subscribe: Posts | Comments

No safe refuge in the UK for LGBT people

0 comments

No Safe Refuge, LGBT asylum seekers in UK detention, Stonewall, UKLGIGLGBT claimants have said they are treated like criminals when seeking refuge in Britain.

Consensual sexual acts between same-sex adults are criminalised in 72 United Nations member states, and only 50 countries recognise trans people’s rights to have their gender identity legally recognised.

In countries that criminalise same-sex relationships, or fail to protect LGBT people, they face persecution, discrimination and violence.

Or put another way: in many countries lesbian, gay, bi or trans people face significant levels of violence and discrimination; in 72 countries sex with someone of the same sex is still illegal, and in some of those countries, people face the death penalty because of who they love.

People who face persecution on the basis of their real or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity can claim asylum in Britain, where ‘UK Visas and Immigration’, part of the Home Office, is responsible for managing asylum claims.

But LGBT claimants have said they feel that they are treated like criminals when seeking refuge in Britain.

Having experienced abuse, torture and persecution in their country of origin, many are placed in detention when they get to the UK, even though seeking asylum is not a crime.

And they can find themselves placed in detention at any time during the course of their asylum-claiming process.

Seeking asylum is not a crime; it is a right enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

And yet over the past 20 years the scale of this kind of detention in the UK has expanded rapidly, as Paul Dillane from the UK Lesbian and Gay Immigration Group (UKLGIG) explained in the foreword of Stonewall’s most recent report on this issue, No Safe Refuge.

Until last year the UK was alone in Europe in operating the Detained Fast Track (DFT), a large-scale detained process where asylum claims were determined on a highly accelerated basis: in a matter of days.

The UK has one of the largest detention estates in Europe, and detains more migrants and asylum seekers than the vast majority of other countries.

Shockingly, it is also alone in detaining them indefinitely.

Indefinitely.

In July 2015, the High Court found that this process was ‘systemically unfair and unlawful’ – and the UK government has consistently stated its intention to introduce a new detaining procedure.

In March 2015, the cross-party Parliamentary Inquiry into the Use of Immigration Detention delivered a damning verdict and reported that the UK detains far too many people for far too long.

It recommended that the UK introduce a legal limit on the length of time that migrants can be detained as part of a radical overhaul of the entire detention system.

The Detention Inquiry also expressed serious concerns about the hidden abuses against LGBT people.

Between November 2015 and March 2016, Stonewall and UKLGIG conducted 22 in-depth interviews with lesbian, gay, bi and trans (LGBT) asylum seekers.

Participants from 11 different countries in Asia, Africa, the Caribbean as well as Russia, were asked about their experience with staff and other detainees, their physical and emotional well-being while in detention and their access to legal and health services.

The resulting report, No Safe Refuge, reflects the diverse experiences LGBT asylum seekers faced.

The research also found that LGBT asylum seekers are particularly vulnerable and face significant disadvantages when detained.

In detention they experienced discrimination and harassment from other detainees as well as from some members of staff, and the detention environment has had serious long-term effects on their mental and physical well-being.

Those who were open about their sexual orientation or gender identity often experienced harassment and abuse from other detainees. And detention staff failed to protect LGBT asylum seekers from abuse.

Staff often lack basic understanding of LGBT issues and even display discriminatory attitudes towards LGBT detainees. Some reported discrimination from staff.

Many felt forced to hide their sexual orientation and gender identity while in detention as they feared bullying and discrimination.

Trans asylum seekers face particular threats of violence in detention.

They face particular danger in having to share bedrooms and communal showers with other detainees.

One trans interviewee reported being placed in multiple male detention centres, even though she made it known that she identifies as a woman.

And LGBT asylum seekers said they could not fairly pursue their legal claim while being detained.

They are required to collect detailed evidence to ‘prove’ their sexual orientation and gender identity. Due to a lack of privacy and resources, LGBT asylum seekers are gravely disadvantaged when fulfilling these requirements while in detention.

Detention has serious ill-effects on the mental health of LGBT claimants, as the challenging and unsafe detention environment causes constant stress and severe anxiety. As a result of this, depression, self-harm and suicide attempts were reported by most interviewees.

Medical treatment fails to meet the particular needs of LGBT detainees.

Lack of experience with LGBT issues and discriminatory attitudes from health care staff made it difficult for LGBT people to speak openly about their health concerns and receive the treatment and medication they required.

Health care staff are not equipped to respond to the specific needs of trans people.

Trans detainees often can not continue their transition, which leads not only to emotional distress but also has a direct effect on their mental and physical well-being.

LGBT asylum seekers found it difficult to settle back into society after their experiences of detention.

Many described experiencing severe mental health issues, isolation, discrimination and financial hardship post-detention.

They are often excluded or feel unable to access diaspora or LGBT communities and therefore miss out on the support those community networks could provide.

And as Ruth Hunt said in her foreword to the No Safe Refuge report, ‘Stonewall is working with international activists so that people do not have to live with the daily threat of violence and discrimination.

‘But while LGBT people are forced to seek asylum, we urgently need to address the system in the UK that’s meant to support them.

‘That means the Home Office working with civil society organisations, advocates and other influencers like the All Party Parliamentary Group on Global LGBT rights to address the serious concerns raised in this report.

‘We need to ensure that when LGBT people reach the UK they are finally free to be themselves,’ she said.

Yes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *