Problems with the Isla Vista media coverage
Media Spotlight looks at 3 problems with the Isla Vista media coverage.
A 22 year-old man went on a shooting and stabbing rampage on 23 May near the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB) campus in Isla Vista, USA, killing six students and injuring 13 more.
The confirmed suspect, Elliot Rodgers, claimed it was his “day of retribution” for a lifetime of rejection by women.
Elliot Rodgers’s crimes testify to the dangers of misogyny and racism, but the media coverage of the killings are similarly worrying.
Media Spotlight looks at 3 problems with the Isla Vista media coverage.
1) Mental health over misogyny
‘Tomorrow is the day of retribution, the day in which I will have my revenge . . . you girls aren’t attracted to me, but I will punish you all for it. I’ll take great pleasure in slaughtering all of you. You will finally see that I am in truth the superior one, the true alpha male.’
Despite the fact that in his 140-page manifesto Elliot Rodgers outlined his intention to seek ‘retribution’ against women who he says sexually rejected him, and recorded YouTube videos in which he calmly outlined how he would ‘slaughter every single spoiled, stuck-up, blond slut I see’, some media outlets have been reluctant to use the word ‘misogyny’ when reporting on the killings.
The Isla Vista killings were not necessarily an either/or situation.
To say that Rodgers had mental difficulties is not to diminish the role misogynistic culture played in the tragedy, or to imply that his actions were the direct cause of his mental health.
However, to stress Rodgers’ mental health over his misogyny – to dismiss his actions as simply those of a mad man – is to ignore his toxic ideology, which Laurie Penny summarised clearly:
‘Women owe men. Women, as a class, as a sex, owe men sex, love, attention, “adoration”, in Rodger’s words. We owe them respect and obedience, and our refusal to give it to them is to blame for their anger, their violence – stupid sluts get what they deserve.’
2) Objectification of the women Rodgers hated
As well as downplaying the part played by misogyny in Eliot Rodgers’ actions, in the week and a half since the killings much of the media has fetishised the women believed to have been those whom Rodger blamed for rejecting him.
There have been dozens of articles published – alongside bikini shots of the women Rodgers saw as objects to be viewed and used by him.
Not only does this smack of victim-blaming, but it panders to the same cultural trends that themselves contributed to Rodgers’ actions.
3) Racism
‘I came across this Asian guy who was talking to a white girl. The sight of that filled me with rage. I always felt as if white girls thought less of me because I was half-Asian, but then I see this white girl at the party talking to a full-blooded Asian. I never had that kind of attention from a white girl!’
A third area where the media should be held to account over Isla Vista coverage is their frequent suppression of the racial component to Rodgers’ crime.
Well-intended articles like White Guy Killer Syndrome: Elliot Rodger’s Deadly Privileged Rage, and Elliot Rodger is ‘White’: What the Santa Barbara Shooter Can Teach Us About Race and Masculinity themselves ignore the fact that Rodgers was mixed-race.
Misogyny was not the only ideological component behind the killings.
Throughout his manifesto Rodgers repeatedly expresses disgust at ‘hot white girls’ being in relationships with black or Asian men, and his first three victims – Cheng Yuan “James” Hong, 20; George Chen, 19; and Weihan “David” Wang, 20 – were all Asian.











