Should we celebrate women making the Forbes list?
Record numbers of women are now billionaires, according to the 2014 Forbes list.
But what exactly does that mean?
‘Girl Power!’ the Daily Mail said of the record number of women making the 2014 Forbes list of billionaires.
But is that really the message the record sends out?
There are indeed a record number of female billionaires on the Forbes list, at 172 that is up 60 per cent from 2012 and 25 per cent from 2013.
Forty-two women have made the list for the first time in 2014.
They include Facebook CEO Sheryl Sandberg; the CEO of betting firm Bet365 Denise Coates; Nigerian business tycoon Folorunsho Alakija; and the granddaughters of Estee Lauder who are set to take the helm of Clinique this year, Aerin Lauder Zinterhofer and Jane Lauder.
Forbes is trying to tout this as a win for gender equality, claiming that the female billionaires on the list are also ‘wielding their vast influence across multiple spheres’ by simultaneously appearing on Forbes’ annual 100 Most Powerful Women ranking.
Well, at least, ten of them are.
Forbes also highlights that nearly one fifth – nearly one fifth! – of women on the list were even instrumental in the building of their own fortunes, a number which has more than doubled in the past three years with ‘promising’ momentum.
However, ‘nearly one fifth’ also equates to only 32 out of 172 women actually creating their own fortunes, with the rest having inherited their wealth from a spouse or parent.
Even Forbes has to admit that women remain in the ‘extreme minority’ of the 1,080 self-made billionaires on the list.
They make up just 1.9 per cent, in fact.
Sure, some women are getting wealthier, but very few are doing so by their own means.
And sure, some women are making it in traditionally male-dominated industries; however Sandberg is joining Meg Whitman of Hewlett-Packard and they are the only two female technology billionaires on the list.
Sure, women are taking more of the global super wealth, but they still only make up 172 of 1,645 listees – roughly 10 per cent.
So what is the message we send out by celebrating this as a step towards gender equality?
Firstly, if we are fighting for equal representation of women at all levels of society figures such as 10 per cent are simply not enough.
Secondly, that the vast majority of female listees inherited rather than earned their wealth promotes the outdated idea that women are only as successful as their family and spousal connections allow them to be.
Thirdly, the Forbes list of billionaires, both male and female, reflects another worrying process: the concentration of wealth in the hands of the few.
According to a 2014 Oxfam report, almost half of the world’s wealth is now owned by just one per cent of the world’s population; and the wealth of that one per cent totals 65 times the total wealth of the bottom half of the world’s population.
In addition, gaps are widening.
Seven out of ten people live in countries where economic inequality has increased in the last 30 years, and the richest one per cent have increased their share of income in 24 out of 26 countries between 1980 and 2012.
This extreme economic inequality, Oxfam argues, is not only morally questionable, it also compounds other inequalities, such as those between men and women.
A recent BBC report for International Women’s Day, 8 March, found that the G20 group of leading industrial nations had no representative in the top 10 countries where women have equal opportunities to participate in economics and politics, health and education.
The UK ranked eighteenth and the US ranked twenty third in the world, below countries such as the Phillippines (fifth) and Nicaragua (tenth).
The Fawcett Society highlights that both overall economic inequality and women’s economic inequality are high in the UK. Women are more likely to be employed in low paid, part-time work, more likely to head a single parent household, likely to have fewer financial assets and more likely to live in poverty, especially in older age.
The undeniable truth is that economic inequality is bad for everyone, especially women.
In celebrating the successes of a few women at the top, then, do we forget the masses of women struggling at the bottom?
If so, the Forbes list makes for disheartening, rather than encouraging, reading.











