Survivors present petition to Irish government
Survivors of Symphysiotomies petition for time limits to be set aside so survivors can seek redress.
A petition has been presented to the Irish government calling on it to set aside the statute bar so survivors of symphysiotomies can seek compensation.
Symphysiotomy was a medical procedure carried out in Irish hospitals largely between the 1960s and 1980s.
It involved the sawing of the pregnant woman’s pubic bone in half to open the birth canal.
This was ostensibly done to facilitate an easier delivery but, influenced by the strict Catholic doctrine of the time, had darker undertones.
A symphysiotomy was an alternative to a Caeserean section, which was seen by many at the time as a form of artificial birth control.
By sawing open the pubic bone, a woman could in theory carry and deliver limitless pregnancies.
More often than not, the procedure was carried out while the pregnant woman was giving birth, and she was given very little or no information as to what was happening.
It was a painful and invasive practice and left its victims with a multitude of permanent, adverse side effects.
Victims have suffered incontinence, severe back pain, difficulties walking, and prolapsed organs.
Many have suffered psychological and neurological problems because of the way in which the procedure was carried out.
One survivor, Máirín O’Moore, described the procedure as “barbaric.”
It was carried out on her during the birth of her first child in 1950 and it left her with permanent ailments, affecting her ability to work.
She said, “It was a nightmare, you couldn’t explain it. An actual saw was used on my pelvis. […] An animal would not have the same thing done to it.”
A group representing the approximately 200 mainly elderly women described such a step as “the only thing the Dáil can do in a practical way to assist survivors”.
The petition was signed by over 22,000 people, among them over 470 doctors who described the practice as “butchery” and “medieval.”
One went as far as to liken the practice to that of Nazi doctor Josef Mengele, who carried out ghastly experiments on prisoners of concentration camps during the Second World War.
It is estimated that symphysiotomies were performed on around 1,500 women between the 1960s and 1980s, although the procedure has been carried out as recently as 2000.
Earlier this year, a woman successfully sued the HSE (Health Service Executive) for damages following a symphysiotomy carried out during the delivery of her second baby in February 2000.
Tracey Nelson alleged that Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda, Co. Louth, was negligent in the management of her treatment during her pregnancy, failing to diagnose a certain physical dysfunction and thereby prevent the condition escalating to the point that a symphysiotomy was carried out.
In ruling in Ms Nelson’s favour, the judge said that her life had been “transformed and degraded” and that the procedure was the “primary cause.”
Ms Nelson, a former chef, has been unable to work since the procedure and has developed depression and constant pain in her joints and muscles.
She had to undergo further operations in 2004 and 2007 to stabilise and treat her condition.
She was awarded €591,297 in damages.
The women who endured the procedure between the 1960s and 1980s want the statute bar to redress lifted so that they can seek compensation for what they suffered.
Marie O’Connor, chairwoman of Survivors of Symphysiotomies (SOS) said, “they need to be able to litigate these cases without being held up by points of procedure that are related to time.
“The fact is that these operations in many cases took place 40 years ago and it’s quite difficult to take action after such a long time so setting aside the statute bar is actually the only thing the Dáil can do in a practical way to assist survivors of symphysiotomies.”
The group went on to say, “There are no floodgates, only 200 or so mainly elderly women standing, waiting, for justice.”
Among the doctors who signed the petition, a number were based in the UK and the USA.
One, Dr Mayra Luria, based in Florida, wrote, “I did not realise that being a Catholic required total ignorance.”
Another, Dr David Marchesi from the UK, wrote “Any doctors who took part in these ghastly exercises should be struck off.”
Dr Nigel Drew, also based in the UK, referred to the death in November 2012 of Savita Halappanavar after she was denied a potentially life-saving abortion, a tragedy which drew international attention and scrutiny of Ireland’s draconian abortion regime.
He wrote, “Ireland has a despicable record on its care for women, from abuse in children’s homes, birth control and pregnancy services.
“Many of us are appalled at the recent death of a young woman denied an abortion of her dead baby. Time to abandon the Mediaeval mindset.”
The petition was presented by Survivors of Symphysiotomy to Sinn Féin deputy Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin and Senator Jillian van Turnhout of the All-Party Victims of Symphysiotomy Oireachtas Support Group.
Ó Caoláin said it would be promptly conveyed to Minister for Health Dr James Reilly.
He pointed out that “a succession of governments has failed to properly recognise its duty on behalf of all the people of this country […]
“It’s very, very important now that every effort is employed to give these women closure. The victims of symphysiotomy deserve no less.”
















Is there no end to the butchery that women have to suffer? This is appalling.