subscribe: Posts | Comments

Helen Mirren crits the celluloid ceiling

5 comments

movie camera, women filmmakers, helen mirrenWomen directed only 9 per cent of the 250 top grossing films in 2012.

Guest post by Thea Raisbeck.

Helen Mirren  received the ‘Legend’ accolade at the Empire Film Awards recently, and she used her acceptance speech to highlight filmmaking’s glaring inequality of representation.

Taking her cue from Sam Mendes, who cited the typical cannon of masculine influence as he received his award for ‘Skyfall’, Mirren pointed out that there was not one woman’s name there behind the camera.

She had nothing against Sam, she said, she just hoped that in five or ten years’ time there would be two or three or four women’s names there.

Her comments were well-received on the night but, predictably, somewhat disingenuously reported.

The Independent had Mirren-as-harpy, ‘taking a swipe’ at Mendes, while the Daily Maal saw it as a very public ‘telling off’.

However, her speech was not the premise for a public spat but an indictment of the gendered bias in filmmaking.

Indiewire nailed it: Mirren was not attacking Mendes but ‘dissing [an] industry that only provides male role models’.

Criticising masculine dominance and publicly advocating for female talent is a strident act.

Unfortunately, Mirren’s feminist credentials have not always stood up to close scrutiny.

In 2008 she proclaimed date rape a ‘tricky’ area; not a crime but a subtlety that needed to be ‘worked out’ between men and women.

Her recent choice to star in a film that allegedly ‘trashes’ the reputation of murder victim Lana Clarkson has also drawn dismay.

On Hollywood, however, even her most vocal detractors must concede the point.

In January the Centre for the Study of Women in Television and Film revealed that women directed only 9 per cent of the 250 top grossing films in 2012.

Peer acknowledgement is bleaker still.

Jane Campion remains the only woman to win the Palme D’or and we had to wait 81 years to see a woman clinch the Best Director Oscar: Kathryn Bigelow for ‘The Hurt Locker’ in 2010.

Bigelow stands alone as Hollywood’s career-established, statuette-clutching, bone-fide Female Success Story.

Yet recognition of The Hurt Locker was still muddied by accusations of tokenism and sullied by a depressingly inevitable focus on her appearance.

Encouragingly, the Sundance Institute recently reported that women are better represented in the independent sector.

Over the last ten years of the Sundance festival, women made up 29.8 per cent of filmmakers.

Another study has asserted that ‘when female and male filmmakers have similar budgets…the resulting grosses are also similar’.

Obtaining bigger budgets, it seems, is a woman’s problem.

Callie Khouri, scriptwriter of the seminal ‘Thelma and Louise’, has spoken of the industry’s fear of mainstream, big-budget, female filmmaking.

Reflecting on the bind she said: “I would like to work outside the female centric world…but if [the film’s] got a woman in it, I’ve got a much better chance of getting it made”.

The Sundance report recommended increased peer promotion of women’s filmmaking and raised awareness of gender bias.

Mirren was listening, but what about Mendes?

One critic helpfully reminded us it is not Mendes’ fault the industry is fundamentally sexist, pointing out that we should stop moaning because ‘Bridesmaids’ had lots of women in it.

The point is, surely, that the industry could do better.

There have been many important films made by women. Kimberly Pierce’s ‘Boys Don’t Cry’ was groundbreaking, heartbreaking and fierce all at once.

Surely the late, great Nora Ephron taught us all a thing or two about the nuances and idiosyncrasies of the male/female dynamic?

Until women are accepted as equals with something to say, their films will never be as zeitgeist-forming or genre-defining as the heroes in whose wake Sam Mendes treads.

  1. ‘One critic helpfully reminded us it is not Mendes’ fault the industry is fundamentally sexist, pointing out that we should stop moaning because ‘Bridesmaids’ had lots of women in it.’ Well, that’s OK then!

    • I loathe these kind of absurd counterarguments. ‘Here’s one film that has a lot of women in it, so…you lose.’ (not to mention the fact that while Bridesmaids had a lot of women in it, as I recall it was still mostly about finding a man to marry in the end, and I am pretty sure it would actually not pass the Beschdel Test) I don’t really understand why my gender seems to have so much trouble admitting the existence of patriarchal systems. The facts speak for themselves, and yet the world is filled to bursting with ignorant people remaining willfully blind to gender inequality.
      Also, anyone involved in making Skyfall needs a good swipe. That movie was ridiculously sexist, even for a Bond film. Not only do the women he sleeps with NOT EVEN HAVE NAMES in this movie (and lest we forget, one was a former child sex slave who he climbs into the shower with without any explanation and then lets her get shot BEFORE kicking the asses of every bad guy present really easily), but every female supporting character either gets killed (and her position of authority filled by a man) or becomes a secretary after proving that women just can’t cut it in the field. There should have been an outcry about the film. I don’t get it.

    • Thea Raisbeck says:

      I know, Jane. He also cited ‘The Help’, ‘The Hunger Games’ and ‘Brave’ as signs that things may be looking up for women in filmmaking. Not a single one was directed by a woman. I think he kind of missed the point, that women are sidelined and often pigeonholed into roles, or a certain ‘type’ of filmmaking. I think the reason there is a stronger female presence in the independent sector is largely to do with the fact the industry view of filmmaking is so gendered – i.e. women are seen as good at making quiet, quirky, thoughtful or countercultural films. They can’t escape this label and are unable to find backing for what may be traditionally (but erroneously!) seen as male subject matter. Callie Khouri says she tried for years – unsuccessfully – to get a film about baseball made (and ended up making the excellent but still female-centric Nashville instead).
      I think films with strong, interesting female leads are important, but I also think it’s important that women aren’t limited in the projects they are involved in due to rigid gender divides. It’s OK for men to traverse the divide but women rarely do so.

  2. It is frustrating Thea, very.

    Graeme: thank you for your post. Several bloggers did point out the rape scene in Skyfall, such as this one http://therealsgm.blogspot.co.uk/2012/10/james-bonds-skyfall.html

    Also, Giles Cohen wrote a piece that wasn’t published here:
    http://reciperifle.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/bond-villain.html But the mainstream just ignored it.

  3. Thea Raisbeck says:

    Completely agree with Graeme about Skyfall. It was lauded by the mainstream as being a very knowing and self-referential Bond film – the corollary being that there’s no need to take the misogyny, two dimensional and decorative female characters too seriously because it’s all very much of a tradition. The need to crowbar in some Bond sex resulted in, as you point out, a very problematic scene. I’ve also heard some defend it as a very ‘female’ film because it’s really about M, not Bond. I personally found it hard to extrapolate Judy Dench from M and it felt very much like a homage to a departing actress than a celebration of matriarchy.
    I too find it annoying when people suggest that a large female cast somehow redresses gender imbalances. It’s not the volume of women but, as you say, how they are represented. Bridesmaids would struggle to pass the Bechdel test . The fact marriage is, despite everything else, still viewed as the sacrosanct destiny and obsession of all women – mutes many arguments for it being a wholly positive, empowering depiction of womanhood.
    The point with Mendes, which I was trying to get across in this article, is that he didn’t try hard enough. The argument that men can’t cite female inspiration because women don’t make good enough films is nonsense and again and a way to try and obfuscate the patriarchal institution of Hollywood. I refuse to believe Mendes hasn’t watched films created by women and been impressed, or inspired by them. He just seemed intent on reeling off a list that sounded like film studies 101, as if he was afraid he wouldn’t be taken seriously if he didn’t say he was influenced by Truffaut, Scorsese and Bergman.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *