Judge feared for footballer’s career
Do even members of the judiciary see footballers as different from and better than the average Brit?
When Cardiff City midfielder Kevin Sainte-Luce was found guilty of punching one woman unconscious and shoving another woman in a Cardiff nightclub, the story passed with little comment from the mainstream media, with only Wales Online reporting on the case.
The lack of exposure for this story is particularly concerning for those who feel that violence against women is not taken seriously enough, not least because Sainte-Luce escaped a jail term and was only fined £1,250 and given community service.
District judge Bodfan Jenkins defended the decision not to jail the footballer because he said that the assault was “drastically different to the behaviour Sainte-Luce exhibited in his work and home life”.
Apparently knocking a woman out in a nightclub is not sufficient to merit jail time as long as you keep your nose clean elsewhere.
What is perhaps most disturbing is Judge Jenkins’ further justification for the lack of a custodial sentence, which is that “because your promising career could be compromised by prison time, I want to avoid taking such action”.
We can only wonder if the judge would have said the same to a defendant whose career was less glamorous – e.g. a talented IT consultant, or a dedicated care assistant.
It seems that even members of the judiciary – who are supposed to be impartial – cannot resist the temptation to canonise footballers as somehow different from and better than the average Briton.
It should be noted, however, that Cardiff City Football club have taken it upon themselves to send out a stronger message than Judge Jenkins’ faint condemnation of Sainte-Luce’s behaviour.
The club has terminated Sainte-Luce’s contract with immediate effect, therefore making a mockery of Jenkins’ main reason for not jailing the footballer.
Sadly, it was only when Sainte-Luce was dismissed from the team that any of the non-Welsh media bothered to report the story, with The Sun describing the footballer as a ‘Cardiff bad-boy’.
Judge Jenkins did warn Sainte-Luce that if he committed any further offences during the next 12 months, he would be recharged for the two offences as well as the new offences.
This implies that the judge recognises his sentencing has been pitifully light, so why he did not impose a stronger one to begin with remains a mystery.
It seems that when it comes to taking violence against women seriously, even members of the UK judiciary are still – inexplicably – dragging their feet.











