subscribe: Posts | Comments

Rape case coverage still an obstacle to justice

0 comments

Media coverage of women involved in rape cases does not help encourage victims to come forward. Photo: Jon S/FlickrToo much focus on women’s personal lives and speculation about motive.

The media coverage of  women whose rape claims are deemed false is yet another obstacle to victims coming forward.

A student barrister has received a three and a half year jail sentence after being found guilty of falsely accusing her former boyfriend of raping and assaulting her.

Rhiannon Brooker’s former partner, Paul Fensome, was originally jailed for 37 days after she made the accusations.

However, bruises and injuries Brooker presented as evidence were subsequently deemed to have been self-inflicted and it was found that Fensome had alibis for some of the occasions he had been accused of rape, so the focus turned instead on Brooker.

Under investigation, which reportedly included a morning home raid, the seizing of childhood diaries and extensive questioning about traumatic events in her past, Brooker briefly admitted that the claims were false before reiterating that the claims were true.

Based on this admission, Fensome received £38,000 compensation and Avon and Somerset police decided it was in the public interest to charge Brooker with perverting the course of justice.

During the ten-week trial that followed, Brooker was accused of staging the injuries and making the claims because she was failing her Bar exams, despite her being among the top ten per cent of students on her course.

Numerous witnesses from Brooker’s past were called to testify, and her character was subject to intense speculation both in court and in the media.

The sentencing judge, Julian Lambert, argued that that claims like Brookers’ which are deemed false made it more difficult for ‘real rape victims’ to be believed in court.

And a police spokesperson said, “False claims have a clear adverse impact on victims reporting incidents to police and the prosecution of genuine cases.”

Crown advocate for the Crown Prosecution Service, James Ward, said: “This case was brought both to protect the integrity of genuine rape allegations and victims of rape and because of the devastating effects false allegations of sexual offending can have on genuine victims, innocent people so accused and their families.”

“It would be a travesty if this case were to undermine the confidence and experiences of victims,” Chief Superintendent Sarah Crew, force lead for rape and sexual offences at Avon and Somerset police, added.

“We want to assure all victims of rape, sexual assault and domestic abuse that we will listen to and support you every step of the way.”

However, some argue the decision to jail Brooker for making the claims will deter the very people the authorities are hoping to encourage to come forward and report rapes and domestic abuse.

Women’s rights campaigners claim that such a severe sentence will put off rape victims from going to the police for fear they could face prosecution if their allegations are not proven.

More than a dozen lawyers and organisations, including the campaign group Women Against Rape (WAR) who had a representative at Brooker’s trial, wrote to the judge.

‘The prosecution [of Brooker] was not in the public interest. A prison sentence will put even more women off reporting, enabling even more attacks from violent men.

‘The resources spent on prosecuting Ms Brooker should have been put into prosecuting rapists and other violent men,’ they argued.

WAR has also released a press statement arguing that Brooker only retracted her claims under the intensity of the police interrogation to try and ‘make it all go away’.

WAR have called Brooker’s sentence a miscarriage of justice which forms part of a broader problem where rape and domestic abuse victims are mistreated by the police.

‘In our experience, charges against women often follow negligent and biased police investigations.

‘In many rape cases brought to us, police lost evidence or did not gather it, witnesses were not interviewed, statements were not taken,’ WAR said.

However, the police reject claims by WAR that it prosecuted Brooker to cover its back.

What is clear is that reports of rape deemed false are punished more harshly in the UK than in the US, where accusers are unlikely to receive a jail sentence.

‘Reporting [of rape and abuse in the UK] has increased in the wake of the Savile and other scandalous cases where women were not only disbelieved but threatened with prosecution.

‘If the authorities want to turn the clock back and put women off from coming forward, prosecutions like this are a very effective deterrent,’ WAR said in their press release.

However, the media coverage of the case has also played a role in punishing Brooker.

Uninterested in objectivity, the media coverage has been almost exclusively focused on assassinating Brooker’s character, painting her as suicidal, delusional, manipulative, conniving and an unfit mother to her nine-month-old baby, among other unsavoury portrayals.

The disproportionate focus on Brooker’s personal life and speculation about her motives is horribly indicative of how women involved in rape cases are put on trial not only in the court room but also across the pages of the newspapers.

And knowing tabloid character assassination probably lies ahead is just one more deterrent for victims of rape and domestic violence, stopping them from coming forward.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *