.

But the new measures don’t go far enough, according to some.

The NSPCC said it was disappointed: “The best option to protect children is for adult content to be automatically blocked by internet service providers,” according to head of corporate affairs Alan Wardle.

“Hardcore pornographic videos are just a few clicks away and a quarter of children have been sent unsolicited sexual material online.”

Iceland has proved itself to be a progressive country when it comes to championing gender equality.

A similar ban in the UK may raise concerns over government censorship, but there is a lot we can learn from Europe’s second largest island, which remains the best place to be a woman.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *