subscribe: Posts | Comments

How women be councillors studied

0 comments

Milton Keynes Fawcett Society, observations, women councillors, recommendationsSignificant gender differences in the participation of male and female councillors were observed.

In 2015 Milton Keynes members of the Fawcett Society undertook an observational study of Milton Keynes Council meetings in order to explore whether there were gender differences and/or inequalities in the way council business was seen to be carried out in public forums.

In their ensuing report they analysed the data collected and concluded that it shows significant gender differences in the participation of male and female councillors at Milton Keynes Council meetings.

They therefore recommend that there should be more engagement by all political groups in Milton Keynes to encourage more women to enter local politics as councillors; all political groups need to offer support for women councillors once they are elected to ensure they are able to engage fully with all aspects of Council work; and that there is a need for changes in meeting behaviour so that there is a better representation of all voices present.

The news media and most campaigning groups – see for example the 50:50 Parliament campaign and the Women’s Equality Party – have focused on the lack of women at a national level.

The Fawcett Society nationally is concerned about the lack of engagement of women in politics.

But Fawcett is also concerned about women’s representation at the local level and has encouraged members to explore the situation in their local areas and support women as voters, activists and elected representatives of all parties to engage more.

Engagement in local politics is seen as important both in its own right and because it can serve as the entry stage for individuals who later go into national politics.

At the time of the study roughly one third of Milton Keynes councillors were women.

In two main areas of council business Milton Keynes’ Fawcett members observed major gender differences in distribution of roles and activities and participation in meetings.

However, they were not evenly distributed over all Council committees.

Women councillors were over-represented in committees in traditionally ‘female’ areas: corporate parenting, health and adult social care, health and well-being.

They were under-represented in traditionally ‘male’ areas: audit and budget scrutiny.

It has been argued that experience of finance and planning does women rise to the most senior roles in local government.

At a variety of meetings they observed a consistent under-participation of women councillors both as speakers (in proportion to their numbers present i.e. using Fawcett’s parity measure) and in the number of interventions they made compared with male speakers (using the parity measure)

Of the three Full Council meetings observed, for example, women councillors made up 33 per cent of those councillors present in the meeting but women councillors made only 19 per cent of all interventions made by councillors.

They also noted when officers or members of the public spoke: women made only 20 per cent of all the formal interventions in the chamber.

And male councillors were much more likely to make more than one intervention.

Male councillors often engaged in friendly, cross-party ‘banter’ – something observed across in all three Full Council meetings. This gives a strong sense of ‘ownership’ of the debate and shared history. It was never observed among women.

Male councillors often read prepared ‘speeches’ that contained party political statements and did not always seem to contribute directly to the debate. Women were not seen doing this.

Women seemed sometimes more hesitant or diffident in their interventions, prefacing an intervention with statements such as: ‘I apologise if I’ve not read the papers correctly’; ‘I don’t understand – maybe I’m missing something’; ‘I’m just learning’ for example.

With women so thinly spread in the committees, their absence from a meeting could mean there was no female voice at all, and even when women were in the majority in the meeting men dominated the debate.

Recommendations:

1 – Local political parties should examine who is given roles on council committees and groups and look for ways to give positions of responsibility to more women.

2 – Local political parties should offer additional support to women who are new members of committees and groups, to improve their confidence and ability to carry out their roles.

3 – Some male councillors should review their behaviour in public meetings in order to ensure that they are making space for less experienced and less confident colleagues: men as well as women.

4 – Female councillors should make greater efforts to make interventions in discussion in public meetings; their constituents would not expect them to engage less on their behalf than a male councillor.

5 – Female councillors should take the training opportunities offered by their political parties to build their confidence and develop their skills.

6 – Local political groups should consider strategies to encourage more women to stand for election as Councillors.

The objective of the study was not simply to describe what was observed but to use these observations to help members of the Council and others understand the nature of any gender differences in observed behaviours and use this to help inform plans to support women to engage in local politics – in particular as Milton Keynes councillors.

However, the Fawcett members reported, they feel that council meetings that are open to the public are also a forum where members of the public observe the behaviour of councillors; what is observed can then encourage or deter people from deciding if they want to put themselves forward for elected positions.

This is a very welcome report. To read the whole paper, click here.

WVoN thoroughly backs Fawcett’s suggestion that other women throughout the country carry out such observations as well as ascertaining from either their own observation or surveys or other people’s research what actually is stopping women from standing. Childcare of course is probably still one example.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *