subscribe: Posts | Comments

Pay and pensions: a vicious circle

0 comments

Money, women's pensions, women's rights, pay gap, pension gapWomen are living on smaller pensions than men, and their lowest pension income since 2008.

The gender pay gap is something which is discussed with depressing regularity, with the most recent disparity recorded at a cringe-worthy 9.6 per cent in 2012.

But news last week also showed how this gap carries on throughout a woman’s working life and into retirement, where the economic chasm remains – and widens – in the pension gender gap.

According to research carried out by insurance company Prudential, the pension gender gap has this year increased by 13 per cent, to an eye-watering 36 per cent, where women can now expect to receive a retirement income of £6500 less than men.

That’s a third less.

Shocking, I know.

Prudential’s ‘Class of 2013’ research looked at the retirement plans and expected incomes of around 1000 adults who were retiring this year.

The expected annual income through pensions for a woman taking retirement in 2013 is an average of £11,750 per year – down from £12,250 in 2012.

This figure is a five-year low, and includes income from private, state and company pensions.

What is worse, this devaluation is now in its fifth year – women’s pensions have been in a steady decline by around £500 a year since 2008.

For men, the trend is reversed, with the average income for a man retiring this year expected to be £18,250 – up from £18,000 last year.

It is all so disappointingly familiar.

So what is going on?

Why does a woman, who may have experienced a substantial gender pay gap her whole working life, have to face an even bigger one in retirement?

Simply put, women are being penalised with smaller pension pots because of the disparity in pay they earn throughout their working lives, and because of interruptions to work patterns to raise families.

According to the Office of National Statistics (ONS): ‘The low income levels of women pensioners reflect the gender pay gap during people’s working lives as well as interrupted working histories due to caring responsibilities, which impair the ability of women to save for retirement though the pension system.

‘In addition, many older women pensioners are widows, and the level of occupational pension received by a widow is generally only half the level of the pension received by the couple when the man was alive.’

So women are victims of the apparently unassailable gender pay gap when they are working, and then again when they retire.

It is like perpetual motion.

For taking care of families, bringing up children, sacrificing career aspirations and taking lower paid jobs to juggle family life, women are being penalised as they reach pensionable age.

A spokesperson for the Prudential acknowledged that the disparity in retirement income has increased over the last few years, and that it would not disappear ‘for years to come’.

Women are all too aware of this.

Far less women in the Prudential study felt financially prepared for retirement than men.

And to add insult to injury, the new flat rate pension of £144 per week, which will now be introduced in 2016, will see over 30,000 women lose out on around £310 a year.

According to the Telegraph, a particular group of women will suffer ‘because people are only entitled to the new flat rate state pension when they reach state pension age.

‘Women born between April 1952 and July 1953 will lose out because they will reach state pension age before April 2017, and will therefore miss out on higher flat rate state pension payments.

‘Men born between these dates will reach state pension age after the change takes effect.’

The new flat rate pension is a quagmire of difficulties anyway, and although designed to benefit numerous women in the long run, it is cold comfort to the 30,000 or so who fall through yet another gender gap.

Sarah Pennells, who founded SavvyWoman, a financial website for women, said she was in favour of simplifying the current complex and confusing state pension system and welcome the aims of a flat rate scheme.

“However,” she said, “Thousands of women born before April 6th 1953 feel aggrieved that they won’t qualify for the new pension, even though men born on the same date will.”

Unsurprisingly, Labour’s Shadow Pension Minister Gregg McClymont MP, was less than complimentary, saying that ‘there is significant confusion surrounding the pension changes.

‘In pensions, clarity is key particularly for those so close to retiring and the government is failing. Hundreds of thousands of women close to retirement are now set to lose out thanks to this government’s plans.

‘First we were to see the new pension in 2016, then it was “too complicated”, now they have decided it isn’t that tricky after all.

‘The truth is the coalition approach to pensions is in utter disarray.’

The government’s approach to equality is certainly no better.

It’s about time they took into consideration the enormity of what women actually do – work (often in lower paid jobs), sacrifice career and earning potential to raise families, care for other relatives – and stop penalising us for doing so.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *