subscribe: Posts | Comments

Conviction rates for domestic violence fall

0 comments

Rt Hon Yvette Cooper MP, reports of domestic violence have risen, but fewer are leading to successful prosecutionNew data shows that reports of domestic violence have risen, but fewer are leading to successful prosecution.

In Warwickshire, 7,434 incidents of domestic violence or rape were reported in 2012-13. Only 217 cases ended with a conviction.

This example marks the worst conviction rate (2.92 per cent) in the country and has been revealed by data collected by the office of Labour’s shadow home secretary, Yvette Cooper, earlier this month.

The problem, however, is not confined to one or even two counties.

In the most comprehensive data on conviction rates for domestic violence and rape collected since the current coalition government came to power, it has been uncovered that while reported incidents of domestic violence increased by 11 per cent from 2010-11 to 2012-13, convictions in the same period in fact reduced by 11 per cent.

That equates to 838,000 reported incidents of domestic abuse in England and Wales during 2012-13 and just 52,500 of those resulting in a conviction.

The data shows that nearly 90 per cent of all reports of domestic violence to police forces in England and Wales were taken no further: police referred just 10.5 per cent of the cases to the Crown Prosecution Service in 2012-13 compared to 12.1 per cent  in 2009-10.

In addition, the 16,300 rape offences recorded by police in 2012-13 led to just 2,300 convictions.

That ratio marks the first time since 2008 that rape convictions have dropped below 15 per cent of the overall number of incidents.

Some argue that increased reports reflect historical abuse being reported more frequently in the wake of the Jimmy Savile scandal, and suggest it is perhaps unsurprising that such reports are harder to convict.

High-profile trials ending in ‘not guilty’ verdicts – for example in the cases of William Roache and Dave Lee Travis – have also been cited as having perhaps discouraged local police authorities from taking reports through to prosecution.

However, Yvette Cooper has blamed the government, and said: “The scale of domestic abuse is shocking. The Government and the Home Secretary have turned their backs on this issue.

“Support and justice for victims is getting worse not better as a result of their failure.”

“There has been an appalling lack of leadership from [Home Secretary] Theresa May. Why has so little been done to investigate this drop?

“The Home Secretary is failing to make ending violence against women a priority for the criminal justice system and the clock is being turned backwards as a result,” she continued.

Cooper established that Labour would commit to publishing domestic abuse and sexual violence league tables for every police force across England and Wales in a bid to expose poor performance and raise standards.

In response, the coalition’s Crime Prevention Minister, Norman Baker, released a statement pointing out that the latest data from the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) shows the highest ever conviction rate for violence against women and girls, and that the government already has investigations underway to assess how police forces deal with rape and domestic abuse.

“More victims are coming forward to talk about rape and domestic violence and I am determined to improve the response at every point in the criminal justice system to address these horrific and inexcusable acts”, he added.

Whatever the political stance, it is clear that the problem of domestic and sexual violence is a huge and under-addressed problem in the UK.

A recent survey by the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) highlighted that 44 per cent of UK women had suffered some form of physical and/or sexual violence, with 29 per cent of having suffered violence at the hands of a current or previous partner.

With figures like that, we just cannot afford a drop in conviction rates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *