A cross-cultural look at breastfeeding
Exploring what other cultures can teach us about supporting women as they become mothers.
When the government released statistics last month revealing the first fall in UK mothers initiating breastfeeding since the collection of data started in 2004, a number of news agencies reported the development as evidence that further policy is required to promote breastfeeding.
Last year’s fall, a mere 0.1 per cent, amounts to 5,700 fewer infants being breastfed over the course of the year. Is this really cause for concern, or have we got caught up in a numbers game?
Despite a few notable exceptions, there is little debate about the health benefits associated with breastfeeding for both mother and child, but breastfeeding is not a “one size fits all” practice and for some it is simply not the right fit.
In 2012/13 approximately 73.9 per cent of women initiated breastfeeding in the UK, but by 6-8 weeks after delivery that figure had dropped to just under half (48.6 per cent).
Such a sudden decline would seem to suggest that while many mothers are keen to breastfeed, once they return to their homes and daily stresses, they find that the practice becomes challenging and, in some cases, untenable.
Rather than attaching huge significance to the numbers for initiating breastfeeding around the country, would it not be more productive to find out why some women cease breastfeeding in those early stages, and develop strategies and public policy which will actually help them. Maybe then, the numbers will take care of themselves?
Looking at policy and cultural norms elsewhere provides a jumping-off point for this kind of approach, not just revealing systems that seem to be working elsewhere but also confirming where we are already making the right decisions.
Statistics released from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) in 2005 revealed that the lowest incidence of breastfeeding in Europe is recorded in France.
With this in mind, surely there’s nothing we can learn from the French?
Well…
Parental leave in France is 6 weeks prenatal and 10 weeks postnatal for the births of the first two children, but the country offers subsidised or free (depending on income) full-day childcare centres beginning at 2 or 3 years of age.
This points to the importance attached to work in the country, and an article by philosopher Elisabeth Badineter in part attributes the country’s low incidence of breastfeeding as a corollary of the primacy French women place upon their professional activity.
With 50 per cent of French mothers continuing to work full time after the birth of their first child, the statistics seem to bear this out.
In contrast only 30 per cent of UK women with dependent children work full time. So with a UK government backed report finding that getting mothers back into work could boost the country’s economic growth by 0.5 per cent a year, perhaps we can look to France to see how this might impact on breastfeeding and vice versa?
Too often the rhetoric around breastfeeding in the UK emphasises the “natural” practice of breastfeeding and carries with it assumed maternal-sacrifice or personal abnegation for the benefit of your child.
France, claims Elisabeth Badnineter, is free from the social pressures associated with being a “natural” mother and, “most mothers balk at the idea of giving up work, even in the first year of their child’s life, and most of them bottle feed.”
The infant feeding culture in France is arguably borne out of a feminist history which advocates the enfranchisement of women, and rightly or wrongly sees breastfeeding as a form of “slavery” which inextricably ties women to their position as mother.
Parenting forums and blogs reveal that perhaps the culture in France has swung too far against breastfeeding and assumptive formula feeding leaves those that want to breastfeed feeling unsupported both medically and socially.
Let’s look further afield.
In the Middle East, given the emphasis on modest dressing in public, one might expect the laws surrounding breastfeeding in public to be rigidly opposed to the practice.
Perhaps as a result of the Qur’an’s recommendation that breastfeeding should continue for the first two years of an infant’s life, in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) there are no formal rules against breastfeeding in public as long as mothers refrain from “unnecessary exposure”.
Maternity leave in the country, however, is a mere 45 days for those not working in governmental organisations, but women are permitted one hour in their working day to either express or return home and feed their infants.
Private nurseries abound in the country and accept infants from as young as 4 months.
While breastfeeding initiation rates in the country are high, only a third are exclusively breastfeeding at six months – something attributed to a lack of training among healthcare professionals, as well as, perhaps surprising given the Qur’an’s recommendation, limited peer support networks in the area.
I gave birth to both of my sons in the UAE. The hospital promoted breastfeeding and I have done so publicly in cafes and restaurants with never a hint of the kind of vitriol that breastfeeding mothers receive in more “liberal” countries.
So while the culture is certainly in favour of breastfeeding, with at least some policy provision to back it up, when feeding problems arise, as they so often do, my experience is that women abandon the practice because they can find nowhere to turn for advice.
The Middle East is by no means unique in this; a similar situation occurs in the United States.
In 1956, as Dubai founded its first police force, a group of seven mothers from Illinois were motivated to provide other mothers with a friendly and reliable breastfeeding advisory service which was available at any time of the day or night. Such was the success of La Leche League that it now has a presence in 67 countries around the world.
In 1956 the breastfeeding rate in the USA was just 20 per cent, and while the current breastfeeding initiation rate is just under 75 per cent, this drops to 15 per cent for those exclusively breastfeeding at six months.
This steep decline is often blamed on current federal legislation and, despite Obama’s 2010 amendment which requires employers to “provide reasonable break time for an employee to express breast milk for her nursing child for one year after the child’s birth”, US women are still only guaranteed a miserly 12 weeks of unpaid maternity leave.
With over half of US mothers with infants under six months old returning to work, is it really any wonder that they turn to synthetic alternatives to feed their children?
Like the UK, the US has a culture of disapproval when it comes to breastfeeding in public.
Despite having laws in 45 of the USA’s 50 states which specifically allow women to breastfeed in any public or private location, stories about lactivist protests being triggered by narrow-minded and downright illegal restrictions being placed on breastfeeding in public are depressingly common.
A country’s breastfeeding rate is clearly tied to a number of wider cultural issues, as well as matters of government policy.
A mother’s milk supply often takes several months to stabilise, so employment legislation should ensure adequate paid parental leave and provision needs to be made for women to express in the course of their working day, so that those who are keen to return to work can do so without needing to abandon breastfeeding.
Since the health benefits of breastfeeding for both mother and infant are widely recognised , it is unsurprising that most countries in the developed world extoll breastfeeding as the best option.
But support must be available, above and beyond the obligatory visit from the lactation consultant before being discharged from hospital.
Support at flexible times and in a variety of different forms, so that when problems arise women have the necessary networks to support them through such a physically arduous and emotionally draining time.
While the French medical approach can hardly be heralded as the best option for new mothers who want to breastfeed, perhaps there is something to be said for supporting those that are keen to return to work and recognising that the “natural” mother is not so “natural” for everyone.
Surely the most complicated issue surrounding breastfeeding, however, is society’s reaction to breastfeeding in public.
At a time when women often already feel cut off from their former life, the prospect of being confined to the house so that they can feed their baby “on demand” can be a step too far for many.
In the Middle East, children are celebrated as a blessing, and as a result, there are no restrictions on their presence, in even the most up-market of establishments – even if they need to feed.
How can we breed this kind of acceptance in the UK?
Honestly, I’m not sure, but more open and frank discussion must be a move in the right direction.
















I find it interesting that there is always such a forensic study of women’s choices around feeding their babies without such a cross examination of the environment the women is making those choices in. I found the person who had the most influence on my parenting choices, my co parent (the father) was not held accountable for his support or lack of it in what options were open to the mother at all. My ex’s support was to leave me totally unaided and tell me all i had to do was flop a [breast] out to breast feed. I was also attacked verbally by a bunch of boys in a car park whilst feeding my daughter in my car quietly. I for one am tired of articles about parenting that do not address the invisible 50% of the partnership and hold them to account for how much they actively parent alongside their team mate? In africa they say it takes a village to bring up a child, in the uk we make it a one person job and not even junior doctors are left on call 24/7 for years on end.