Mick Philpott: Badly misplaced outrage
Why is there no outrage over the depravity of a violent man unchecked by police or social services?
The week Mick Philpott was convicted of killing his six children in a botched arson attack has been a climatic one in the rise of ‘the UK Benefit Scrounger’.
Over the last few years, the national lens has been focusing ever closer on the ‘scrounger’, that feckless ingrate to be found skulking behind drawn curtains and in the comedic sketches of Little Britain.
Now we learn, courtesy of mainstream media and a few government ministers, that the welfare state is capable not of only of nursing into being an army of shirkers but also turning people into child killers.
For the Daily Mail, declaring Mick Philpott, an unemployed father of 12, a ‘Vile Product of Welfare UK’ must surely be their magnum opus; the logical conclusion of dedicated years spent convincing the nation that benefit claimants are a breed distinct from mankind in all but basic bone structure.
Following Philpott’s conviction for killing his children in a failed attempt to frame his ex-lover, the Daily Mail wrote: “The trial spoke volumes about the sheer nastiness of the individuals involved.
“But it also lifted the lid on the bleak and often grotesque world of the welfare benefit scroungers – of whom there are not dozens, not hundreds, but tens of thousands in our country.”
The actual scale of estimated benefit fraud has been handily illustrated in this diagram.
Meanwhile government ministers were falling over themselves to pick up where media coverage left off, proving that the death of six children is no reason to pass up an opportunity for brazen political point scoring.
Chancellor George Osborne, with the full backing of the Prime Minister, told reporters: “It’s right we ask questions as a government, a society and as taxpayers, why we are subsidising lifestyles like [those of Mick Philpott]. It does need to be handled.”
And on the front page of the Metro, in place of the usual gaudy mobile phone advert, was a picture of Mick and Mairead Philpott with the title ‘Tears of a Savage”.
Their cover story began: “Unrepentant benefits scrounger Mick Philpott…”
Not ‘Unrepentant abuser of women’, or even ‘Unrepentant child killer’, but ‘Unrepentant benefit scrounger’.
In what sort of a society is his status as ‘benefit scrounger’ more newsworthy than the degree to which he abused his power as father and husband?
Over to the Six O’Clock News and BBC presenter George Alagiah asked: “Are there lessons to be learned from this shocking case?”
Indeed there are George, but not the ones you’re euphemistically referring to.
Lesson One might be that people with violent, abusive patterns of behaviour will often stop at nothing to control and destroy the people they’re supposed to love.
Mick Philpott has a history of violently controlling young, often vulnerable, women.
This history stretches back over 35 years.
Philpott’s treatment of the women closest to him – grooming, humiliating and assaulting them – will be very familiar to both victims and survivors of domestic violence.
In his twenties Philpott was convicted for attempted murder and grievous bodily harm after one girlfriend, Kim Hill, tried to leave him. He crept into her home at night and attacked both Hill and her mother.
Heather Kehoe was 14 when Philpott, then 37, began grooming her, eventually convincing her to run away from her family at the age of 16.
Lisa Willis, Philpott’s ex-girlfriend, who shared a home with Mick and Mairead Philpott, told the jury, from behind a sealed screen, how he kept her and Mairead Philpott, his co-defendent, in a state of slavery.
“I could not go out shopping on my own, I could not go into town,” she said. “He would ask me questions – where I’m going, how long I’ll be and what for.”
Both women were working and their wages were paid directly into Mick Philpott’s bank account.
But little attention has been paid to the reality of the benefits actually received by the Philpott family.
Mostly these benefits were working tax credits from both Mairead Philpott and Lisa Willis’s low paid jobs – not the much vilified unemployment benefits.
Mairead Philpott, who has received a 17-year sentence for her involvement in the arson plot that killed the children was a vulnerable 19 year-old woman, isolated from her family when she first met Philpott. Philpott was 43.
When Lisa Willis left Philpott and begun seeking custody of their children, he was furious and became obsessed with her.
His plot to frame her for setting fire to his home with their children in it was his revenge against her for daring to leave.
So why hasn’t this case prompted public debate about domestic violence?
Why is there no outrage over the depravity of violent partners who control their families, unchecked by police or social services?
The truth is, the story of abusive relationships and gender violence is too commonplace, too enduring to solicit salacious front page attention.
Not to mention the fact that victims and survivors of domestic violence are rarely the ones setting the news agenda or making public policy.
It’s a cruel insult to the six children who died in this fire to focus on Philpott as a ‘benefit scrounger’ whilst ignoring the real context for their deaths.
If the media coverage it to be believed, Mick Philpott fell naturally off the sofa from a lifestyle of worklessness into plotting the events that would be responsible for the death of his six children.
His long history as a controlling, threatening, violent man is altogether less important.
And for a government whose entire political analysis turns on convincing people the poor are authors of their own fate, there could be no better poster boy than Mick Philpott, in all his gold-ringed, white-vested glory.
Ministers are salivating with glee as they call the Philpott case an ideological victory, a glee Obsorne’s best ‘serious-little-boy-at-funeral’ face has done little to disguise.
When we remember that this same ideology is being used to justify cuts to vital domestic violence services, like those that provide a lifeline to women and children abused by people like Mick Philpott, we begin to appreciate the full audacity of the government’s gloating.
















What an excellent piece, thank you.
We should expect more and more Mick Philpott’s. Here is a man that has been groomed by male culture into seeing females and children as objects to be owned or sub humans to be worked, like slaves. He is a psychopath along age and gender lines. He didn’t love the women or children in his life – you cannot love that which you hold in contempt. He loved his ‘ownership’ of people as it fed his ego. The outrage is that we as a society keep blaming the products of male culture’s violent discrimination towards women and children rather than blaming the media that promotes this attitude. Jimmy Saville and Mick Philpott are not products of the BBC or welfare state, but they are products of the culture of violent verbal and physically abusive attitudes towards women and children as promoted within male media. Not all men will succumb to this grooming just as not all men will die of smoking, but with 1/2 million women ending up in A&E through violent attacks by sexist men every year and 1 in 5 female children attacked by a male relative, at what point do we, as female tax payers, start demanding a political end to sexist violence in the family and society.
This is a great piece, Heather. Given Mick Philpott’s attitude to women, one wonders what kind of life his daughter experienced before her death. I agree it is not possible to lay any blame for his actions with the welfare system. His behaviour has resulted from something much deeper than that. We, as a society, do need to demand a change in attitude to male violence against women and children and politicians need to take action as a matter of urgency – only then can a more positive future for women and children be achieved.