subscribe: Posts | Comments

Thatcherism did not just affect UK women

0 comments

villa grimaldi, pinochet, chile, torture, rape, thatcherGlaring omissions in Thatcher obituaries about her negative impact on women outside the UK.

Trigger warning for mentions of rape and torture

As Christopher Barrie remarked in OpenDemocracy recently, a brief survey of major news media in the UK suggests that a – sizeable – portion of Margaret Thatcher’s legacy abroad has gone largely unreported.

We should, he remarked, also take note of the glaring omissions in the obituaries written about the UK’s former prime minister, and be clear exactly what we are being told to “pay tribute” to.

A survey of obituaries in The Guardian, The Telegraph, The Times, The Independent and BBC News shows not one mention of her dealings with Chile, Cambodia, East Timor or Saudi Arabia.

Only The Independent, he pointed out, makes any mention of her policy towards apartheid in South Africa – for which David Cameron recently apologised.

Of course, this absence could be put down to the domestic bias of British newspapers, but other international adventures have been remarked upon, for example, the Falklands War, and interactions with Reagan and Gorbachov.

There has been a lot of talk about her legacy regarding women in the UK. But her actions and her beliefs did not just affect the UK’s women.

Let me take Chile as an example.

General Augusto Pinochet, as Barrie pointed out, took over the government of Chile  following a CIA-backed coup in 1973, during which the democratically elected socialist president, Salvador Allende, was killed.

Following the coup, Pinochet’s men rounded up and summarily executed large numbers of unarmed civilians in the national stadium of Santiago. It is estimated that during his regime he was responsible for the deaths of at least 3,000 and for a great number more who disappeared.

Meanwhile, after the detention and torture of Sheila Cassidy in 1975, a British doctor living  and working  in Chile, the then Labour government subsequently broke off diplomatic relations.

However, once in power, Thatcher restored diplomatic relations and rescinded a previous arms embargo, and the pair went on to ‘enjoy a close relationship bolstered, in no small part, by their shared commitment to neoliberal doctrine’. As such, Thatcher was not just a supporter but a close friend of the late South-American dictator.

In 1988, when Spain requested Pinochet be extradited from the UK to Spain to face charges of abusing human rights, Thatcher, in a letter to The Times noted that “Chile, led [during her premiership] by General Pinochet, was a good friend to this country during the Falklands War.

“By his actions the war was shortened and many British lives were saved.”

But, as  the 1991 Rettig Report found, 3,428 people disappeared or were murdered by Pinochet’s regime from 1974 to 1977 .

And, in 2003, the Report of the National Commission on Political Imprisonment and Torture was commissioned to create a comprehensive list of those who were imprisoned and tortured for political reasons between September 1973 to March 1990.

As well as documenting that 35,868 people had been tortured or imprisoned improperly, this second report found that nearly every female prisoner was the victim of repeated rape.

The rapes took many forms, from penile penetration by military men,  to the insertion of foreign objects into victims.

Numerous women (and men) reported spiders or live rats being implanted into their orifices.

One woman wrote, “I was raped and sexually assaulted with trained dogs and with live rats. They forced me to have sex with my father and brother who were also detained. I also had to listen to my father and brother being tortured.”

Her experiences were mirrored by those of many other women who told their stories to the commission.

And for those women not picked up and tortured?

The military wanted women to be politically passive and uninvolved, and so encouraged them to embrace traditional gender roles through controlling the Mother’s Centers that had previously facilitated women’s political and economic participation.

However, although the dictatorship sought to prevent women from being active outside of the house, its economic policies and political structure had the opposite effect: the extreme poverty forced women to seek employment and social involvement in order to survive, often by joining some form of pro-democracy communal group.

When the legal battle over the fate of Pinochet, former dictator, life senator and alleged mass murderer, reached its climax in the UK’s House of Lords in November 1988, it was watched, the Independent reported, by Christina Godoy-Navarrete and Sara De Witt.

Godoy-Navarrete and De Witt were among four former political prisoners of the Chilean military junta and asked the UK’s Attorney General to charge General Pinochet with torture and kidnapping.

Both were victims of Pinochet’s secret police force when they were picked up in 1974 and detained in two of the most notorious of the regime’s torture houses, Jose Domingo Canas and the Villa Grimaldi.

Prisoners at both centres were subjected to electric shocks, severe beatings, suspensions from ceilings until their wrists tore, and rapes.

“The torture took place daily,” Godoy-Navarrete recalled.

“We would be blindfolded, strapped to beds and then it would begin. There were electric shocks administered to all over our bodies, and then there would be a rape.”

In 2000 the BBC reported, Pinochet ‘made a hesitant admission of responsibility for atrocities committed by the military while he was in power.

“As a former president of the republic, I accept all the facts that they say the army and the armed forces did,” he said in a taped message on his 85th birthday.’

But, as Lauren Foote wrote in 2003, ‘the question of whether some human rights can be encroached upon in the interest of national (or global) security is one without an easy answer and it is a question that should be debated.

‘Perhaps,’ Foote continued, ‘some human rights will be suspended in tumultuous times.

‘But if you choose to argue that the trauma Chile faced during Pinochet’s reign necessitated “some” repression, do so with a full understanding of what you are defending.’

And if you expect any or all of us to mourn the demise of any politician or friend of a politician who supports such behaviour, think again.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *