Gender segregation in apprenticeships
The number of women apprentices may have increased, but women are still doing the poorly paid jobs.
Alison Johnstone, Green MSP for Lothian and a member of Holyrood’s economy committee, has challenged Scotland’s First Minister Alec Salmond to do more to help women play a full part in economic recovery.
She highlighted the fact that the UK government’s welfare reforms are having a significant impact on women, including for many the loss of financial independence.
And she pointed towards childcare and apprenticeships as key areas for the Scottish government to tackle.
“Investing in a transformative, affordable childcare system would provide hundreds of jobs and would enable thousands of women to pursue work and education, boosting economic recovery,” Johnstone said.
“I pointed out to the First Minister that the most popular modern apprenticeships are severely gender segregated and that while the number of women apprentices may have increased women are still doing the poorly paid jobs.”
“I’m glad the First Minister accepted my point that sectors such as construction remain male-dominated and I will continue to press for women to be given the chance to play a full and fair part in Scotland’s economic recovery.”
The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) in Scotland, is the independent advocate for equality and human rights in Britain.
Their report on inequalities in accessing Modern Apprenticeships, the Scottish government’s flagship training programme, showed that currently:
• disabled people take up less than 0.5 per cent of all apprenticeship places
• gendered segregation in apprenticeships is still unacceptably high – less than 2 per cent of engineering or construction placements go to women
• Scotland is the only part of the UK where men’s access to apprenticeships is higher than women’s
• ethnic minorities also have poor access – less than 2 per cent of all apprenticeships in Scotland are offered to ethnic minorities
• although men are increasingly moving into ‘traditionally female’ apprenticeship programmes, e.g. the care sector, there is no evidence of women moving into ‘traditionally male’ apprenticeships
Speaking about the report, Alastair Pringle, the EHRC’s director in Scotland, said: “At a time when the government is moving people from welfare into work, the accessibility of training for skills is essential.
“Our report shows that out of the 26,000 apprenticeships placements available in Scotland, only 74 disabled people have been able to take up places.”
The report also shows that occupational segregation remains a significant issue in apprenticeships programmes, with little or no progress being made in trying to open up employment opportunities in traditionally “male” sectors of the economy such as engineering and construction, where men occupy 98 per cent of the available apprenticeship placements.
The research, conducted by Heriot-Watt University for the EHRC, draws on both official and unpublished data.
As well as focussing on Modern Apprenticeships, the research also looks at the extent to which Scotland’s industries are aware of equality issues and the extent to which conditions can be placed on contractors to drive up their equality performance.
Pringle went on to say: “The Scottish government has invested a great deal of money in developing the Scottish economy by boosting the skills of its workforce.
“It is therefore disappointing to see that the profile of apprenticeship opportunities is a very old one – men doing the “heavy work” like building; women doing the “softer work” like caring and teaching; and disabled people not having much work at all.
“If we are to emerge from the recession successfully, we need to harness the talents of all of Scotland’s people. This report shows that we are missing a trick by failing to maximise the potential of all Scotland’s people.
“We believe that the government needs to demand greater effort from their contractors to drive up the representation of ethnic minorities and disabled people and to open up occupations which have traditionally been “men only” to young women apprenticeships.”











