The end of divorce for victims of domestic abuse?
Changes to the legal aid system could remove legal aid for many who need a divorce.
Does the introduction of legal aid reforms to family law cases by the government on 1 April 2013 mean the end of divorce as a way out for victims of domestic abuse?
In May 2012, the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LAPSO) came into force.
On 1 April 2013 the Act was reformed, bringing significant changes to the legal aid system in family law cases, and removing legal aid as an option for many in cases of divorce.
Whilst drastic changes have been made in terms of eligibility for cases of child contact and divorce proceedings, an individual is still able to claim legal aid if they can provide evidence of the existence of domestic abuse within their relationship.
On first reading, this appears to be a positive aspect to the changes.
But if you are a victim of domestic abuse, is the government really throwing you a lifeline by allowing legal aid claims to be made in this instance?
Take a closer look at the figures cited by the government on issues of violence against women.
‘Around 1.2 million women suffer domestic abuse, over 400,000 women are sexually assaulted, 60,000 women are raped and thousands more stalked each year.
‘These crimes are often hidden away behind closed doors, with the victim suffering in silence.
‘Fewer than 1 in 4 people who suffer abuse at the hands of their partner – and only around 1 in 10 women who experience serious sexual assault – report it to the police.’
These figures are taken from the gov.uk website which focuses on policy making.
These figures were published on 26 March 2013.
The amendments to the LAPSO Act 2012 came into force only a few days later on 1 April 2013.
Look more closely at the amendments and see how they sit alongside the figures quoted by the government.
Crucially – and less than one week after the government acknowledged the large number of women suffering abuse at the hands of their partners – women seeking to divorce their partners on grounds of domestic abuse will now need to provide evidence of domestic abuse before they will be offered any financial assistance to help dissolve the marriage.
The government has just explicitly said that fewer than one in four people will report abuse to the police; is the onus of proving that abuse as a means of funding your escape, truly the avenue the government has devised to help victims leave abusive relationships?
As incomprehensible as it sounds, it appears so.
From 1 April 2013, in order for a divorce from an abusive partner to be funded by legal aid, victims will need to provide one of the following specified forms of evidence in order to satisfy the government that they are indeed a victim of domestic violence:
‘Finding of fact by the court that they are a victim of domestic violence
‘An unspent conviction or caution against an individual for a domestic violence offence
‘Criminal proceedings for domestic violence that have not yet concluded
‘Protective injunctions in place such as a non-molestation order, an occupation order or a restraining order in the preceding two years
‘Medical evidence from a registered GP who will assert that the victim has presented to them with injuries consistent with domestic abuse in the preceding two years
‘Written confirmation from a domestic violence support agency that in the preceding two years a person was admitted for 24 hours or more to a refuge due to domestic violence
‘Written confirmation from social services which states that in the preceding two years the victim was assessed as being, or at risk of being a victim of domestic abuse
‘Letter from a Multi Agency Risk Assessment Conference chair confirming that the individual is at high risk of domestic violence and that a protective plan has been put in place in the preceding two years
‘The police have issued a caution against the perpetrator for a domestic violence offence in the preceding two years
‘The perpetrator is on a current order or one has been granted one for domestic violence offences in the preceding two years
‘An undertaking has been given to the court in place of an injunction order within a family relationship in the preceding two years but excluding cross undertakings’
When you first see this list, it appears to provide the victim with a number of options.
In reality though, the number of practical options available to victims caught up in the mechanics of an abusive relationship are very few.
The first option, for instance, requires private funding to attend court and to be legally represented.
If a victim is considering an application for legal aid this is unlikely to be something they can afford to do.
The remaining options also prove difficult if a victim has not disclosed the abuse to anyone else – as is so often the case.
Home Office Circular 003/2013 defines domestic violence and abuse as ‘Any incident or pattern of incidents of controlling, coercive or threatening behaviour, violence or abuse between those aged 16 or over who are or have been intimate partners or family members regardless of gender or sexuality.
‘This can encompass but is not limited to the following types of abuse: psychological, physical, sexual, financial emotional
‘Controlling behaviour is: a range of acts designed to make a person subordinate and/or dependent by isolating them from sources of support, exploiting their resources and capacities for personal gain, depriving them of the means needed for independence, resistance and escape and regulating their everyday behaviour.
‘Coercive behaviour is: an act or a pattern of acts of assault, threats, humiliation and intimidation or other abuse that is used to harm, punish, or frighten their victim.’
But if a victim has not previously reported the abuse to anyone, the remaining options are also not available to her.
Acknowledging abuse can take place over a number of years, as abuse doesn’t necessarily take place on a frequent basis.
The LASPO definition of domestic violence is any incident, or pattern of incidents, of controlling, coercive or threatening behaviour, violence or abuse (whether psychological, physical, sexual, financial or emotional) between individuals who are associated with each other.
The very definition of what constitutes abuse, as provided by the government, describes behaviour which isolates victims ‘from sources of support’.
It is not uncommon for perpetrators to control victims by making it nigh on impossible for them to seek support.
