Remarks on the budget
Clear need for ‘Plan F’, a feminist strategy for a caring and sustainable economy.
A further £12billion extracted from an already depleted social security budget will undermine the security of women and drive poor families deeper into poverty.
Self evident really.
But this is one of several policies outlined by the newly-elected Conservative government in the Summer Budget presented on 8 July.
And the result will be increased personal debt, a rise in maternal poverty and greater care burdens on women.
The Women’s Budget Group, an independent voluntary organisation bringing together over 200 researchers, policy experts and activists – academics, trade unionists, and people who work for non-governmental organisations – was set up to provide assessments of UK economic and social policy and show the impact of government taxation and expenditure on women’s everyday lives in terms of access to money, jobs, public services and to identify policies that are supportive of gender equality and women’s rights.
Key points raised in the Women’s Budget Group analysis of the recent Budget are:
That the £13billion of cuts in social security spending by 2020/21 will disproportionately hit families and women on low incomes, and the rise in the minimum wage won’t compensate this.
Instead the cuts in working tax credits will decrease work incentives for second earners and widen the gap between benefit recipients and the rest of the population;
That included in the £13billion cut to social security is a reduction in the benefit cap to £23,000 in London and £20,000 elsewhere.
This is going to force more families into debt and rent arrears, many will be forced to leave homes where they have community networks and jobs, and it will disrupt the lives of the poorest children.
The House of Commons Library has already reported that four-fifths of those adults affected by the cap in 2014 were women, many of whom had several children;
Raising taxation is welcome, including cuts in pension tax relief.
However, such measures are partly offset by continued give-aways including: the poorly-targeted and expensive rise in personal tax allowance, the continued freeze in fuel duties and further cuts to corporation tax rates, all of which benefit mostly men as they are more likely higher-income earners and/or shareholders;
Any increase in high quality childcare services is welcome; the pledge of 30 hours a week free childcare for all 3-4 year-olds is a step in the right direction.
However, the policy is restricted to children whose parents are in paid employment.
There is also little detail on how much the government will spend.
If no extra funding is available the policy will simply compound existing problems in childcare provision such as the structural public underfunding of childcare, low availability of childcare places and quality issues; and
The pay rise cap for public sector workers, combined with further cuts in departmental spending yet to be announced, will again affect women disproportionately and threaten employment retention and quality of public services.
The impact of these latest measures – discussed in detail here – must be judged alongside the austerity programme implemented over the last five years.
The Women’s Budget Group also believes the Budget will widen the division between those who gain from Conservative government policies and those who lose from them.
It will increase alreadu high poverty rates for children and women, and decimate vital public services and social infrastructure, to which women make an important contribution.
And as the report concludes, this latest budget is a terrifying move towards permanent austerity, which will in turn have a devastating effect on women’s security.
The Women’s Budget Group also mentioned in their last briefing the budget insufficiently addressed the crisis in both childcare and social care, the burden of which will continue to fall on women.
In short, the need for a radical alternative has become that much more urgent.
During the run up to the 2015 general election the Women’s Budget Group, in partnership with the Scottish Women’s Budget Group, published a manifesto for change called ‘Plan F’, a feminist strategy for a caring and sustainable economy.
To achieve Plan F there must be a shift away from the ideological pursuit of austerity and towards an economic strategy built on investment in social and sustainable physical structure.
This includes investment in social housing, education, health and care.
Caring responsibilities need to be shared through investment in quality public services.
Gender relations in paid and unpaid work must be transformed.
And the economic priority should be on fostering equality, human rights and sustainability.
The Women’s Budget Group explained the details of the Plan F policies in its response to the April budget, and showed how the money could be found:
Cancel plans for Trident – costing £100bn over the next 30 years; reverse tax giveaways – costing about £27bn a year; stop corporate welfare – reportedly worth around £93bn in 2012/13; and retrieve the billions lost in tax avoidance – estimated to cost the Exchequer up to £120bn a year.
By continuing to cut public services and decimate social security, by spending too little on care and other social infrastructure, and by encouraging private debt while chasing a budget surplus, this government is creating a system that undermines the security of women and the poorest in society.
This is unnecessary and wrong, the Women’s Budget Group concluded; Plan F is a more effective and fairer plan for current and future economic security for all.











