subscribe: Posts | Comments

Legal aid residence test deemed unlawful

0 comments

legal aaid ruling, unlawful, judges, grayling, RefugeIt would prevent the most vulnerable people in society from accessing legal protection.

In 2013 the Ministry of Justice issued a consultation paper entitled ‘Transforming Legal Aid’.

The consultation paper announced a further round of cuts to legal aid, following closely in the wake of the Legal Aid Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO) which came into force on 1 April 2013.

The proposals, if implemented, would mean that many migrants and prisoners would no longer be eligible for legal aid.

Access to judicial review would be restricted.

And it would see the creation of a residence test for civil legal aid restricting eligibility to those with at least 12 months’ continuous “lawful residence”.

On 7 July we asked for your support in joining a Thunderclap against the implementation of the Legal Aid Residence Test.

The Thunderclap #iamforjustice on 8 July was a great success. Thank you, if you joined in and supported it.

On 9 July there was a vote on this ‘Residence Test’ in Parliament. It was approved – by a margin of 70 votes.

Peers in the House of Lords, who have been more resistant to cuts in legal aid, are due to vote on the order next week.

However, the government’s attempt to introduce a residence test for legal aid was struck down by three senior judges ruling in the High Court this week.

Three senior judges unanimously declared that the draft regulations, now waiting for a House of Lords vote on 21 July, cannot be enacted by means of secondary legislation.

Lord Justice Moses said: “The Ministry of Justice described LASPO as ‘targeting legal aid at the most serious cases which have sufficient priority to justify the use of public funds’.

He added: “Within the system provided by LASPO, the United Kingdom is not permitted to discriminate against non-residents on the grounds that to do so might save costs.”

Moses dismissed Justice Secretary Chris Grayling’s claim that the reforms would have public support, saying: “In the context of a discriminatory provision relating to legal assistance, invoking public confidence amounts to little more than reliance on public prejudice.”

Remarking on the judgment, Sandra Horley, chief executive of national domestic violence charity Refuge, said: “I am pleased that the high court has struck down proposals to introduce a ‘residence test’ requirement for legal aid on the grounds that it would be discriminatory and unlawful.

“Refuge had serious concerns about this proposal, which would prevent the most vulnerable people in society from accessing legal protection – including victims of domestic violence and human trafficking.

“When survivors of violence and abuse make the extraordinarily brave step of speaking out against their abusers, it is vital that they are supported by the full force of the law.

“Attempting to restrict legal aid on the basis of ‘residency’ would deny life-saving protection to many victims.”

She added: “It is now up to the House of Lords to ensure that these measures are dropped when it votes on this issue next week.

“I urge members of the Lords to consider the court’s ruling and to safeguard the right to justice for all victims of violence and abuse.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *