subscribe: Posts | Comments

Game of Thrones – and that scene

0 comments

game of thrones scene sparks internet debate and rape questionsControversial Game of Thrones scene sparks internet-wide discussion for all the wrong reasons.

Warning: Spoilers Ahead.

If it wasn’t already clear, major spoilers abound in this article for Game of Thrones, season four.

To recap, one of the beginning scenes in the third episode of this season is Jaime Lannister forcing himself on his twin sister, next to the dead body of their son.

It remains unclear as to why exactly the directors and writers chose to frame the scene in this way, when in the books it is consensual (though still disturbing) sex.

One interpretation, the most charitable one, is that perhaps they did not realise that many viewers would interpret the scene as rape.

This is backed up by the statement from Alex Graves, director of the scene, who said: “Well, it becomes consensual at the end, because anything for [Cersei and Jaime] ultimately results in a turn-on, especially a power struggle.”

He also expressed one of those sentiments that many of us have heard so often: “And also, the other thing that I think is clear before they hit the ground is she starts to make out with him.

“The big things to us that were so important, and that hopefully were not missed, is that before he rips her undergarment, she’s way into kissing him back. She’s kissing him aplenty.”

In other words, he repeats the same thing many of us have heard when discussing sexual assault and rape: well, she was kissing him/flirting with him/leading him on, so obviously she actually wanted it.

During the whole scene, Cersei is saying no, attempting to push Jaime away, and at the end she is sobbing.

It’s hard to imagine how anyone could think these actions expressed consent.

There is always the possibility that, after several misogynistic acts – Daenarys’ rape by Khal Drogo comes to mind, as does Ros’s death, her friend whom Joffrey forced her to beat, and the poor girl Ramsay Snow had torn apart by dogs – those involved in the show are simply beginning to get acclimatised to violence against women.

Given that there is only one woman out of nine current writers and directors, it is possible that the perspective of the thousands of women who have had something similar happen to them was simply not considered.

But it is important for anyone who creates art to remember that they are not creating it in a vacuum.

Directors and writers of popular shows like Game of Thrones should never lose sight of that fact.

They should never forget that millions of people from all sorts of backgrounds will be watching what they make.

Perhaps after the backlash over this, they will take it into consideration in the future.

But somehow, I doubt it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *