‘Revenge porn’ laws proposed
‘Society needs to deliver a message that this is unacceptable and that the victim is in no way responsible’.
An amendment to the Criminal Courts and Justice Bill has been proposed which would make broadcasting explicit material of ex-partners a criminal act.
The amendment seeks to address the rising problem of so-called ‘revenge porn’ where images or videos of ex-partners are shared via the internet without the ex-partner’s consent, usually as a means of public humiliation after a relationship break-up.
Specifically, the amendment proposes to criminalise the online publishing without consent of images which are of ‘an intimate or pornographic nature’.
The pictures would have to be of an identifiable person who had, at the time the pictures were taken, a reasonable expectation that the images would be kept private.
The amendment proposes a maximum sentence of one year in prison.
It was tabled by Liberal Democrats Lord Marks and Baroness Grender earlier this month as the Criminal Courts and Justice Bill passed through the House of Lords and, if accepted into the full Bill, could pass into law within weeks.
‘We hope to work closely with Ministers within the Ministry of Justice to ensure that this offence reaches the statute book,’ said Lord Marks.
A similar proposal was made in Scotland earlier this year by the Lord Advocate Frank Mulholland QC when he also called for specific legislation to tackle ‘revenge porn’.
“We can and do prosecute this crime robustly using existing legislation,” Mulholland said, “However, it is a growing problem and specific legislation would send a signal to those who do this that they face jail.”
“Following discussions with campaigners I believe there is significant under-reporting of this issue, possibly because those affected are too embarrassed to come forward or fear they will be blamed…
“Society needs to deliver a message that this is unacceptable and that the victim is in no way responsible just because they may have consented to an image being taken for personal use,” he added.
In England, Liberal Democrat MP Julian Huppert, who has led the campaign to create targeted legislation on this issue, said that there is currently no sanction in place because ‘revenge porn’ is not technically considered a crime.
“At the moment it is not a criminal offence to share the image because the photo was taken legitimately. Consent was given for the photo or the film, but not for it to be shared,” he said at the Commons debate on the Queen’s speech last month.
“Typically, the problem is not covered under the harassment legislation, which requires something to have happened more than once, but once the image has been published online, it is broadcast forever more,” he added.
Explaining his reasoning behind the campaign, Huppert said: “I do not often call for new criminal sanctions – it is not my natural style.
“In this case, however, I think we need to make a criminal sanction available when people share indecent images in the knowledge that consent would not have been given.”
Justice Secretary Chris Grayling said the recent tabling of the amendment was part of government efforts to promote “serious discussions” on the growing issue, especially in light of the links between the practice and a number of suicides.
However some see it as a ‘civil’ rather than a ‘criminal’ issue.
For example, Gabrielle Guillemin, a legal officer of international free speech campaign Article 19, has called for “civil remedies” to the problem.
“We have seen a lot of legislation, for example in the United States, to address this particular issue, but you would question whether it is for the criminal law to get involved in what is very often, ultimately, the fallout of failed relationships,” she said.
Other critics have pointed out that ‘revenge porn’ is just one part of a wider problem which needs addressing in full.
Polly Neate, chief executive of Women’s Aid, argued that if attempts to tackle ‘revenge porn’ are to be meaningful, they must also take account of all other kinds of controlling and abusive behaviour.
“That control is central to domestic violence, which is why we’re campaigning for all psychological abuse and coercive control to be criminalised.
“We urge Mr Grayling and the Home Office to go further, and ensure victims can get the support of the criminal justice system for all the abuse they experience,” she said.
And Sarah Green from the End Violence Against Women Coalition said that victims need a wide range of supportive services including the ability to take their ex-partners to court.
“The impacts of revenge porn can be devastating, from the impact on your everyday life of work and relationships, to the feeling of violation and abuse,” she said, and called for victims to receive support regardless of “whether or not they report to the police”.