They will isolate them from their friends and family and withhold money to prevent them from socialising or having any reason to leave the house.
In such a situation, how will it be possible to provide the evidence listed in the government’s legal aid reforms?
The reforms make it difficult to understand how it is possible for a victim who does not have the means to fund it privately to divorce a perpetrator of domestic violence and abuse.
It appears that the effect of the amendments will be to completely trap a victim in an abusive relationship – and all this by a government which professes to be ‘determined to support victims in reporting these crimes, and to make sure perpetrators are brought to justice.’
The legal aid reforms appear to focus predominantly on physical violence – yet the LAPSO definition clearly states domestic abuse can take many forms.
Victims can be so afraid of their partner they do not tell anyone, making obtaining ‘objective evidence’ as necessitated by the new legal aid reforms, very difficult.
Given the complex nature of domestic abuse cases, it seems unreasonable to have placed a two-year time limit on a large number of the possible evidential options available to the abused partner.
Even where a protective order has been granted it must have been within the last two years.
It often takes far longer than two years for a victim of domestic abuse to develop the courage needed to seek support or report the issue to anyone.
Often the only form of possible evidence may be a report obtained from a GP.
But it seems the government has not properly considered what this means for a victim of domestic abuse.
Although, with that evidence secured, the victim may be entitled to legal aid for the divorce proceedings, very often the cost involved, which can be upwards of £50, is not something the victim can afford.
The government has boldly declared that ‘We all must do much more to prevent violence against women and girls happening at all…’, but is it?
When it comes to preventing further domestic abuse and violence – to enabling a victim to permanently leave an abusive marriage and to break free from an abusive partner – the government appears to want to hinder the process, not support it.
And we have to conclude that with these new family law legal aid reforms, the government has made it even harder for those victims of domestic abuse who cannot afford to fund a private case for divorce to find safety away from their abuser.
















I don’t think any of our so called support services is really aware of how psychopathic some men are towards women or children. Most males are raised now on media that refer to us as b*tches/female dogs, whores and the like. When dealing with a psychopath, as I know to my cost, the last thing you want to be doing is looking for support from a bunch of mealy mouthed well wishers who keep giving him the benefit of the doubt and that whatever he’s done to you, he really probably didn’t mean it. When you go for support, the first thing you really really depend on is that you are believed. In today’s war on women, that is about the last thing that most women can depend on, that they will be treated as believeable. And once they have been turned away or contacted by some bumbling idiot looking for proof that he really is as psychopathically disposed towards them as they say he is, he has probably been alerted and is now in punishment or obliterate mode. Not many council workers seem to have the imagination or experience to understand they are dealing with self groomed psychopaths with a taste for hurting the woman or children in their lives who they see as leaches holding them back or that have trapped them by being born.
Hi Vicki,
Regarding your comment:
‘And once they have been turned away or contacted by some bumbling idiot looking for proof that he really is as psychopathically disposed towards them as they say he is, he has probably been alerted and is now in punishment or obliterate mode.’
It’s a big concern isn’t it. When the abused partner leaves a relationship this is when they are most at risk from the abuser. Asking the victim to go and provide proof at a time when they are doing all they can to keep themselves safe seems an incomprehensible position to place someone in.
I have been raped twice, pushed out of a window by one ex and dragged round the house by my hair whilst pregnant by another. My six year old daughter has been sexually assaulted by a gang of five boys aged six and seven already … and all this violence against a chorus of people saying that the males didn’t really mean to be as violent as they were, to the point of writing to me that ‘unfortunately your daughter was punched several times by the same boy today in playtime’ … like it was an accident?
500,000 females suffer sexist attacks in the home every single year … against a backdrop of people saying these guys didn’t really mean it, didn’t understand, really do love their families etc etc etc. Try telling that to Mick Philpott’s kids…? I have looked in the eyes of several different men as they’ve punched me, raped me, hit my mum or lied to cover up violence against my daughter … believe you me, they all knew exactly what they were doing and meant every bit of it to regain their false authority over me – a supposedly equal autonomous human being but who they have been brought up to see as an inferior. Can’t have it both ways in this society …
Vicki, I commend you on your strength and wish you and your daughter all the very best for the future. I am truly shocked by your story and it sounds like you have had an incredibly tough time at the hands of abusive men.
Society has to act and it has to act now. Violence against women should not happen but making it harder for women to leave when it does occur is simply not acceptable.
By raising awareness and by sharing experiences we can hope that the powers that be will start to take notice and make the necessary changes which will provide a positive impact on the lives of victims.
I thank you for taking the time to comment and for sharing your experiences.
Thanks Donna. I am in the process of trying to get Dept of Ed to take action against the headmaster of my daughter’s old school and contemplating taking it all the way to the European Court of Human Rights whilst we are still in Europe. I have been sickened that so few parents of girls seem to be standing up against institutional covering up of violent sexist attacks on their daughters on school premises which is, after all, government property … how can these parents call themselves loving or the parents of boys that learn through pornography call themselves responsible? This country has gone back to front and upside down …