subscribe: Posts | Comments

Child First campaign launched

0 comments

Child first, domestic abuse, court cases, campaign launch, Women's AidThere is a misguided belief that, because a relationship has ended, so has the domestic abuse.

The national domestic abuse charity Women’s Aid has launched a major new campaign, Child First which calls on the family courts and the Government to put the safety of children back at the heart of all decisions made by the family court judiciary.

Child First was launched alongside the report, Nineteen Child Homicides.

Nineteen Child Homicides reviewed relevant serious case reviews for England and Wales, published between January 2005 and August 2015.

It uncovered details of 19 children in 12 families who were killed by perpetrators of domestic abuse. All of the perpetrators were men and fathers to the children that they killed.

All of the perpetrators had access to their children through formal or informal child contact arrangements.

The report tells the stories of the cases of nineteen children, all intentionally killed by a parent who was also a known perpetrator of domestic abuse.

These killings were made possible through unsafe child contact arrangements, formal and informal.

Over half of these child contact arrangements were ordered through the courts.

Key statistics from Nineteen Child Homicides: 19 children killed from 12 families; 2 mothers killed, 2 children seriously harmed through attempted murder – and for 7 out of the 12 families, the contact had been ordered through court.

Polly Neate, chief executive of Women’s Aid, said: “There is a misguided belief within the family courts and among judges that, because a relationship has ended, so has the domestic abuse.

“Survivors frequently report to us that they and their children are re-victimised and traumatised by their abusers, even after separation, through the family court process.

“This trauma makes it extremely difficult for the non-abusive parent to advocate clearly and effectively for the safety of their child.

“In the criminal courts, there are protection measures in place to give victims fair access to justice.

“This is not the case in the family courts. For example, it is common for victims of domestic abuse to be cross-examined by the perpetrator. This must end.

“The desire by the family courts to treat parents in exactly the same way, and get cases over with quickly, blinds them to the consequences of unsafe child contact.

“As the report Nineteen Child Homicides shows, these consequences can be fatal.

“The culture of, ‘contact with the child, no matter what’, must end.

“Less than 1 per cent of child contact applications are refused, but we know that domestic abuse features in around 70 per cent of CAFCASS caseloads, and in 70-90 per cent of cases going to the family courts.

“Clearly, the system is failing.

“The best interests of children should be the overriding principle of the family courts, but far too often this is simply not the case.”

Women’s Aid is urging the government and family courts to undertake two key recommendations made by the Nineteen Child Homicides report, in order to protect children and their non-abusive parent, and to stop any further avoidable child deaths.

These form the two campaign asks of Child First:

1) Further avoidable child deaths must be prevented by putting children first in the family courts – as the legal framework and guidance states.

Ensure that domestic abuse is identified and its impact fully considered by the family court judiciary.

Child contact arrangement orders must put the best interests of the child(ren) first and protect the well-being of the parent the child is living with, in accordance with ‘Practice direction 12 J Child arrangements & Contact order: Domestic violence and harm’.

There is an urgent need for independent, national oversight into the implementation of Practice Direction 12J.

2) Make the family courts fit for purpose through the introduction of protection measures for survivors of domestic abuse

Ensure survivors of domestic abuse attending the family court have access to protection measures, similar to those available in criminal courts.

Survivors of domestic abuse should always have access to a separate waiting room or area, and judges must ensure there is time for the non-abusive parent to leave court safely before releasing the perpetrator.

For, as Lord Justice Wall, said in 2006; “It is, in my view, high time that the Family Justice System abandoned any reliance on the proposition that a man can have a history of violence to the mother of his children but, nonetheless, be a good father.”

Claire Throssell, the mother of Jack and Paul, who were both killed by their father in 2014, said: “No parent should have to hold their children and comfort them as they die, or be told that their child has been harmed in an act of revenge or rage.

“Having experienced the family court judicial process and its protocols, the tragic outcome that occurred – whilst court proceedings were still ongoing – exposes flaws and malpractice within family law.

“All too often children’s voices are not heard or acted upon.

“Attending court is an emotional, frightening and at times a traumatic experience which nobody decides to initiate lightly – but does so to protect their children’s physical and emotional wellbeing.”

To find out more about the campaign click here.

To download the report, click here.

To sign the Child First petition clcik here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *