subscribe: Posts | Comments

Should sex offenders have human rights?

3 comments

human rights, sex offenders, women's rightsFour sex offender registration appeals have been successful on the grounds of human rights.

Imagine if you or  a member of your family or your best friend was a victim of rape, how would you feel if the perpetrator was allowed to apply to come off the sex offenders register?

This has now been possible since 1 September 2012, after the Supreme Court ruled that a life-long inclusion on the register breached the Human Rights Act 1998.

Shocked?

So was Prime Minister David Cameron.  He appealed the decision, but the appeal was rejected.

Suffolk police received and approved four requests from sex offenders asking to be removed from the register. The names of these ex-offenders have not been released because of privacy laws.

Detective Superintendent Alan Caton of Suffolk Constabulary said  said of these particular decisions: “Members of the public should be reassured that sex offenders who we believe continue to pose a risk will remain on the register.”

So, now, it is possible there are convicted sex offenders walking around UK streets, maybe a street near you, under no restrictions or with no supervision whatsoever.

Is that so bad?

The law in the UK currently requires anyone jailed for 30 months or more for a sex offence to be automatically placed on the sex offenders’ register for an indefinite period.

This means that their names, addresses, date of birth and national insurance number are recorded. They must notify the police of any changes in personal details, such as their name or address. If they wish to leave the country they must inform the police in person.

In some respects the decision by the Supreme Court sounds worse than it is.

While it is true that sex offenders can now apply to be removed from the register and if successful, to live their lives without scrutiny from the police, they are only able to apply to do so 15 years after their release from prison.

During that time, they should have received rehabilitation both in custody and in the community on licence.

For some this may take longer than fifteen years, for others it will be less.

Factors taken into consideration in support of an application to be removed include the applicant’s age and whether or not they have re-offended during their time on the register.

Police officers and representatives from partner agencies must be content that the applicants no longer pose a risk to the public.

Figures released under freedom of information laws showed that sex offenders are already being successful at appealing their life-long inclusion on the register.

Critics of this change include not only victims of sexual offences, but also the support agencies who work with rape victims.

They argue the law is unfair, as victims are forced to serve a life sentence following the offence.

They also say that the human rights of the victims have not been considered.

Andrew Flanagan, chief executive of the NSPCC, said the NSPCC had “been told the legal ruling could not be overturned”.

He is concerned that there is no proven or recognised ‘cure’ for adult sex offenders who abuse children and they must therefore always be considered a risk.

“Physical and emotional harm caused by sexual abuse can damage children’s lives,” he said. “We will monitor the appeals process closely and will raise concerns if we believe the civil liberties of convicted sex offenders are being put before the protection of children.”

Below is the view of a sex offender, writing anonymously, who feels that life-long registration impacts not only on his ability to rebuild his life but also impinges on his family’s right to a private life.

‘At each visit [to the police station each year] my photographs and other details like my National Insurance number and my car’s registration number are also taken.

‘Being on the register also means that every time I leave the country for work or holiday, for more than three days, I have to go to the police station and give them full details of my visit including the destination address and length of stay, also if I am to visit friends or family within the United Kingdom and my aggregate stay anywhere is more than seven days, again I have to register that address with the police.

‘In other words you have to register the details of my friends and family as well who have not committed any crime.’

You could argue that this is one of the repercussions of committing an offence of a sexual nature, and perhaps a consideration which should have been thought about by the offender before committing the offence.

The other side of the coin is that if we deny sex offenders this right of appeal, we are labelling them and accepting the view that people are not capable of changing.

And in reality, if a sex offender wants to re-offend, does registration on the sex offenders register prevent him from doing so?

Does a list really protect the public?

This is undoubtedly a contentious issue.

Are we protecting the public and balancing the rights of the victim and of the offender?

Is it a fair and just decision for those involved?

We are yet to see the full affects of the Supreme Court’s decision. For now, the jury remains out.

  1. charlie tyler says:

    As a survivor of rape and intimate partner violence I have a connection to this issue that is somewhat complicated. In incarnation of offenders we do, for a period of time, restrict their right to a range of human rights. I think this is just and equitable. I also think 15 years is a long time, and if we are to reduce re offending behaviour we must offer offenders some hope of successful reintegration. I would argue for better funded support for survivors and better funded education and rehabilitation for offenders. I would also argue that a person that committed an offence against an adult 20 years earlier that has understood his offence, taken steps where appropriate to make amends and is at low risk of reoffending should be able to apply to be removed. I think that in general, and also of the men that raped me.

    • vicki wharton says:

      I would rather put the money into preventing rape via the link between sexism and thinking of females as inferior which allows men to either take sex from an inferior or use sex to humiliate and degrade an inferior. Likewise, I would like the propoganda that supports and encourages males to think of females as dogs and whores, pornography, to be not allowed to refer to one gender with hate words and portray them as enjoying acts of violence against them. I would also stipulate that no act should be shown without it being shown being done and enjoyed by both genders in the same scene – ie anal, group etc and if hate language is used about one gender, then it should be used about both or better still, about neither.

  2. Thank you for commenting Charlie – your opinion is valued and admirable as a victim and survivor of rape and intimate sexual violence.

    I personally agree entirely with your perspective but one of the arguments opposing the right to appeal is the compulsive nature that is associated with sex offending.

    Some argue that it’s a biological compulsion and one that will remain in spite of intensive therapy, years of incarceration or anything else. However, I believe that if the offender is motivated and willing to be rehabilitated the risks can be reduced but one has to have full trust and belief in the skills of those assessing the risks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *