subscribe: Posts | Comments

Lily Allen’s comeback video

0 comments

lily allenNothing at all to do with race?

If you are a human who has access to an internet connection – which seems likely given that you are currently reading this – then last week you probably noticed several things: people still like cats, Jennifer Lawrence has had a haircut, and Lily Allen has released a new music video.

The video for ‘Hard Out Here’ opens with Allen lying on a plastic surgeon’s operating table while being told that she has ‘let herself go’, and goes on to parody a host of sexist music video tropes, aiming some balloon-shaped digs at Robin Thicke along the way.

But the video has also been accused of being racist for its use of twerking by scantily clad black dancers.

Here two writers present opposing sides of the argument.

Hard Out Here: A bold parody of music industry sexism

by Ruby Guyatt

In a blog Allen has defended the video for Hard Out Here, stating that the dancers were chosen for their ability rather than their race. She adds that: ‘The video is meant to be a lighthearted satirical video that deals with objectification of women within modern pop culture. It has nothing to do with race, at all.’

Much of the criticism of the video ignores the simple fact that, while four of the dancers are black, three (plus Lily) are not. As Jameela Jamil has pointed out, the video also features a non-black dancer being photographed in her underwear, a white dancer being spanked on all fours, and a black dancer sharing ‘tips’ with a non-black dancer.

Furthermore, as Allen has stated online and several of the dancers have themselves reiterated on Twitter, the women in the video were hired for their dancing ability, not because of their race.

While acknowledging that some elements of the video are problematic, Guardian commentator Ellie Mae O’Hagan argues that Allen should not be expected to represent all feminism.

I am inclined to agree. Lily Allen is a popstar, and as such has never claimed to be a spokeswoman for intersectional feminism. I think it is a shame that Allen does not take the opportunity to address the twin problems of cultural appropriation and white objectification of black bodies in music videos, but I do not think that she should have to do so in order to avoid accusations of racism.

Hard Out Here may not be perfect, but it is a bold parody of sexism in the music industry – a problem that Allen has now made impossible to ignore.

Lily, you disappoint me

by Heather Kennedy

I’ve watched Lily’s Allen infamous comeback video Hard Out Here twice now and winced my way through it each time.

You don’t need a PhD in cultural theory to see how this uses de-humanising stereotypes and plays into the convention of white women flaunting their power and autonomy over their Black sisters.

As blogger Batty Mamzelle argues; “Here is Lily Allen, a white (presumably feminist) woman, making a statement about her autonomy, sexual agency and self worth, while mocking the very same in black women.”

Responding to criticisms on her blog Allen declares “[the video] has nothing to do with race, at all.”

Well thanks for clearing that up.

Allen has been commenting on media representations long enough to understand that good intentions aside, images have potent currency of their own.

You can’t use deliberately provocative imagery to make a comment about injustice then deny all responsibility when you unwittingly endorse other structures of injustice you’re less familiar with. Especially when those structures are so bleeding obvious. Like mainstream feminism being dominated by white voices. Like the music industry amplifying a grand tradition of muted, de-humanised Black women choreographed by the desires and fetishes of other people.

Look, none of us are perfect. And the learning which takes us beyond our own experience into empathy and understanding with other people is a life’s work. But it’s disappointing Allen couldn’t have taken a step back to reflect on criticisms made of her video, asking herself whether there was something she was missing. There’s not much evidence of this in the defensive, angry tone of her blog.

At best Allen’s choices for this video were blunderingly ignorant, not something I can easily stomach from the self-styled ‘thinking woman’ of pop. “Don’t need to shake my arse for you cos I’ve got a brain” she sings in Hard Out Here.

Shame she couldn’t engage said brain when she gave the thumbs up to near naked Black women slapping one another’s champagne drenched bum cheeks while she parades through dance sequences every bit the powerful ringmaster, engaging the viewer with a knowing smile, stylishly attired in a range of tasteful outfits.

“Always trust the injustice cos it ain’t going away” Allen sings.

She ain’t lying.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *