The truth about the ‘fertility cliff’
We need to admit that we do not know as much as we think about female fertility.
TV presenter Kirstie Allsopp caused a furore earlier this month by suggesting that young women should consider the limits of their fertility ‘window’ when planning their lives.
“Nature is not with you and I. Nature is not a feminist,” she said, on BBC TV.
Allsopp used the sort of emotive terms which often surround this issue.
She argued that female fertility “falls off a cliff” after 35 and backed up her claims with references to Nature as if that makes age-related infertility a hard and fast cosmic law.
Female fertility – how to manage it, how to plan around it, what to do with the lack of it – is indeed a highly personal and emotive issue.
It is the sort of issue on which so much depends and yet the data surrounding it is, at best, unclear.
But many often-cited statistics surrounding the ‘fertility cliff’ at 35 have been highlighted as being woefully out of date.
Dr Jean Twenge, professor of psychology at San Diego State University, published her findings about fertility data last year in The Atlantic.
She reported that one widely cited statistic – that one in three women aged 35 to 39 will not be pregnant after a year of trying – is from a 2004 article in the journal Human Reproduction.
However, that article uses data from French birth records from 1670 to 1830, because the researchers needed a population not using contraception.
Twenge found that there are few well-designed studies of natural fertility and age which studied women born in the 2oth century, and that the most ominous of the historical data is the most highly publicised, something that she dubs ‘one of the more spectacular examples of the mainstream media’s failure to correctly report on and interpret scientific research’.
The few more recent studies that do exist show a much more nuanced picture.
For example Twenge quotes the David Dunson study published in Obstetrics & Gynecology in 2004 studied European women and found that when having sex at least twice a week, 82 per cent of 35 to 39 year-old women conceived within a year, compared to 86 per cent of 27 to 34 year-old women – a four per cent difference.
And a Boston University study published in 2013 found only a six per cent drop in fertility levels within a year between the 20 to 34 year-old women studied and their 35 to 40 year-old counterparts.
In response to studies like these, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) updated its guidance on fertility in 2013.
It now says that over 80 per cent of couples will conceive within a year if the woman is aged under 40 and has regular sex without using contraception.
Another 10 per cent will conceive in the second year of trying.
The next 10 per cent make up the generally agreed percentage of women said to be affected by infertility in the UK.
And many of those women would struggle with infertility regardless of their age.
So where is the ‘fertility cliff’ at 35 in the data?
The head of assisted reproduction at Guy’s and St Thomas’ Hospital in London, Yacoub Khalaf, explained that it is just not that simple.
“It is tempting to want a black and white answer, but biology doesn’t work that way…
“Some women find it difficult to conceive in their late 20s, while others don’t have a problem into their 40s,” he told the BBC.
It is more appropriate to consider that on average women experience a slow decline in fertility from 35 as the quality and quantity of their ova decline, a process which speeds up after 40.
However, it is also important that we acknowledge that the most we can say about female fertility is that it is individual to each woman.
“I think that doctors who give blanket advice to populations… are making all sorts of presumptions,” said leading fertility expert Professor Lord Winston.
“We eventually find out that so much of this advice is spurious and unnecessary and often wrong.”
In short, the hype around the so-called ‘fertility cliff’ is just another example of the media putting pressure on women.
Interestingly, many studies have found that male sperm counts have been steadily decreasing over years, but the media is not nearly as interested in that.
We do need to be honest with women, as Allsopp urges, about their reproductive health, however that means acknowledging that the ‘facts’ are not as clear-cut as Allsopp would have people think.
Considering that our society already hounds women about their bodies, their relationships, their careers or lack thereof, their family-work balance, the state of their homes and wardrobes, we do not need to add unnecessary scaremongering about ‘fertility cliffs’ to that list with no very sound data to prove it.











