Will mandatory reporting close the gender pay gap?
Will the regulations be tight enough?
Last week, the UK government announced plans to force companies with more than 250 employees to publish details of their gender pay gaps.
To be introduced in the first half of 2016, the plan to enforce pay gap reporting is part of David Cameron’s stated goal of ending the gender pay gap within a generation.
This move is long overdue.
As Anoosh Chakelian has pointed out, the UK is behind many other European countries when it comes to mandatory reporting on pay gaps.
At 19.1 per cent, we currently have the sixth-biggest pay gap in the European Union; on average, women in the UK earn 80p for every £1 taken home by men.
While the government is making much of the fact that the current pay gap is the lowest since records began, progress has stagnated in recent times.
There’s been little change in the pay gap during the past five years, and it actually widened in 2012-13.
After pay gap reporting regulations were introduced by Labour’s Harriet Harman to the Equality Act of 2010, the coalition government decided against mandatory enforcement – instead hoping companies would publish information voluntarily.
Only five did so: Tesco, Friends Life, PwC, AstraZeneca and Genesis.
Shadow inequalities minister Gloria De Piero has welcomed the government’s realisation that enforced reporting is required, but called for an additional “annual equal pay check” to assess progress and make further recommendations.
And although the announcement has been widely welcomed, women’s rights groups have raised concerns about the loose wording of the legislation – based on Section 78 of the 2010 Equality Act – which could make it too easy for companies to keep inequalities hidden, and so have questioned how effective the regulations are likely to be in their current form.
The Fawcett Society is calling for more detailed guidelines, requiring companies to publish data such as maximum and minimum salaries by gender for each role; details of bonuses and overtime; and pay gaps by mode, mean and median, to give a fuller picture of what’s happening.
The Fawcett Society’s chair, Belinda Phipps, has pointed out that companies reporting voluntarily have used a comparison of median pay (excluding bonuses/overtime) for each gender – which, she said “doesn’t actually tell you very much at all, and it’s very easy for you to game it.”
The Women’s Budget Group is also calling for greater detail in reporting requirements, while drawing attention to the many underlying issues in urgent need of action.
“More wide-reaching efforts are required to close the gender pay gap, including tackling the congregation of women in low-paid sectors such as care and beauty and the lack of high-paid jobs that are also part time or flexible to fit around caring responsibilities,” said the Group’s Polly Trenow.
She also highlighted the need to tackle “maternity discrimination and other issues which see women returning to salaries around 5 per cent lower after having children.”
While enforcement will commence in the first half of 2016, it is believed businesses may have up to two years from now in which to investigate their own current pay gaps – and start to implement positive changes – before publishing their figures.
The government’s open consultation on Closing the Gender Pay Gap, now under way, will consider what data companies are required to provide, as well as the details of how and when this will be achieved.
The consultation is open for input until 6 September 2015: to have your say, click here.











