A brief history of infant feeding
The debate about whether breast is best goes back further than you might think.
The biomedical industry certainly threw fuel on the fiery debate about infant feeding when it began developing alternatives to human milk in the late nineteenth-century.
But don’t think that’s when the discussions over whether or not breast was best began – physicians, philosophers, and social activists have been debating the topic and prescribing maternal behaviour for a lot longer.
As far back as the oldest and most significant medical papyri from ancient Egypt, the Ebers Papyrus (circa 1550 BCE), there were remedies for women suffering from lactation failure:
“To get a supply of milk in a woman’s breast for suckling a child: Warm the bones of a sword fish in oil and rub her back with it.
Or: Let the woman sit cross-legged and eat fragrant bread of soused durra, while rubbing the parts with the poppy plant.”
If the prospect of a “sword fish oil” massage seems a little unappealing, consider the foundlings of eighteenth-century France, for whom the safest method of feeding was, apparently, directly from the udder of a goat or ass.
Soranus of Ephesus, a Greek physician from the first to second century CE, recommended that newborns should be given no food for the first two days of life – imagine the tears! – before being breastfed by a nurse until the twentieth day post-partum whereupon the mother would take over the responsibility of feeding.
Despite these recommendations, it was a widely accepted social practice for wealthier families in ancient history to employ a wet nurse.
Commonplace among the ancient Mesopotamians, Egyptians, Greeks, and Romans, so routine was the practice that it was regulated as a profession with laws and contracts – it is thought that wet nursing was introduced to the UK during the Roman occupation.
With the practice of wet nursing heavily entrenched among the wealthy, this gave rise to a public sentiment which was not just opposed to breastfeeding, but downright disgusted by it; one tract from 1695 declares: “a lady that will condescend to be a nurse, though to her own child, is become as unfashionable and ungenteel as a gentleman.”
Time passed but men continued to advise women about their bodies and how they should raise their children – notably philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778) who, despite abandoning at least one of his own children to the foundling hospital, urged for women to take inspiration from nature and breastfeed their infants.
At this time, the transmission of infectious diseases and opiates through breast milk was not understood and such was the demand for wet nurses that even those with venereal and other contagious diseases, as well as those addicted to opiates, found employment.
Rousseau’s comments did, therefore, have some worthwhile merit and by the mid eighteenth-century books and pamphlets drew upon his notion of “natural” feeding and advised against the use of wet nurses.
A number of historians have attributed aristocratic women’s reticence to breastfeed during this period on issues inexorably bound up with gender norms, including the impact it would have on their figures, the way it prevented them from wearing fashionable clothes, and restricted their access to social activities.
A woman’s decision not to breastfeed, however, was revealed by Mary Wollstonecraft (1759-1797) as sometimes the product of rather less frivolous, feminine fancy and rather more misogynistic coercion:
“There are many husbands so devoid of sense and parental affection that, during the first effervescence of voluptuous fondness, they refuse to let their wives suckle their children.”
Throughout history, there was often parity between the way that the very rich and the very poor fed their infants – although for very different reasons!
In the wake of the industrial revolution, social class and wealth continued to be the greatest determinants of how women fed their children.
As entire families relocated from rural to urban areas in search of work, low wages combined with a high cost of living often forced women out to work and they were left with little alternative than employing a peasant wet nurse – even once the safety of the practice was called into question.
However, as patent baby-foods developed in the mid nineteenth-century, their medical merit was propounded by doctors and Victorian childcare manuals enthusiastically recommended feeding infants Horlicks, Robinson’s and Nestle’s among others.
While Victorian breastfeeding mothers were told not only to abstain from sexual activity but that they should behave like cows and refrain from social contact, rest much and eat bland food (thankfully not grass!).
Advice no-nonsense child-guidance book writer, Mrs Panton, responded to with: “Let no mother condemn herself to be a common or ordinary ‘cow’ unless she has a real desire to nurse…”
The very rich, no doubt swayed by the health benefits promoted in new advertisements, were keen for their newborns to benefit from this significant scientific development, whereas for the very poor the decision to formula feed continued to be a decision borne out of need.
In the wake of World Wars, such was the necessity for many of the poorest women in the UK to return to work soon after giving birth, that the government issued a welfare food product called National Dried Milk, of which 124 million tins were distributed in Infant Welfare Clinics between 1945-1949, before discontinuation on safety grounds in the mid 1970s.
As a corollary of the second wave feminist movement, women began rejecting the authority of medical discourses about their bodies – including male authored accounts of childbirth and child-rearing – making them more empowered to breastfeed.
During this period, breastfeeding initiation rates rose significantly across the developed world and have remained relatively static since then.
And so the debate rages on about whether “Breast is Best”.
While this brief history of infant feeding is by no means exhaustive, it raises what has often been missing from the advice books and medical recommendations –exactly who is looking after Mum?











