Right To Be Forgotten “unworkable”
But it could be an incredible tool for those who are victims of “revenge porn” or harassment.
The House of Lords has condemned the recent ‘right to be forgotten’ ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) as being ‘wrong in principle’ and ‘unworkable’.
The ruling states that EU citizens should be able to request that search engines remove certain links from their results.
Baroness Prashar, Chairwoman of the House of Lords EU Home Affairs, Health and Education Sub-Committee, said “We believe that the judgment of the Court is unworkable[…]
“It is also wrong in principle to leave search engines themselves the task of deciding whether to delete information or not, based on vague, ambiguous and unhelpful criteria.
“We do not believe that individuals should be able to have links to accurate and lawfully available information about them removed, simply because they do not like what is said.”
The ruling would mean that anyone, including corporations, would be able to ask Google or Bing to take down links to information that they deemed inaccurate.
It is inevitable that some companies are likely to abuse the ruling to take down anything negative about them.
It is already possible for bloggers to be fined for bad reviews.
And earlier this month Google took down a number of news articles from its results – but whether this was to make a point or not remains to be seen.
In some ways, this is a worrying precedent – and yet, it could also be used as an incredible tool for those who are victims of “revenge porn” or harassment.
For such people, making sure others can no longer access explicit content which they did not consent to sharing, or pages that publish their personal information to harass them would be at least some measure of relief.
If the CJEU wish to protect such people, they need to clear up the wording and make sure that individuals, not corporations, are established as the primary beneficiaries.











