subscribe: Posts | Comments

Gender identity questions in schools

0 comments

SRE, trans, gender issues in schools, ATL conference“There’s an attitude of ignore it and it’ll go away.”

Although more and more pupils are raising issues around their gender identity, there is some concern that schools and colleges are not adequately prepared to support and educate young people.

But last month education staff were able to voice their concerns about the lack of meaningful, informed discussion surrounding gender identity in schools.

Julia Neal, the deputy director of a sixth form in Devon, proposed a motion about these concerns be debated at the Association of Teachers and Lecturers’ (ATL) annual conference, because she was concerned about how unprepared schools were.

She said: “We are not addressing the issues effectively in many schools and colleges. I want to emphasise the need for specialist training for senior managers and governors.

“Leaders need to be prepared to guide staff and support young people.”

Jill was one of three ATL members who told their stories to highlight the issues staff and students are facing.

Jill was an assistant head teacher at an independent school when she transitioned.

“There’s an attitude of ignore it and it’ll go away. The excuses have to be removed.

“When I transitioned I was tolerated, partially because I was essential to the functioning of the school and also because I was politically astute about the situation – I did everything I could to minimise the impact and prevent controversy.

“I provided training to senior staff and the deputy head then trained all staff.

“The problem was this was reduced to statutory Equality Act guidance, with no real explanation of LGBT or protected characteristics. Any LGBT colleagues and pupils were really no better off.

“For example it didn’t stop some colleagues making jokes to each other and to pupils.

“Some schools are doing a really great job. They’ve made trans their ‘thing’. But by and large there is an attitude of, ‘If we leave it alone, it’ll go away, there’s no one like that here, this doesn’t apply to us.’ The vast majority of schools think they can ignore it.

“The fact SRE [Sex and Relationships Education] isn’t compulsory is a big issue. SRE is often well meaning but not well informed.

“Trans is usually not covered and when it is, it is often confused as an issue of sexuality not gender.

“Trans should be addressed and not just in a statutory sense, for example noting inclusion in the Equality Act, but with SRE.

“Trusted information needs to be available for young people. There is so much negativity and misconceptions in the press and online.

“Very few schools support LGBT History Month, which would be a positive move.

“Staff need training delivered by trans specialist groups.

“Crucially Department for Education [DfE] support is needed. Without their direction schools are too able to ignore it. The excuses have to be removed and education must provide an understanding of this protected group.

“We can’t keep producing generations of misinformed children.”

A motion ‘challenging gender identity prejudice in education’ was proposed by Julia Neal, Equality and Diversity Committee; and seconded by Nic Preston, Equality and Diversity Committee:

‘That Conference deplores the paucity of meaningful and informed discussion of gender identity and trans issues within schools and colleges.

‘Young people with questions about or an interest in gender identity have very few reliable sources with which to counter the factually incorrect, prejudicial and abusive messages that often prevail in social media, traditional media and on the internet.

Conference therefore calls upon the Executive Committee to:
(i) provide information to help members support young people to explore identity issues in a safe environment;
(ii) campaign for specific funding for staff to be trained by specialist organisations to support their students;
(iii) lobby Government to ensure that all schools and colleges provide specific training for all leadership teams and governors in supporting all their staff;
(iv) promote Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans History Month (LGBT HM), using it to challenge gender stereotypes and celebrate trans role models.

Dr Mary Bousted, general secretary of the Association of Teachers and Lecturers (ATL), said: “We welcome increased discussion around gender identity and want to support young people, but that requires well-trained teachers, delivering well-informed and inclusive Sex and Relationships Education.

“As education staff we want to support those young people to feel confident and to get the expert help and advice they need to flourish.

“Let’s not leave young people to educate themselves on these issues via misconceptions and bigotry so often found in the media and online.

“Trans issues present yet more impetus on the call for Nicky Morgan to reverse her decision and make SRE mandatory for all students.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *