subscribe: Posts | Comments

No to parallel legal systems

0 comments

women object to parallel legal systems in the UKWe oppose any religious body – whether presided over by men or women – that seeks to rule over us.

Over 300 abused women, mostly of Muslim and other minority faiths, have issued a statement announcing their objections to the use of parallel legal systems based on fundamentalist religious codes in the UK.

The House of Common’s Home Affairs Committee launched an inquiry into Sharia councils operating in the UK in June this year.

The Committee was to examine how Sharia councils operate in practice, their work resolving family and divorce disputes and their relationship with the British legal system.

Debate on the subject has thus far overwhelmingly focused on religious identity politics rather than women’s rights and access to justice.

The Select Committee appears to have chosen not to hear from witnesses experienced in front line advocacy work with BME women – work which has necessarily involved the invocation of human rights and equalities legislation to challenge Sharia laws.

It has also not asked to hear from women who refuse to use Sharia Courts ‘out of fear and distrust arising from their own negative experiences of religious control in their communities’.

These and other concerns regarding the treatment of witnesses were raised in a letter to MP Yvette Cooper in November.

More recently, Pragna Patel, from Southhall Black Sisters, writing in the Guardian, said: ‘The experiences of these women tell us that the entrenchment of sharia councils and parallel legal systems within minority communities creates a space for the perpetuation of patriarchal control and harm to women, children and others perceived to be apostates, atheists and nonconformists.

‘Secular feminist spaces – the long fought for and now beleaguered refuges and advocacy centres – are their best hope of accessing justice.

‘Secular – not religious – spaces provide vulnerable minority women with alternatives to violence, isolation and fear, creating opportunities to build solidarity based on need and not religious or communal identity.’

The evidence and testimonies gathered from such women were submitted to the home affairs select committee by Southall Black Sisters and the Sisters’ coalition partners as part of the One Law for All campaign which calls for:

the UK government to recognise that Sharia and all religious laws are arbitrary and discriminatory against women and children in particular. Citizenship and human rights are non-negotiable;

an end to all Sharia courts and religious tribunals on the basis that they work against and not for equality and human rights; and

that the law be amended so that all religious tribunals are banned from operating within and outside of the legal system.

Women who have been affected by this system have – so far – not been listened to, so they published a full statement on the subject in openDemocracy on 14 December, saying:

‘We oppose any religious body – whether presided over by men or women – that seeks to rule over us: because they do not have any authority to speak or make decisions on our behalf and because they are not committed to women’s rights and social justice.

Whether we are women of Muslim, Hindu, Sikh or Christian faiths or of no faith, we have much in common with each other in the face of cruelty, tyranny and discrimination in our families, in our communities, and in the wider society.

Many of us are deeply religious, but for us religion is in our hearts: a private matter between us and our God. Religion is not – and must not be – something that can be used to deny us our freedom or the little pieces of happiness that we find by mixing and borrowing from many different traditions and cultures which give meaning to our otherwise difficult existence.

We know from personal experiences that many religious bodies such as Sharia Councils are presided over by hard line or fundamentalist clerics who are intolerant of the very idea that women should be in control of their own bodies and minds.

These clerics claim to be acting according to the word of God: but they are often corrupt, primarily interested in making money and abuse their positions of power by shaming and slandering those of us who reject those aspects of our religions and cultures that we find oppressive.

We pay a huge price for not submitting to domestic violence, rape, polygamy and child abuse and other kinds of harm.

For this reason alone, we are fearful of religious laws and rulings from such bodies.

Our experience in our countries of origin and in our communities tells us that they are deeply discriminatory and divisive.

They will weaken our collective struggles for security and independence.

We struggle to fit into this country and to educate our children, especially our daughters, and to protect them and give them a better life.

We struggle to have our experiences of violence and abuse addressed properly in accordance with the principles of equality and justice for all.

We do not wish to be judged by reference to fundamentalist codes that go against our core values of compassion, tolerance and humanity.

We do not want to go backwards or to be delivered back into the hands of our abusers and those who shield them.

We do not want Sharia Councils or other religious bodies to rule our lives.

We demand the right to be valued as human beings and as equals before one law for all.

We demand the right to follow our own desires and aspirations.’

Three hundred women have signed this so far, some using only their first names to avoid recognition – having fled domestic violence, for example. Some are the sisters of women who died in so-called honour killings, and some have survived Sharia Court abuses.

To read their names, click here.

Any women who are either a victim of violence and abuse or concerned about the issues mentioned, are invited to join the 300 signatories; to make your voice be heard, click here to add your name to the statement.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *